Abstract
Lipids have tremendously transformed the biomedical field, especially in the last few decades. Nanosystems, especially Lipid nanocapsules (LNCs), have emerged as the most demanding nanovehicle systems for delivering drugs, genes, and other diagnostic agents. Unique attributes and characteristic features such as higher encapsulation efficiency, stealth effect, ability to solubilize a wide range of drugs, capability to inhibit P-gp efflux pumps, and higher stability play a vital role in engaging this nanosystem. LNCs are a lipid-based nano-drug delivery method that combines the most significant traits of liposomes with polymeric nanoparticles. Structurally, LNCs have an oily core consisting of medium and long triglycerides and an aqueous phase encased in an amphiphilic shell. This manuscript crosstalks LNCs for various biomedical applications. A detailed elaboration of the structural composition, methods of preparation, and quality control aspects has also been attained, with particular emphasis on application approaches, ongoing challenges, and their possible resolution. The manuscript also expounds the preclinical data and discusses the patents atlas of LNCs to assist biomedical scientists working in this area and foster additional research.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction to Nanomedicines and Nanotechnology
Nanotechnology and nanoscience have enormously impacted the advancement of the world. Nanotechnology has emerged as one of the most significant scientific breakthroughs of the twenty-first century [1, 2]. Nanotechnology is growing increasingly due to its versatile potential applications in material science, engineering, computing, biotechnology, and even the pharmaceutical realm [1, 3]. Nanoscience is an amalgamation of physics, material science, and biology. It focuses on manipulating materials at the molecular and atomic scales.
In contrast, nanotechnology is the capacity to understand, measure, customize, establish, govern, and fabricate a subject matter at the nanometer scale [4]. The National Nanotechnology Initiative (NNI) of the United States describes nanotechnology as "a science, engineering, and technology conducted at the nanoscale (1 to 100 nm), wherein special phenomena allow novel applications in a wide range of fields, from chemistry, physics, and biology to medicine, engineering, and electronics" [5]. Nanotechnology is no longer a new concept; it has existed since the fourth century AD [6]. The American physicist and Nobel prize laureate Richard Feynman introduced nanotechnology in 1959. Richard Feynman described the hypothesis and vision of creating smaller machines and forming molecular levels using devices and technology in that concept. For that idea and demonstration, he was recognized as the Father of Nanotechnology [1, 7].
In the pharmaceutical and biomedical realm, nanotechnology has gained more scientific attention than diagnosis, prevention, and treatment [8, 9]. Nanomedicine, a developing field formed by blending nanotechnology with medicine, is one of the most promising routes for developing efficient therapies [10]. At present, nanotechnology-based medicine is focused on improved and precise treatment, minimal adverse effects/toxicity, and unmet medical needs of patients [2]. As time moved on, nanomedicines were designed based on the need for such characteristics and functions to exhibit biodegradability, biocompatibility, no or minimal toxicity, non-immunogenic, easy preparation, and high drug loading efficiency [11]. Subsequently, nanomedicines were known by other names as well as nanocarriers, nanosystems, nano-ghost, nano-vesicles, nano-composites, nano-complex, nano-scaffold, nano-matrix, nanosensors, nanoparticles and nanocapsules [12].
The transition of nanomedicines over conventional medicines is because of the outstanding benefits offered by nanomedicines, such as enhanced efficacy, safety, physicochemical characteristics, and pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic (PK/PD) profiles of pharmaceutical substances [13]. Increased frequent administration, toxicity, low solubility, and instability of drugs are significant concerns allied with conventional drug delivery that can be augmented using nanomedicines [2].
To date, countless nanomedicines have been developed and widely accepted in clinical and non-clinical applications [13]. Lipid-based nanosystems have presented new avenues to the pharmaceutical industry due to their characteristic structure and capability in drug delivery. The key factors that support their success in the field of superlative drug delivery over conventional drug delivery are ideal physicochemical characteristics, the ability to transport macromolecules (i.e., proteins, peptides, oligonucleotide, and DNA), offering high bioavailability, administered via numerous sites, built-in capacity to triumph over the blood–brain barrier, etc. [14]. Lipid-based nanosystems such as liposomes, solid lipid nanocarrier, lipoplex, nanostructured lipid carriers, and LNCs have shown noteworthy work by encapsulating small molecular weight phytochemical drugs and macromolecular likes identify RNA (iRNA), plasmid DNA, peptide and protein [15, 16]. In 1995, the first “nano-drug” Doxil (Liposome) received FDA approval for the treatment of AIDS-related Kaposi’s sarcoma and earned approximately $600 million in yearly sales across all of its markets [17].
By 2022, 21 lipid-based nanomedicines will be approved globally for different diseases, including vaccine delivery [11, 18]. However, significant drawbacks (i.e., use of organic solvents, instability in biological fluids) and the development of a non-toxic, solvent-free, low-energy process and stable vector that can encapsulate and deliver the drug as well genetic materials to the target cell have transformed towards LNCs [19,20,21].
This review will express the view of nanotechnology and nanoscience in the pharmaceutical research industry and the significance of nanosystems in advancing nanomedicines. Also, the importance and trends of LNCs in drug and gene delivery can be analyzed by exploiting their mechanism in efficient delivery. In addition, it will guide the merits of LNCs and possible approaches for drug delivery, gene delivery, and drug-gene hybrid delivery of various drugs and biomolecules. Here, we have summarised the functional superiority of LNCs over other nanocarrier systems.
Lipid Nanocapsules and their Biomedical Benefits
Lipid and polymeric nanoparticles have been controversial for a long time for the delivery of a vast range of drugs and biomolecules [12]. In a nutshell, nanocapsules can be defined as a vesicular system in a range of 50-300 nm, where a drug or active moiety is confined in the inner cavity (liquid/solid), which is layered by the polymeric coating [8, 22]. In general, LNCs have an oily core formed primarily of a medium chain triglyceride encompassing capric and caprylic acids, which is encased by a surfactant shell composed of a pegylated surfactant and lecithin or other lipophilic co-surfactants [23]. LNCs are produced using generally regarded as safe (GRAS) and FDA-approved components that support inertness, non-toxic, non-immunogenic, biocompatible, biodegradable, and cost-effective [24,25,26] (Figs. 1 and 2).
In addition, they are smaller in size and possess large surface area, broad drug-loading features, and high specificity to the target site. These characteristics make them suitable nanocarriers for the transport of drugs and genes [27]. Owing to their structures and function, they are also known as bio-nanocapsules, nano-cargo, nano-vectors [28], and biomimetic nanocarriers [29, 30]. LNCs can be manufactured swiftly, without organic solvents, and at scale, and their characteristics can be tailored for the best possible form for drug delivery [26]. The salient feature of LNCs is mentioned in Fig. 3. LNCs consist of a lipid core and a tension-active shell, and the lipid core allows for the dispersion of drugs (hydrophilic, lipophilic, or amphiphilic) or adsorbed at the interface of capsules [31]. So far, several researchers have investigated LNCs as novel carriers for topical, transdermal [31, 32], intradermal [33], nose-to-brain [34] central nervous system (CNS) delivery [26] for different disease by encapsulating drugs, peptides and DNA (Fig. 2).
Groo et al. utilized LNCs nanocarriers to deliver encapsulated antimicrobial peptide-loaded reverse micelle (RMs-AMP) against infectious diseases. The study's primary objective was preserving antimicrobial activity and efficient antimicrobial peptide (AMP) delivery of AMPs (AP138) through LNCs. RM-LNCs were developed using the phase inversion temperature method to incorporate AMP-loaded reverse micelles. Further, AMPs-loaded LNCs were evaluated for antimicrobial activity, and it was found that AP138 was efficiently encapsulated in the LNCs, which showed preserved antimicrobial activity and resistance against protease. LNCs not only shielded peptides from proteolytic enzymes but also enhanced the antimicrobial activity of peptides [29]. Zhai et al. developed the novel ropivacaine-loaded LNCs (RPV-LNCs) with a mean particle size of 62.1 ± 1.7 nm and evaluated RPV-LNCs, and transdermal delivery potential. Mice models were used for transdermal delivery of RPV-LNCs. Topical application of RPV-LNCs showed enhanced permeability as compared to propylene glycol. They proved that LNCs can modulate stratum corneum. Hence, LNCs could be used as promising nanocarriers for transdermal delivery [31].
The oral route is considered the most convenient route for drug administration and is widely accepted by patients. However, drugs with low bioavailability, solubility, low intestinal permeability, enzymatic degradation, and mucosal instability affect the drug’s efficacy. For this reason, LNCs are considered promising techniques for enhancing oral drug delivery [35]. Mucus is a multifaceted biological fluid layered over the eyes, lungs, nasal tract, vagina, and gastrointestinal tract, that mainly lubricates and forms a protective layer on organ surfaces. However, the mucus layer has been noted as a barrier for the exogenous substances, including peptides and drugs like paclitaxel (PTX), affecting their physicochemical properties and hindering pharmacological responses. Groo et al. investigated the interaction between intestinal mucus and PTX/PTX-loaded LNCs for improved oral drug delivery. PTX-loaded LNCs were prepared following the original method, and DiI and DiD were also incorporated with PTX-LNCs for imaging tracking fluorescent substances.
Further, different formulations of Taxol® (Standard PTX formulation) and PTX-loaded LNCs were studied for transport using pig’s intestinal mucus in the Transwell® diffusion system. They demonstrated that LNCs have considerably amended PTX transport in the mucus layer than Taxol® and also presented that PTX-loaded LNCs showed more extended stability under the mucus layer. These findings stated that LNCs are suitable nano vectors for oral delivery of biopharmaceutical classification system class IV (BCS-IV) drugs, including PTX [28]. Numerous advantages of LNCs loaded or coated with peptides and drugs are presented in Table 1.
Unique Architectural Features of Lipid Nanocapsules
LNCs are bio-inspired nanocarriers with an architecture that is a cross between polymeric nanoparticles and liposomes. Long or Medium-chain triglycerides make up the oily core of LNCs, which is encased in a surfactant shell formed of a PEGylated surfactant and lecithin or other co-surfactants (Fig. 2.) [10]. In a recent investigation, Urimi et al. used cryo-TEM, small-angle X-ray (SAXS), and neutron scattering (SANS) techniques to clarify the structure of LNCs developed using the phase-inversion approach. Further, combined analysis of Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), Small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), and cryo-TEM data revealed the presence of a core–shell system in the LNCs. Additionally, the drug loading had an insignificant effect on the LNCs’s overall core–shell structure. According to SANS data, the core size remained constant for unloaded LNCs and LNCs loaded with drugs (Fig. 3.).
LNCs comprise an oily phase, an aqueous phase, and a nonionic surfactant (Table 2). The oily phase is a blend of medium and long-chain triglycerides serving as the base for lipophilic substances, while aqueous and surfactant play a vital role in the stabilization and dispersion medium (Figs. 4 and 5).
Oily Phase
Most LNCs' components are liquid oils, whereas the shell comprises solid lipids with an oily phase that serves as a drug reservoir. The primary elements of this phase are medium-chain triglycerides, including capric acid, caprylic acid, and triglycerides (Labrafac® WR 1349). Compared to long-chain triglycerides, medium-chain triglycerides are distinguished by a more profound solvent capacity for hydrophilic molecules, GRAS status, good self-dispersibility, and higher stability [36]. On top of that, medium-chain triglycerides function as penetration boosters. There are lipids such as ethyl oleate, isopropyl myristate, Miglyol®, and Captex® 8000 (glyceryl tricaprylate), as well as some vegetable oils, notably castor oil, soybean, olive oil, and sesame oil are also used. [37].
Surfactants: Lipophilic and Nonionic
A prominent lipophilic surfactant used in LNCs is lecithin. It is a phosphatide that exists in both plants and animals. Lecithin is a complex compound made up of phosphatidyl esters such as phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylinositol, and phosphatidylserine as well as additional elements like carbohydrates, fats, and triglycerides. Lecithin is derived from eggs, soy beans, sunflowers, and lysolecithin. It is also available commercially under brand names such as phospholipon® and Lipoid®. Phospholipon® is a blend of natural hydrogenated lecithin and phospholipids that serve as compound lipid and establishes the important elements of the plasma membrane [38]. Lipoid® S75-3 is the most widely utilized lipophilic surfactant, which includes 69% phosphatidylcholine soybean lecithin and functions as a co-surfactant. It is used in modest amounts to considerably boost LNCs stability, which is especially important in the case of lower-size (50-100 nm) LNCs. It is also known as amphiphilic co-surfactant. The amount of lecithin present in composition directly relates to the thickness and hardness of the outer shell. [39].
The phase inversion of an emulsion depends significantly on nonionic surfactants, polyethylene glycol (PEG) chain is likely to impact the temperature needed for the inversion. The most frequently used nonionic surfactant is Solutol® HS 15, which can be found under the brand term Kolliphor HS 15. It is a polyglycol ester of 12-hydroxystearic acid and PEG. Amphiphilic characteristics are added to Solutol® by the hydrophilic PEG combined with hydrophobic hydroxy stearate [40]. Consequently, it has considerable surface activity and affects the triglyceride/water interface. In LNCs, the ratio of Solutol® to total particle size is inversely proportional. Other nonionic surfactants from vegetable oils, especially hydrogenated Cremophor EL (ethoxylated castor oil), Cremophor RH40, and PH60 (ethoxylated hydrogenated castor oil), have been discovered for use in LNCs.
Water
Water is a commonly used solvent in the preparation of LNCs and has a significant role in forming, stabilizing, and functionalizing lipid nanocarriers [41]. The water ration in LNCs maintains hydration around the shell and the integrity of the hydrophilic shell. In addition, it acts as a continuous phase or dispersion medium for hydrophobic or lipid molecules during the emulsification process and prevents aggregation. The aqueous environment within LNCs makes it more biocompatible [40, 42].
Sodium Chloride (NaCl)
In developing LNCs, sodium chloride is often employed at a concentration of 1.75 percent. The phase inversion zone, where the W/O emulsion transforms into an O/W emulsion, shifts from higher to lower temperatures by adjusting the NaCl concentration (1–5%) before dilution [36].
Manufacturing Techniques and Quality Control Attributes of LNCs
Researchers have developed and utilized several approaches to prepare and characterize LNCs. The preparation approaches are solvent-free phase inversion method/ phase inversion method and emulsion-diffusion solvent evaporation. The phase inversion method/ phase inversion Technique is approach is based on the characteristic property that allows typical nonionic surfactants, such PEG surfactants, to change their affinity for oil and water depending on temperature [43]. As the temperature rises, heat agitation causes hydrogen bonds between water molecules and oxide groups to break, eventually leading the PEG moiety's ethylene oxide groups to dry, enabling the lipophilic property of nonionic surfactants to predominate. Accordingly, the system is a continuous micro-emulsion when the balance between lipophilicity and hydrophilicity appears in the phase inversion zone (PIZ). It is abruptly broken up by a rapid cooling step, promptly developing a nanoemulsion of small droplets constituting the LNCs [26, 44, 45].
In 1969, Shinoda and Saito introduced the Phase inversion method. This method is being adapted due to it is low-energy emulsification technique, which includes no use of hazardous organic solvent (chloroform or dichloromethane) that needs to be removed after production and producing very small nanocapsules by thermally manipulating an oil/water mixture [45].
In this method, an aqueous phase comprising sodium chloride and distilled water was combined with the oily phase (i.e., Labrafac®). The hydrophilic surfactant, such as Solutol® HS 15 and Lipoid®, which contains 69% phosphatidylcholine soya bean lecithin in modest quantities to significantly improve LNCs stability, was added to the system and heated under magnetic stirring at 85 °C, ensuring that the phase inversion temperature is attained. W/O emulsion will form once the temperature reaches 85 °C, and O/W emulsion will follow when the temperature drops to 60 °C at a rate of 4 °C/min. Phase inversion is then achieved by applying three temperature cycles (85–60-85–60–85 C). To create an o/w emulsion, the created emulsion is next quickly chilled by dilution with cold water (0 °C) [44]. A rapid alteration in temperature causes an abrupt shock that breaks the micro-emulsion system. As a consequence, lipid content solidifies to form a shell, creating stable nanocapsules. In addition, surfactants are trapped and concentrated in the interfacial zone due to temperature cycling, creating a thick tension-active shell that serves as a barrier to oil diffusion [37].
The "emulsion-diffusion" method has been used successfully to create well-defined nanocapsules. This two-stage procedure starts with a typical emulsification step and removes certain portions of the oil phase in the next stage. The process begins with creating an oil-in-water emulsion with an "oil phase" that contains both the polymer and the oil in an organic solvent (i.e., ethanol, ethyl acetate). The polymer and the oil separate when the organic solvent in the oil phase is removed, which reduces particle size [46].
Zafar et al. followed a similar technique for loading Docetaxel (Dx) and thymoquinone (Tq) into LNCs simultaneously. DxTq-LNCs were obtained by blending appropriate proportions of liquid and solid lipids with lipophilic drugs in ethanol. Furthermore, the organic phase containing the drug-lipid complex was gradually injected into the aqueous phase containing sodium chloride (NaCl), followed by a continuous stirrer. This method has similar advantages as the phase inversion method, including high encapsulation yields, high repeatability, improved control over particle size, and ease in scaling-up while it differs as it uses organic solvent [43, 46].
Quality Control Approaches for Lipid Nanocapsules
Several characterization techniques have been implemented to assess features like hydrodynamic diameter size, polydispersity index (PDI), and morphological facets to demonstrate the development of LNCs. Other characteristics, such as encapsulation efficiency, stability, etc., can also be obtained using the technique mentioned in Table 3.
Biomedical Application of Lipid Nanocapsules
LNCs can deliver anti-inflammatory drugs and antimicrobial agents to target sites of inflammation or infection. This targeted approach enhances the drug's therapeutic effect and minimizes systemic side effects. LNCs can strengthen the effectiveness of vaccines by encapsulating antigens and adjuvants. This improves antigen presentation, leading to more robust and longer-lasting immune responses, potentially providing more effective vaccines against infectious diseases [47]. Since their development, LNCs have been used for various purposes, including the delivery of drugs and biomolecules, food and bioactive ingredients, nutraceuticals, cosmetics, diagnostics, and theranostics, among others.
Delivery of Therapeutic and Diagnostic Agents
LNCs have been explored to safely deliver medicinal drugs via oral, parenteral, cutaneous, inner ear, pulmonary, ophthalmic, and brain routes, enhancing their permeability and bioavailability. Although oral administration is the preferred mode, not all medications can be delivered via oral route. According to Draper et al., the presence of P-glycoprotein limits the oral bioavailability of several drugs. However, they discovered that encapsulating certain drugs in LNCs may overcome such a problem [48].
In an investigation by Ashour et al., a phytomedicine tanshinone IIA has been transformed into LNCs to improve its oral bioavailability. The prepared LNCs showed particle size, zeta potential, and entrapment efficiency of 70 nm, 13.5 mV, and 98%, respectively. In addition, around a fourfold increase in the area under the curve was observed compared to tanshinone IIA suspension. Additional evidence of LNCs showed an enhanced half-life and mean residence time of tanshinone IIA, indicating prolonged circulation. [49].
A comparable result was seen by Pensel et al. when albendazole LNCs were given orally to mice with echinococcus granulosus infection [50]. LNCs are believed to be ideal candidates for injectable nanocarriers due to their monodisperse nanometric size, biocompatible ingredients, GRAS surfactants, low macrophage uptake, and ability to suppress P-gp pump [51].
Gene Delivery
LNCs can also serve as carriers for gene delivery, allowing the transport of therapeutic nucleic acids (such as Small interfering RNA (siRNA) or Messenger RNA (mRNA)) to target cells, providing potential treatments for genetic disorders and other diseases. LNCs were initially created by mimicking lipoproteins and using biodegradable excipients for hydrophobic compounds. LNCs have found widespread use in the last five years for the delivery of nucleic acids and in treating various illnesses, particularly cancer [52]. Gene therapy using siRNA is beneficial for temporarily inhibiting protein expressions in cancer development or chemotherapy resistance. In contrast to intra-tumoral delivery, the development of nanomedicines for intravenous administration is prioritized. Additionally, it was noted that a significant accumulation of LNCs intra-tumorally was seen after siRNA LNCs were modified utilizing PEG [53].
Similarly, Skandrani et al., developed functionalized LNCs with poly(ethyleneimine) to deliver plasmid DNA. At the same dose of poly(ethyleneimine), the transfection efficiency increased by more than 2.8-fold compared to free pDNA. Additionally, it was shown that high drug efficacy was attained when LNCs were loaded with the hydrophobic medication PTX [54].
Diagnostic and Theranostic Application
LNCs are well demonstrated for therapeutic efficiency. However, their use in diagnosis is limited and has not been explored much. The lipidic core or the surface of LNCs could be loaded or functionalized with various radionuclides, such as 99mTc, 188Re, 111In, or 125I, and could be used for radiotherapy, imaging, and oxygen sensing. Magnetic resonance imaging can map hypoxia in oxygen-deficient areas of biological systems or oxygen in cancers with increased sensitivity to lipid signals. During a hyperoxia test, it was found that LNCs were responsive to oxygen shifts. Furthermore, the use of magnetic resonance imaging enabled the mapping of oxygen gradients and tumor heterogeneity. [48, 55, 56].
Nandwana et al. developed self-assembled lipid nanoconstruct magnetic LNCs for non-invasive theranostic application. As comparative data among traditional lipid nanocarriers, magnetic LNCs showed superior structure stability and theranostic (therapeutic and diagnostic) capabilities. Magnetic LNCs exhibit enhanced therapeutic efficacy (16 times) than the free drug due to a larger payload and triggered drug release. The magnetic resonance contrast enhancement of magnetic LNCs was investigated by measuring spin–spin relaxation time (T2) of the magnetic LNCs under 3 T-MRI, and it was shown to be nine times greater than that of ferumoxytol (FDA-approved T2 contrast agent), indicating the LNCs' diagnostic ability. As an outcome, LNCs will likely perform well in theranostic applications [57].
Targeted Delivery of Therapeutics
Surface modifications of LNCs with ligands, antibodies, or peptides can enable specific targeting to particular cells or tissues. This targeted drug delivery approach increases drug accumulation at the intended site, enhances therapeutic efficacy, and reduces off-target effects on healthy tissues. LNCs are considered versatile carriers for bypassing barriers such as the blood–brain barrier and blood-cerebrospinal fluid barrier. Hearing loss is challenging to cure because the temporal lobe has limited access to therapeutic medicines. LNCs proved to be suitable carriers for inner ear delivery and showed acceptable biocompatibility. The only nanocarriers that demonstrated genuine drug transport efficiency to the cochlea were LNCs. Low doses of hydrophobic medications can be linearly released into the inner ear using LNCs. There is no initial burst release with them.
Food Industry
Due to growing interest in health and life quality, natural foods and substances with functional characteristics have become more prevalent in the food sector. Owing to their antioxidant action, carotenoids-natural colorants linked to positive health effects, have drawn particular interest in this context. The carotenoid lutein is plentiful in crops like kale and spinach and is the second most common carotenoid in human blood plasma (carotene being the first). Flowers can also serve as a source of lutein to create nutritional supplements and vegetables. Only the marigold flowers (Tagetes) are commercially grown as a source of this carotenoid, and commercial production of lutein is limited to a few species. A powerful antioxidant that actively shields tissues against reactive species damage is lutein, a hydroxylated carotenoid. The consumption of lutein through diet has also been firmly linked to a decline in conditions, including arteriosclerosis, cataracts, diabetic retinopathy, cancer, and other disorders, in addition to reducing age-related macular degeneration. Despite having these significant biological functions, lutein is an unstable chemical with low bioavailability since it cannot dissolve in water. As a result of processing and storage, as well as variables including temperature, oxygen availability, light exposure, water activity, moisture, acidity, metals, and peroxides, lutein's stability varies greatly.
In an effort to boost the stability of carotenoids, new technologies are constantly being developed. One such technology is microencapsulation, which may disperse powders in water and prevent or lessen the oxidation of bioactive components found in meals. Application of delivery methods with sizes smaller than 1 µm, such as Nanoemulsions, nanoparticles, and nanocapsules, is another option for stabilizing the five carotenoids. The stability and likelihood of usage in the food business are improved by lutein-enriched LNC. Foods can be nano-encapsulated to alter their textures, flavors, colors, and stability. Nutraceuticals are ingredients added to food to improve nutrition. Depending on the size of the nanocarrier, these compounds have a higher bioavailability. The higher the transport capabilities and solubility of the nutraceuticals, the smaller the nanocarrier and the simpler it is for the nanocarrier to enter the bloodstream. For the encapsulation of nutraceuticals, LNCs are employed [58].
Cosmetic Industry
LNCs are well known for cutaneous and transdermal applications because of their small particle size, high encapsulation efficiency, biocompatibility, physical stability, and preservation of encapsulated compounds. According to Da Silva et al., LNCs are shown to be superior to polymeric nanocarriers for the treatment of skin problems. Using ibuprofen as the reference drug, they compared the characteristics of lipid and polymeric nanocarriers for dermal administration. Thus, LNCs improved drug penetration, which is desired for cutaneous application. LNCs are encapsulated with vitamin K1, and their skin penetration is checked using Franz-type diffusion cells. Permeability test revealed that LNCs had more Phytonadione (vitamin K1) in their dermis than controls [59]. 5.8 Biomedical applications.
Biomedical Applications
Researchers have describes the effects of hypoxia, or low oxygen levels, in solid tumors is a result of abnormal and twisted blood vessels that fail to supply enough oxygen to meet the tumor's needs. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), specifically the quantitative assessment of longitudinal relaxation time enhancement, has been shown to be capable of mapping oxygen levels in tumors. This method is more sensitive to lipids compared to water signal. Lipid nanocapsules (LNCs) are proposed as a therapeutic and diagnostic tool in this context. By utilizing the lipidic core of LNCs, researchers aim to develop a technique to increase the lipid content within tissues. This increase in lipid content is expected to enable the assessment and mapping of tissue oxygen levels (pO2). In vitro studies have shown that LNCs are permeable and responsive to oxygen, indicating their potential usefulness in this application. This suggests that LNCs could serve both as a therapeutic tool, possibly by delivering oxygen to hypoxic tumor regions, and as a diagnostic tool for mapping tissue oxygen levels ([56] #72).
Challenges Associated with Lipid Nanocapsules and their Possible Resolution
LNCs have distinct advantages in several aspects, including as drug delivery vehicles. However, they also have some drawbacks that hinder LNCs' functionality. Some of the issues that LNCs face and potential solutions have been presented in Table 4.
Patents Landscape in Arena of Lipid Nanocapsules
So far, different patent applications have been made globally concerning the development method of LNCs and the encapsulation of hydrophilic and lipophilic substances, such as active pharmaceutical ingredients, nucleic acids, and peptides. In addition, the ability to modify the surface is indicated by the successful filing of patents on stealth LNCs. The critical LNCs patent applications are summarized in Table 5.
Conclusion and Future Prospect
The pharmaceutical, theranostic, cosmetic, and food industries have all undergone enormous transformations due to the successful development of LNCs delivery systems. LNCs boosted the delivery of medicines and biologics due to the improved bioavailability of numerous drugs. In addition, LNCs also improved integrity, loading efficiency, preserved activity, and stealth effect. Among the nanosystems, LNCs have considerably enhanced oral, dermal, and ocular drug delivery and gene therapy. Their unique features, such as surface functionalization, amphiphilic, and large molecule encapsulation efficiency, enable the delivery of brain, lung, and cancer therapy. Preclinical investigation has confirmed that LNCs have shown higher stability over 18 months and can be scalable with insignificant size and loading efficiency variations. Patents on LNCs support the utilization of LNCs in various drug delivery and gene delivery domains. However, regulatory concerns about using LNCs in drug delivery primarily matter safety, quality, and efficacy. Preclinical study on cell lines and animal data has revealed that LNCs are safe and effective nanocarrier systems for delivery or encapsulation of a wide range of drug and biomolecules, and they suggested that they can be used for theragnosis purposes also by encasing radio-labelled substances and dye over LNCs for In vivo investigation. In the near future, LNCs will continue to be explored as one of the most promising and widely used alternative nanocarrier systems for improved drug and gene delivery.
Abbreviations
- AIDS:
-
Acquired Immunodeficiency syndrome
- AMPs:
-
Antimicrobial peptides
- AUC :
-
Area under the curve
- CNS:
-
Central nervous system
- DNA:
-
Deoxyribonucleic acid
- DSC:
-
Differential scanning calorimetry
- EPR :
-
Enhanced permeation and retention
- FDA:
-
Food and drug administration
- FTIR:
-
Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy
- GRAS:
-
Generally regarded as safe
- HPLC:
-
High-performance liquid chromatography
- LNCs:
-
LNCs
- MAB:
-
Monoclonal Antibodies
- MSNs:
-
Mesoporous silica nanoparticles
- O/W:
-
Oil in water
- PBS:
-
Phosphate bovine serum
- PEG:
-
Polyethylene glycol
- PEO:
-
Poly ethylene oxide
- PIT:
-
Phase inversion temperature
- PIZ:
-
Phase inversion zone
- PK/PD:
-
Pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic
- PNIPAM:
-
Poly (N-isopropyl acrylamide
- PTX:
-
Paclitaxel
- RPV:
-
Ropivacaine
- SEM:
-
Scanning electron microscope
- si-RNA:
-
Small interfering RNA
- TEM:
-
Transmission electron microscopy
- W/O:
-
Water in oil
- XRD:
-
X-Ray diffraction analysis
References
Bayda SA-OX, Adeel M, Tuccinardi TA-O, Cordani MA-O, Rizzolio FA-O (2019) The history of nanoscience and nanotechnology: from chemical-physical applications to nanomedicine LID. Molecules. https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules25010112
Thapa RK, Kim JO (2023) Nanomedicine-based commercial formulations: current developments and future prospects. J Pharm Investig 53:19–33
Jeevanandam J, Dable-Tupas G, De Guzman MB (2022) Chapter 6 - Applications of nanotechnology in pharmaceutical products. In: Egbuna C, Găman M-A, Jeevanandam J (eds) Applications of nanotechnology in drug discovery and delivery. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Hunt WH (2004) Nanomaterials: Nomenclature, novelty, and necessity. JOM 56:13–18
Litter MI, Ahmad A (2023) The World of Nanotechnology. CRC Press, Industrial Applications of Nanoparticles
Bhagyaraj SM, Oluwafemi OS (2018) Nanotechnology: the science of the invisible. Elsevier, Synthesis of inorganic nanomaterials
Hulla JE, Sahu SC, Hayes AW (2015) Nanotechnology: History and future. Hum Exp Toxicol 34:1318–1321
Chakravarty M, Vora A (2021) Nanotechnology-based antiviral therapeutics. Drug Deliv Transl Res 11:748–787
Singh A, Amiji MM (2022) Application of nanotechnology in medical diagnosis and imaging. Curr Opin Biotechnol 74:241–246
Huynh NT, Passirani C, Saulnier P, Benoit J-P (2009) Lipid nanocapsules: a new platform for nanomedicine. Int J Pharm 379:201–209
Kumar R, Dkhar DS, Kumari R, Divya, Mahapatra S, Dubey VK, Chandra P (2022) Lipid based nanocarriers: Production techniques, concepts, and commercialization aspect. Journal of Drug Delivery Science and Technology 74:103526
Gaber M, Medhat W, Hany M, Saher N, Fang J-Y, Elzoghby A (2017) Protein-lipid nanohybrids as emerging platforms for drug and gene delivery: Challenges and outcomes. J Control Release 254:75–91
Choi YH, Han H-K (2018) Nanomedicines: current status and future perspectives in aspect of drug delivery and pharmacokinetics. J Pharm Investig 48:43–60
Samimi S, Maghsoudnia N, Eftekhari RB, Dorkoosh F (2019) Chapter 3 - Lipid-based nanoparticles for drug delivery systems. In: Mohapatra SS, Ranjan S, Dasgupta N, Mishra RK, Thomas S (eds) Characterization and biology of nanomaterials for drug delivery. Elsevier, Amsterdam
Angelova A, Garamus VM, Angelov B, Tian Z, Li Y, Zou A (2017) Advances in structural design of lipid-based nanoparticle carriers for delivery of macromolecular drugs, phytochemicals and anti-tumor agents. Adv Coll Interface Sci 249:331–345
Mhule D, Kalhapure RS, Jadhav M, Omolo CA, Rambharose S, Mocktar C, Singh S, Waddad AY, Ndesendo VM, Govender T (2018) Synthesis of an oleic acid based pH-responsive lipid and its application in nanodelivery of vancomycin. Int J Pharm 10:149–159
Wang R, Billone PS, Mullett WM (2013) Nanomedicine in action: an overview of cancer nanomedicine on the market and in clinical trials. J Nanomaterials
Hoang Thi TT, Suys EJA, Lee JS, Nguyen DH, Park KD, Truong NP (2021) Lipid-based nanoparticles in the clinic and clinical trials: from cancer nanomedicine to COVID-19 vaccines. Vaccines 9:359
Chouchou A, Aubert-Pouessel A, Dorandeu C, Zghaib Z, Cuq P, Devoisselle J-M, Bonnet P-A, Bégu S, Deleuze-Masquefa C (2017) Lipid nanocapsules formulation and cellular activities evaluation of a promising anticancer agent: EAPB0503. Int J Pharmaceut Investi 7:155
Morille M, Montier T, Legras P, Carmoy N, Brodin P, Pitard B, Benoît J-P, Passirani C (2010) Long-circulating DNA lipid nanocapsules as new vector for passive tumor targeting. Biomaterials 31:321–329
Albanawany NM, Samy DM, Zahran N, El-Moslemany RM, Elsawy SM, Abou Nazel MW (2022) Histopathological, physiological and biochemical assessment of resveratrol nanocapsules efficacy in bleomycin-induced acute and chronic lung injury in rats. Drug Delivery 29:16
Mora-Huertas CE, Fessi H, Elaissari A (2010) Polymer-based nanocapsules for drug delivery. Int J Pharm 385:113–142
Hussein A, Abdel-Mottaleb MMA, El-Assal M, Sammour O (2020) Novel biocompatible essential oil-based lipid nanocapsules with antifungal properties. J Drug Delivery Sci Technol 56:101605
Carradori D, Saulnier P, Préat V, Des Rieux A, EYER J (2016) NFL-lipid nanocapsules for brain neural stem cell targeting in vitro and in vivo. J Control Release 238:253–262
Lagarce F, Passirani C (2016) Nucleic-acid delivery using lipid nanocapsules. Curr Pharm Biotechnol 17:723–727
Moura RP, Pacheco C, Pêgo AP, Des Rieux A, Sarmento B (2020) Lipid nanocapsules to enhance drug bioavailability to the central nervous system. J Controlled Release 322:390–400
Kumar P, Yadav N, Chaudhary B, Umakanthan S, Chattu VK, Kazmi I, AL-Abbasi FA, Alzarea SI, Afzal O, Altamimi ASA (2023) Lipid nanocapsule: a novel approach to drug delivery system formulation development. Curr Pharm Biotechnol 25(3):268–284
Groo AC, Saulnier P, Gimel JC, Gravier J, Ailhas C, Benoit JP, Lagarce F (2013) Fate of paclitaxel lipid nanocapsules in intestinal mucus in view of their oral delivery. Int J Nanomed 8:11
Groo A-C, Matougui N, Umerska A, Saulnier P (2018) Reverse micelle-lipid nanocapsules: a novel strategy for drug delivery of the plectasin derivate AP138 antimicrobial peptide. Int J Nanomed 13:7565–7574
Kasuya T, Kuroda SI (2009) Nanoparticles for human liver-specific drug and gene delivery systems: in vitro and in vivo advances. Expert Opin Drug Discov 6(1):39–52
Zhai Y, Yang X, Zhao L, Wang Z, Zhai G (2014) Lipid nanocapsules for transdermal delivery of ropivacaine: in vitro and in vivo evaluation. Int J Pharm 471:103–111
Kalvodová A, Zbytovská J (2022) Lipid nanocapsules enhance the transdermal delivery of drugs regardless of their physico-chemical properties. Int J Pharm 628:122264
Abd-El-Azim H, Tekko IA, Ali A, Ramadan A, Nafee N, Khalafallah N, Rahman T, Mcdaid W, Aly RG, Vora LK, Bell SJ, Furlong F, Mccarthy HO, Donnelly RF (2022) Hollow microneedle assisted intradermal delivery of hypericin lipid nanocapsules with light enabled photodynamic therapy against skin cancer. J Control Release 348:849–869
Mwema A, Bottemanne P, Paquot A, Ucakar B, Vanvarenberg K, Alhouayek M, Muccioli GG, Des Rieux A (2023) Lipid nanocapsules for the nose-to-brain delivery of the anti-inflammatory bioactive lipid PGD2-G. Nanomed Nanotechnol Biol Med 48:102633
Kaeokhamloed N, Roger E, Béjaud J, Lautram N, Manero F, Perrot R, Briet M, Abbara C, Legeay S (2021) New in vitro coculture model for evaluating intestinal absorption of different lipid nanocapsules. Pharmaceutics 13:595
Graván P, Aguilera-Garrido A, Marchal JA, Navarro-Marchal SA, Galisteo-González F (2023) Lipid-core nanoparticles: Classification, preparation methods, routes of administration and recent advances in cancer treatment. Adv Colloid Interf Sci 314:102871
Thomas O, Lagarce F (2013) Lipid Nanocapsules: A Nanocarrier Suitable for Scale-Up Process. J Drug Delivery Sci Technol 23:555–559
Shete VS, Telange DR, Mahajan NM, Pethe AM, Mahapatra DKJDD (2023) Development of phospholipon® 90H complex nanocarrier with enhanced oral bioavailability and anti-inflammatory potential of genistein. Drug Delivery 30:2162158
Idlas P, Lepeltier E, Jaouen G, Passirani C (2021) Ferrocifen loaded lipid nanocapsules: a promising anticancer medication against multidrug resistant tumors. Cancers 13:2291
Dabholkar N, Waghule T, Krishna Rapalli V, Gorantla S, Alexander A, Narayan Saha R, Singhvi G (2021) Lipid shell lipid nanocapsules as smart generation lipid nanocarriers. J Mol Liq 339:117145
Anton N, Benoit J-P, Saulnier P (2008) Design and production of nanoparticles formulated from nanoemulsion templates—A review. J Control Release 128:185–199
Gershanik T, Benita S (2000) Self-dispersing lipid formulations for improving oral absorption of lipophilic drugs. Eur J Pharm Biopharm 50:179–188
Zafar S, Akhter S, Garg N, Selvapandiyan A, Jain GK, Ahmad FJ (2020) Co-encapsulation of docetaxel and thymoquinone in mPEG-DSPE-vitamin E TPGS-lipid nanocapsules for breast cancer therapy: Formulation optimization and implications on cellular and in vivo toxicity. Eur J Pharm Biopharm 148:10–26
Abdel-Mottaleb MM, Neumann D, Lamprecht A (2010) In vitro drug release mechanism from lipid nanocapsules (LNC). Int J Pharm 390:208–213
Hureaux J, Lagarce F, Gagnadoux F, Vecellio L, Clavreul A, Roger E, Kempf M, Racineux J-L, Diot P, Benoit J-P (2009) Lipid nanocapsules: ready-to-use nanovectors for the aerosol delivery of paclitaxel. Eur J Pharm Biopharm 73:239–246
Moinard-Chécot D, Chevalier Y, Briançon S, Beney L, Fessi H (2008) Mechanism of nanocapsules formation by the emulsion–diffusion process. J Colloid Interface Sci 317:458–468
Mishra DK, Shandilya R, Mishra PKJNN (2018) BIOLOGY & MEDICINE. Lipid based nanocarriers: a translational perspective 14:2023–2050
Draper B, Yee WL, Pedrana A, Kyi KP, Qureshi H, Htay H, Naing W, Thompson AJ, Hellard M, Howell JJTLRHWP (2022) Reducing liver disease-related deaths in the Asia-Pacific: the important role of decentralised and non-specialist led hepatitis C treatment for cirrhotic patients. Lancet Reg Health–West Pac 20:100359
Ashour AA, Ramadan AA, Abdelmonsif DA, El-Kamel AHJIJOP (2020) Enhanced oral bioavailability of Tanshinone IIA using lipid nanocapsules: formulation, in-vitro appraisal and pharmacokinetics. Int J Pharm 586:119598
Pensel PE, Gamboa GU, Fabbri J, Ceballos L, Bruni SS, Alvarez LI, Allemandi D, Benoit JP, Palma SD, Elissondo MC (2015) Cystic echinococcosis therapy: albendazole-loaded lipid nanocapsules enhance the oral bioavailability and efficacy in experimentally infected mice. Acta Trop 152:185–194
Ramadan AA (2010) A study of some lipid-based drug delivery systems (Doctoral dissertation, Université d'Angers)
Li W, Szoka FC (2007) Lipid-based nanoparticles for nucleic acid delivery. Pharmaceu Res. 24:438–449
Resnier P, Lepeltier E, Emina AL, Galopin N, Bejaud J, David S, Ballet C, Benvegnu T, Pecorari F, Chourpa I (2019) Benoit JP (2019) Model Affitin and PEG modifications onto siRNA lipid nanocapsules: cell uptake and in vivo biodistribution improvements. RSC Adv 9:27264–27278
Skandrani N, Barras A, Legrand D, Gharbi T, Boulahdour H, Boukherroub R (2014) Lipid nanocapsules functionalized with polyethyleneimine for plasmid DNA and drug co-delivery and cell imaging. Nanoscale 6(13):7379–7390
Lemaire L, Bastiat G, Franconi F, Lautram N, Dan TDT, Garcion E, Saulnier P, Benoit J-P (2013) Perfluorocarbon-loaded lipid nanocapsules as oxygen sensors for tumor tissue pO2 assessment. Eur J Pharmaceu Biopharmaceu 84:479–486
Nel J, Desmet CM, Driesschaert B, Saulnier P, Lemaire L, Gallez B (2019) Preparation and evaluation of trityl-loaded lipid nanocapsules as oxygen sensors for electron paramagnetic resonance oximetry. Int J Pharmaceu. 554:87–92
Nandwana V, Singh A, You MM, Zhang G, Higham J, Zheng TS, Li Y, Prasad PV, Dravid VP (2018) Magnetic lipid nanocapsules (MLNCs): Self-assembled lipid-based nanoconstruct for non-invasive theranostic applications. J Mater Chem B 6:1026–1034
Brum AAS, Dos Santos PP, Da Silva MM, Paese K, Guterres SS, Costa TMH, Pohlmann AR, Jablonski A, Flôres SH, De Oliveira Rios AJC, Physicochemical SA, Aspects E (2017) Lutein-loaded lipid-core nanocapsules: physicochemical characterization and stability evaluation. Colloids Surf, A 522:477–484
Da Silva ALM, Contri RV, Jornada DS, Pohlmann AR, Guterres SS (2013) Vitamin K1–loaded lipid-core nanocapsules: physicochemical characterization and in vitro skin permeation. Skin Res Technol 19:e223–e230
Urimi D, Hellsing M, Mahmoudi N, Soderberg C, Widenbring R, Gedda L, Edwards K, Loftsson T, Schipper N (2022) Structural characterization study of a lipid nanocapsule formulation intended for drug delivery applications using small-angle scattering techniques. Mol Pharm 19:1068–1077
Tsakiris N, Papavasileiou M, Bozzato E, Lopes A, Vigneron AM, Préat V (2019) Combinational drug-loaded lipid nanocapsules for the treatment of cancer. Int J Pharm 569:118588
Arrua EC, Hartwig O, Loretz B, Murgia X, Ho D-K, Bastiat G, Lehr C-M, Salomon CJ (2023) Formulation of benznidazole-lipid nanocapsules: Drug release, permeability, biocompatibility, and stability studies. Int J Pharm 642:123120
Clavreul A, Roger E, Pourbaghi-Masouleh M, Lemaire L, Tétaud C, Menei P (2018) Development and characterization of sorafenib-loaded lipid nanocapsules for the treatment of glioblastoma. Drug Delivery 25:1756–1765
Lollo G, Ullio-Gamboa G, Fuentes E, Matha K, Lautram N, Benoit J-P (2018) In vitro anti-cancer activity and pharmacokinetic evaluation of curcumin-loaded lipid nanocapsules. Mater Sci Eng, C 91:859–867
Aparicio-Blanco J, Torres-Suarez A-I (2015) Glioblastoma multiforme and lipid nanocapsules: A review. J Biomed Nanotechnol 11:1283–1311
Kiani A, Fathi M, Ghasemi SMJIJOFP (2017) Production of novel vitamin D3 loaded lipid nanocapsules for milk fortification. Int J Food Prop 20:2466–2476
Neupane YR, Srivastava M, Ahmad N, Kumar N, Bhatnagar A, Kohli K (2014) Lipid based nanocarrier system for the potential oral delivery of decitabine: Formulation design, characterization, ex vivo, and in vivo assessment. Int J Pharm 477:601–612
Muller RH, Keck CM (2004) Challenges and solutions for the delivery of biotech drugs – a review of drug nanocrystal technology and lipid nanoparticles. J Biotechnol 113:151–170
Shah MR, Imran M, Ullah S (2017) Chapter 2 - Nanostructured lipid carriers. In: Shah MR, Imran M, Ullah S (eds) Lipid-based nanocarriers for drug delivery and diagnosis. William Andrew Publishing, New York
Heurtault B, Saulnier P, Pech B, Proust JE, Benoit JP (2002) A novel phase inversion-based process for the preparation of lipid nanocarriers. Pharm Res 19:875–880
Christensen G, Urimi D, Lorenzo-Soler L, Schipper N, Paquet-Durand F (2023) Ocular permeability, intraocular biodistribution of lipid nanocapsule formulation intended for retinal drug delivery. Eur J Pharm Biopharm 187:175–183
Roger E, Gimel JC, Bensley C, Klymchenko AS, Benoit JP (2017) Lipid nanocapsules maintain full integrity after crossing a human intestinal epithelium model. J Controlled Release 253:11–18
Guidance FDA (2006) Quality Systems approach to pharmaceutical current good manufacturing practice regulations.
Sharma B (2007) Immunogenicity of therapeutic proteins. Part 2: impact of container closures. Biotechnol Adv 25(3):310–317
Barends D, Dressman J, Hubbard J, Junginger H, Patnaik R, Polli J, Stavchansky S (2017) Multisource (generic) pharmaceutical products: guidelines on registration requirements to establish interchangeability draft revision. WHO, Geneva, Switzerland
Saulnier P, Benoit J-P, Anton N (2016) Universite dAngers and Inserm Transfert SA, 2016. Nanocapsules with a liquid lipid core charged with water-soluble or water-dispersible active agents. U.S. Patents 9,333,180
Patrick Saulnier MF (2015) Process for preparing lipid nanoparticles us patent application. J-PB Angers (FR) Nicolas Anton 12:663960
Heurtault B, Saulnier P, Benoit JP, Proust JE, Pech B, Richard J (2011) Universite dAngers and Ethypharm SAS, 2011. Lipid preparation process and use as medicine. U.S. Patent 8,057,823
Hoarau D, Delmas P, Delmas JC, Ethypharm SAS (2005) Stealth lipid nanocapsules, methods for the preparation thereof and use thereof as a carrier for active principle (s). U.S. Patent Application 10/518,173
Benoit JP, Lamprecht A, Institut National de la Sante et de la Recherche Medicale INSERM (2006) Use of p-glycoprotein inhibitor surfactants at the surface of a colloidal carrier. U.S. Patent Application 10/545,238
Beloqui A, Yining X, Préat V, Patrice CANI, Universite Catholique de Louvain UCL (2022) Lipid nanocapsules charged with incretin mimetics. U.S. Patent Application 17/620,356
Heurtault B, Saulnier P, Benoit JP, Proust JE, Pech B, Richard J (2011) Lipid nanocapsules, preparation process and use as medicine. Google Patents
Petit JLV, Gonzalez RD, Botello AF, Lipotec SA (2013) Lipid nanoparticle capsules. U.S. Patent Application 13/636,909
Acknowledgements
The author, RKT, acknowledges the Department of Pharmaceuticals, Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers, India, for supporting the drug discovery and formulation research at NIPER Ahmedabad. R.K.T also acknowledges the Department of Science and Technology, Government of India, for a Core Research Grant funding (File No. CRG/2021/005402) and also acknowledges the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), New Delhi, for the grant File Id: 2021-14161 and grant File Id: IIRP-2023-4849/F1 for supporting research in RKT lab.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Otavi, S., Lad, N., Shah, S. et al. Lipidic Nanosystem as State-of-the-Art Nanovehicle for Biomedical Applications. Indian J Microbiol 64, 429–444 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12088-024-01298-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12088-024-01298-3