Abstract
During 19–21 July 2021, an extreme rainfall event occurred in Henan Province, China, during which a record-breaking maximum hourly rainfall of 201.9 mm was recorded in Zhengzhou at 09 UTC July 20. In this study, the predictability of this extreme rainfall event is investigated using two convection-permitting ensemble forecast systems (CEFSs): one initialized from NCEP GEFS (named CEFS_GEFS) and the other initialized from time-lagged ERA5 data (named CEFS_ERA). Both are able to reproduce the daily heavy rainfall along the Taihang Mountains, but most members have significant position biases for the extreme rainfall in Zhengzhou. For the hourly rainfall, a few members are able to capture the evolution and propagation of extreme rainfall. However, all ensemble members underestimate the extreme hourly rainfall and have position errors of a few tens to a few hundreds of kilometers. Such results suggest that the predictability of the extreme hourly rainfall at the accuracy of city scale in Zhengzhou is low, especially by deterministic forecasting models, and the occurrence of the extreme requires that many favorable conditions to happen simultaneously. In terms of the Brier score, CEFS_GEFS performs better than CEFS_ERA. The latter lacks spread, especially in regions with scarce rain, resulting in less dispersion in precipitation distributions and larger probability forecast error. When a neighborhood is applied, the probability of precipitation (POP) is significantly increased over Zhengzhou. While the traditional POP shows almost no skill for hourly rainfall ≥ 25 mm h−1, the neighborhood POP significantly improves the forecast skill score, for both daily and hourly rainfall, suggesting higher predictability when spatial error among the ensemble members is allowed.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Brown B G, Gotway J H, Bullock R, Gilleland E, Ahijevych D. 2009. The Model Evaluation Tools (MET): Community tools for forecast evaluation. In: 25th Conference on International Interactive Information and Processing Systems for Meteorology, Oceanography, and Hydrology. Paper 9A.6
Cai S X, Huang A N, Zhu K F, Yang B, Yang X Y, Wu Y, Mu X Y. 2021. Diurnal cycle of summer precipitation over the Eastern Tibetan Plateau and surrounding regions simulated in a convection-permitting model. Clim Dyn, 57: 611–632
Clark A J, Gallus Jr. W A, Xue M, Kong F. 2009. A comparison of precipitation forecast skill between small convection-permitting and large convection-parameterizing ensembles. Weather Forecast, 24: 1121–1140
Clark A J, Gallus William A. J, Xue M, Kong F. 2010. Growth of Spread in Convection-Allowing and Convection-Parameterizing Ensembles. Weather Forecast, 25: 594–612
Clark A J, Weiss S J, Kain J S, Jirak I L, Coniglio M, Melick C J, Siewert C, Sobash R A, Marsh P T, Dean A R, Xue M, Kong F, Thomas K W, Wang Y, Brewster K, Gao J, Wang X, Du J, Novak D R, Barthold F E, Bodner M J, Levit J J, Entwistle C B, Jensen T L, Correia James J. 2012. An overview of the 2010 Hazardous Weather Testbed experimental forecast program spring experiment. Bull Amer Meteorol Soc, 93: 55–74
Du J, DiMego G, Zhou B B, Jovic D, Ferrier B, Yang B, Benjamin S. 2014. NCEP Regional Ensembles: Evolving toward hourly-updated convectionallowing scale and storm-scale predictions within a unified regional modeling system. In: 26th Conference on Weather Analysis and Forecasting/22nd Conference on Numerical Weather Prediction. Paper J1.4
Evans C, Van Dyke D F, Lericos T. 2014. How do forecasters utilize output from a convection-permitting ensemble forecast system? Case study of a high-impact precipitation event. Weather Forecast, 29: 466–486
Fritsch J M, Carbone R E. 2004. Improving quantitative precipitation forecasts in the warm season: A USWRP research and development strategy. Bull Amer Meteorol Soc, 85: 955–966
Gallus Jr. W A, Bresch J F. 2006. Comparison of impacts of WRF dynamic core, physics package, and initial conditions on warm season rainfall forecasts. Mon Weather Rev, 134: 2632–2641
Gebhardt C, Theis S E, Paulat M, Ben Bouallègue Z. 2011. Uncertainties in COSMO-DE precipitation forecasts introduced by model perturbations and variation of lateral boundaries. Atmos Res, 100: 168–177
Golding B, Roberts N, Leoncini G, Mylne K, Swinbank R. 2016. MO-GREPS-UK convection-permitting ensemble products for surface water flood forecasting: Rationale and first results. J Hydrometeorol, 17: 1383–1406
Hamill T M. 2001. Interpretation ofrank histograms for verifying ensemble forecasts. Mon Weather Rev, 129: 550–560
Hersbach H, Bell B, Berrisford P, Hirahara S, Horányi A, Muñoz-Sabater J, Nicolas J, Peubey C, Radu R, Schepers D, Simmons A, Soci C, Abdalla S, Abellan X, Balsamo G, Bechtold P, Biavati G, Bidlot J, Bonavita M, De C G, Dahlgren P, Dee D, Diamantakis M, Dragani R, Flemming J, Forbes R, Fuentes M, Geer A, Haimberger L, Healy S, Hogan R J, Hólm E, Janiskovã M, Keeley S, Laloyaux P, Lopez P, Lupu C, Radnoti G, De R P, Rozum I, Vamborg F, Villaume S, Thépaut J N. 2020. The ERA5 global reanalysis. Q J R Meteorol Soc, 146: 1999–2049
Kong F Y, Droegemeier K K, Hickmon N L. 2007. Multiresolution ensemble forecasts of an observed tornadic thunderstorm system. Part II: Storm-scale experiments. Mon Weather Rev, 135: 759–782
Kong F Y, Xue M, Xue M, Droegemeier K K, Thomas K W, Wang Y, Kain J S, Weiss S J, Bright D, Du J. 2008. Real-time storm-scale ensemble forecast experiment-Analysis of 2008 spring experiment data. In: 24th Conference on severe local storms. Paper 12.13
Li P X, Furtado K, Zhou T J, Chen H M, Li J, Guo Z, Xiao C. 2020. The diurnal cycle of East Asian summer monsoon precipitation simulated by the Met Office Unified Model at convection-permitting scales. Clim Dyn, 55: 131–151
Li P X, Furtado K, Zhou T J, Chen H M, Li J. 2021. Convection-permitting modelling improves simulated precipitation over the central and eastern Tibetan Plateau. Q J R Meteorol Soc, 147: 341–362
Loken E D, Clark A J, Xue M, Kong F Y. 2017. Comparison of next-day probabilistic severe weather forecasts from coarse- and fine-resolution CAMs and a convection-allowing ensemble. Weather Forecast, 32: 1403–1421
Loken E D, Clark A J, Xue M, Kong F. 2019. Spread and skill in mixed- and single-physics convection-allowing ensembles. Weather Forecast, 34: 305–330
Marzban C. 2004. The ROC curve and the area under it as performance measures. Weather Forecast, 19: 1106–1114
Murphy A H. 1973. A new vector partition of the probability score. J Appl Meteorol, 12: 595–600
Novak D R, Bright D R, Brennan M J. 2008. Operational forecaster uncertainty needs and future roles. Weather Forecast, 23: 1069–1084
Nuissier O, Marsigli C, Vincendon B, Hally A, Bouttier F, Montani A, Paccagnella T. 2016. Evaluation of two convection-permitting ensemble systems in the HyMeX Special Observation Period (SOP1) framework. Q J R Meteorol Soc, 142: 404–418
Pan Y, Shen Y, Yu J J, Xiong A Y. 2015. An experiment of high-resolution gauge-radar-satellite combined precipitation retrieval based on the Bayesian merging method (in Chinese). Acta Meteorol Sin, 73: 177–186
Peralta C, Ben Bouallègue Z, Theis S E, Gebhardt C, Buchhold M. 2012. Accounting for initial condition uncertainties in COSMO-DE-EPS. J Geophys Res, 117: D07108
Romine G S, Schwartz C S, Berner J, Fossell K R, Snyder C, Anderson J L, Weisman M L. 2014. Representing forecast error in a convection-permitting ensemble system. Mon Weather Rev, 142: 4519–4541
Schumacher R S, Clark A J, Xue M, Kong F Y. 2013. Factors influencing the development and maintenance of nocturnal heavy-rain-producing convective systems in a storm-scale ensemble. Mon Weather Rev, 141: 2778–2801
Schwartz C S, Romine G S, Fossell K R, Sobash R A, Weisman M L. 2017. Toward 1-km ensemble forecasts over large domains. Mon Weather Rev, 145: 2943–2969
Schwartz C S, Romine G S, Smith K R, Weisman M L. 2014. Characterizing and optimizing precipitation forecasts from a convection-permitting ensemble initialized by a mesoscale ensemble kalman filter. Weather Forecast, 29: 1295–1318
Shen Y, Zhao P, Pan Y, Yu J J. 2014. A high spatiotemporal gauge-satellite merged precipitation analysis over China. J Geophys Res-Atmos, 119: 3063–3075
Shi W R, Li X, Zheng M J, Zhang B, Wang H B, Zhu K F, Zhuge X Y. 2021. Multi-model comparison and high-resolution regional model forecast analysis for the “7.20” Zhengzhou severe heavy rain (in Chinese). Trans Atmos Sci, 44: 688–702
Sobash R A, Kain J S, Bright D R, Dean A R, Coniglio M C, Weiss S J. 2011. Probabilistic forecast guidance for severe thunderstorms based on the identification of extreme phenomena in convection-allowing model forecasts. Weather Forecast, 26: 714–728
Stensrud D J, Brooks H E, Du J, Tracton M S, Rogers E. 1999. Using ensembles for short-range forecasting. Mon Weather Rev, 127: 433–446
Su A F, Lv X N, Cui L M, Li Z, Xi L, Li H. 2021. The basic observational analysis of “7.20” extreme rainstorm in Zhengzhou (in Chinese). Torrent Rain Disast, 40: 445–454
Wang J Z, Chen F J, Chen J, Liu X Q, Li H Q, Deng G, Li X L, Wang Y Z. 2021. Verification of GRAPES-REPS model precipitation forecasts over China during 2019 flood season (in Chinese). Chin J Atmos Sci, 45: 664–682
Wang L, Shen X. 2019. Review on the representation of model uncertainty in convection-allowing ensemble prediction system (in Chinese). Meteorol Mon, 45: 1158–1168
Wei M Z, Toth Z, Wobus R, Zhu Y J. 2008. Initial perturbations based on the ensemble transform (ET) technique in the NCEP global operational forecast system. Tellus A-Dynamic Meteor Oceanography, 60: 62–79
Wei P, Xu X, Xue M, Zhang C Y, Wang Y, Zhao K, Zhou A, Zhang S S, Zhu K F. 2022. On key dynamical processes supporting the 21.7 Zhengzhou record-breaking hourly rainfall in China. Adv Atmos Sci, https://doi.org/10.1007/s00376-022-2061-y
Wilks D S. 2010. Sampling distributions of the Brier score and Brier skill score under serial dependence. Q J R Meteorol Soc, 136: 2109–2118
Wu N G, Zhuang X R, Min J Z, Meng Z Y. 2020. Practical and intrinsic predictability of a warm-sector torrential rainfall event in the south China monsoon region. J Geophys Res-Atmos, 125: e31313
Wu Y, Huang A N, Huang D Q, Chen F, Yang B, Zhou Y, Fang D X, Zhang L J, Wen L J. 2018. Diurnal variations of summer precipitation over the regions east to Tibetan Plateau. Clim Dyn, 51: 4287–4307
Xue M, Kong F Y, Weber D, Thomas K W, Wang Y, Brewster K, Droegemeier K K, Weiss J S K S J, Bright D R, Wandishin M S, Coniglio M C, Du J. 2007. CAPS realtime storm-scale ensemble and high-resolution forecasts as part of the NOAA Hazardous Weather Testbed 2007 spring experiment. In: 22nd Conference on Weather Analysis and Forecasting/18th Conference on Numerical Weather Prediction, CDROM 3B.1
Yin J F, Gu H D, Liang X D, Yu M, Sun J S, Xie Y X, Li F, Wu C. 2021. A possible dynamic mechanism for rapid production of the extreme hourly rainfall in Zhengzhou city on 20 July 2021. J Meteorol Res, 36: 6–25
Yussouf N, Stensrud D J. 2011. Comparison of single-parameter and multiparameter ensembles for assimilation of radar observations using the ensemble kalman filter. Mon Wea Rev, 140: 562–586
Zhang D L, Lin Y H, Zhao P, Yu X D, Wang S Q, Kang H W, Ding Y H. 2013. The Beijing extreme rainfall of 21 July 2012: “Right results” but for wrong reasons. Geophys Res Lett, 40: 1426–1431
Zhao Y, Huang A N, Kan M Y, Dong X N, Yu X J, Wu Y, Zhang X D, Cai S X. 2020. Characteristics of hourly extreme precipitation along the Yangtze River Basin, China during warm Season. Sci Rep, 10: 5613
Zhu K F, Xue M. 2016. Evaluation of WRF-based convection-permitting multi-physics ensemble forecasts over China for an extreme rainfall event on 21 July 2012 in Beijing. Adv Atmos Sci, 33: 1240–1258
Zhu Y J, Zhou X Q, Li W, Hou D C, Melhauser C, Sinsky E, Pena M, Fu B, Guan H, Kolczynski W, Wobus R, Tallapragada V. 2018. Toward the improvement of subseasonal prediction in the National Centers for Environmental Prediction global ensemble forecast system. J Geophys Res-Atmos, 123: 6732–6745
Acknowledgements
This work was primarily supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 41975124, 41730965) and the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2018YFC1507604).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zhu, K., Zhang, C., Xue, M. et al. Predictability and skill of convection-permitting ensemble forecast systems in predicting the record-breaking “21·7” extreme rainfall event in Henan Province, China. Sci. China Earth Sci. 65, 1879–1902 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11430-022-9961-7
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11430-022-9961-7