Abstract
Untreated mental health disorders among people living with HIV (PLHIV) may prevent low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) from achieving the UNAIDS 90-90-90 targets. Anxiety disorders may be associated with decreased adherence to antiretroviral therapy (ART). We sought to review and meta-analyze studies estimating associations between anxiety and ART adherence in LMICs. We searched PubMed, PsychINFO, CINAHL and EMBASE for relevant studies published before July 18, 2018. We defined anxiety as reported anxiety scores from screening questionnaires or having a clinical diagnosis of an anxiety disorder, and poor ART adherence as missed doses, poor visit attendance, or scores from structured adherence questionnaires. We used a random effects model to conduct a meta-analysis for calculating a pooled odds ratio, and conducted sensitivity analyses by time on ART, anxiety evaluation method, and study region. From 472 screened manuscripts, thirteen studies met our inclusion criteria. Eleven studies were included in the meta-analysis. PLHIV who reported anxiety had 59% higher odds of poor ART adherence compared with those who did not report anxiety disorder (pooled odds ratio [pOR]: 1.59, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.29–1.96, p < 0.001). When excluding PLHIV who initiated ART within 6 months, reported anxiety remained strongly associated with poor ART adherence (pOR: 1.61, 95% CI 1.18–2.20, p = 0.003). Among PLHIV in LMICs, reported anxiety was associated with poor ART adherence. This association persisted after the ART initiation period. Increased resources for mental health may be important for achieving virologic suppression in LMICs.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
While many high-income countries have achieved significant progress towards the UNAIDS 90-90-90 goals [1, 2], four years after their inception, many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) are not on target to reach these goals [2]. Closing this gap will require interventions tailored to vulnerable populations, including people living with co-morbid HIV and mental health disorders [2]. Health systems in most LMICs do not provide adequate mental health services; an estimated 74% of people living with mental illness in LMICs still receive no treatment [3]. In 2014, the World Health Organization (WHO) set a goal for 80% of countries to have at least two national programs to better address mental health by 2020. Currently, however, only 32% of countries meet this criteria [4].
The majority of existing literature on mental health and HIV in LMICs focuses on depression. Depression is associated with poor ART adherence [5], risky sexual behavior [6], lower CD4 counts [7], and treatment failure [8, 9]. While not as well studied, anxiety disorders may also interrupt the cascade of HIV care by making individuals less likely to present for HIV testing, remain engaged in HIV care, and adhere to antiretroviral therapy (ART) [10,11,12,13,14,15]. Anxiety has also been associated with risky sexual behavior, increasing the risk for further transmission [10, 16, 17]. Although estimates suggest there is a substantial burden of anxiety among people living with HIV (PLHIV) in LMICs, research and interventions targeting anxiety in these settings have been limited [4, 18]. Thus, little is known about the effects of untreated anxiety on HIV viral load suppression and mortality.
Previous reviews have focused on the epidemiology of all mental health conditions and their prevalence among PLHIV, but have not assessed associations between mental health and HIV-related clinical outcomes [19]. Moreover, previous reviews on anxiety and HIV predate the change to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-V) removing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) from the “anxiety disorder” category [18,19,20,21]. We sought to describe associations between anxiety and poor ART adherence among PLHIV in LMICs, with the aim of addressing these gaps in the literature and motivating further research.
Methods
Search Strategy
Following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines [22], we searched PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO, and Embase for articles published from database inception until July 16th, 2018. Our search included keywords relating to HIV, antiretroviral therapy, adherence, mental health, anxiety disorders, screening for anxiety disorders, and a list of LMICs (Appendix 1). We also manually searched the reference lists of all studies included in the final sample for eligible studies not captured by our database search.
Study Selection and Extraction
Results from each database search were uploaded to Covidence.org [23]. Duplicate articles were removed, and two authors (JW and CK) independently reviewed titles and abstracts and discussed any disagreement prior to making a final decision. The same two authors then performed full-text review on the included articles, alternating primary and secondary extraction with a standardized form. When data clarifications were needed, we contacted corresponding authors to request or clarify additional data.
Eligibility Criteria
Study Design and Population
We included cross-sectional studies, case–control studies, retrospective and prospective cohort studies, and randomized controlled trials. We excluded qualitative studies, systematic reviews, and non-peer reviewed abstracts. When multiple time points were reported from randomized controlled trials and cohort studies, we used the initial enrollment data to better correspond with the data reported in the other cross-sectional studies. Using World Bank Classifications [24], we included any paper reporting data from a low-income, lower middle-income, or upper middle-income country. We did not exclude articles based on the duration of ART use. We excluded studies recruiting participants under age 15, or participants not on ART, unless eligible subgroup analyses were available.
Exposure
Our primary exposure of interest was reported anxiety. We included papers that included either the diagnosis of an anxiety disorder or self-reported anxiety symptoms as an exposure variable. We defined anxiety by positive responses on a structured screening questionnaire, or a clinical diagnosis made during a diagnostic interview. When anxiety scores were reported in multiple groups (e.g., “mild,” “moderate,” and “severe” anxiety) we categorized the data into “no anxiety” and “some anxiety” for the analysis. We excluded papers that focused exclusively on PTSD. In addition, we extracted data on the prevalence of anxiety and methods used to measure anxiety.
Outcomes
Our primary outcome of interest was poor ART adherence. When multiple measures were used to evaluate adherence in the same population, we used whichever measure was more consistent with a “gold standard” method (previously used in a similar population and validated in prior research). However, when it was not possible to ascertain a “gold standard” measure, or the results were equivocal, we utilized the measure that evaluated adherence over a longer course of time. We attempted to include HIV-1 RNA levels (viral load) and CD4 count as secondary outcomes. However, as none of the included studies reported data related to these outcomes, we were unable to complete this analysis.
Data Analysis
We conducted a random effects meta-analysis to assess the pooled association between any reported anxiety and poor ART adherence. Our model included odds ratios as the common measure of association across eleven studies; we excluded data from studies reporting hazard ratio, risk differences, or correlation coefficient estimates which were not comparable to odds ratios. Of the included studies, six reported adjusted odds ratios that accounted for the influence of potential confounding variables in their study populations, and five reported unadjusted odds ratios or proportions only.
We used a random effects model to adjust for within-study and between-study variance, given the different study locations and data collection measures [25]. We assessed between-study heterogeneity using the Cochrane Q statistic, I2 proportion, and τ2 statistic. We conducted analyses examining the influence of publication bias on our pooled odds ratio. All analyses were conducted using the metan package in Stata version 14 (StataCorp, College Station, TX).
We conducted four sensitivity analyses. The first focused only on studies where all participants had been on ART for at least six months to determine whether an association between reported anxiety and ART adherence might persist after an ART initiation phase. The second analysis included studies that used the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale to evaluate for reported anxiety, as this was the most commonly used measure to assess anxiety among the included studies. The final two sensitivity analyses were regional, with the first including studies located in Asia, and the second including studies located in Africa.
Results
Our search returned 664 titles for review. After removing 192 duplicate studies, 472 titles were included for abstract review (Fig. 1). 302 abstracts were excluded at the title/abstract level, leaving 170 articles for full-text review. Full-text review initially yielded 16 articles for inclusion. Three studies appeared to collect data that would have been compatible with our analysis, however, they did not report poor adherence outcomes in the manuscript. The authors were contacted and asked to provide this data, but none of these authors responded to multiple queries [26,27,28]. Consequently, these three articles were excluded, leaving 13 articles for inclusion. Two titles met criteria for inclusion in the review but did not report data that could not be summarized for the planned meta-analysis [29, 30]. Of these two studies, one reported the association between anxiety and poor adherence as a hazard ratio [29], and the other reported it as a Pearson’s correlation coefficient [30].
Characteristics of Included Sample
In total, the 13 studies included in the review (Table 1) ranged in sample size from 101 to 2924 participants [29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39]. One study included only male participants [39]. Among the other twelve studies, proportion of female to male participants varied from 11% [40] to 82% female [33]. Not all included studies reported participants’ ages, however, among those that did the mean age ranged from 34.2 [27] to 42.1 years [26]. These papers were from eight unique countries, distributed across Africa, Asia, and South America. In ten studies, all participants had been taking ART for greater than six months, while two studies focused only on newly initiating patients, and one study did not distinguish between newly initiating and previously established patients. One paper focused exclusively on men who have sex with men (MSM) [39], while the remaining papers did not specify if any portion of the study population identified as MSM. None reported data relating to CD4 count and HIV viral load.
Measurement of Anxiety and Adherence
Six different tools were used to assess anxiety (Table 2). Six studies used the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) [29, 31, 34, 35, 37, 39], two studies used the Generalized Anxiety Disorder 7-item scale (GAD-7) [38, 40] and two studies used the Comprehensive International Diagnostic Instrument [36, 41]. The remaining three studies used unique methods: Beck’s Anxiety Inventory [33], the EQ-5D-5L [42], and the Zung Self-Rating Anxiety Scale [30]. Eleven of thirteen studies used questionnaires developed as screening tools for anxiety, while two [36, 41] used a structured interview and questionnaire. The total prevalence of reported anxiety ranged from 2.5% to 69.8%. Three studies used the same tool to assess adherence, [30, 34, 41], the AACTG questionnaire. The other ten studies each used a unique method. Of these, two [33, 40] used standardized, validated questionnaire tools, while the other used non-standardized self-report measures.
Outcomes
Among the eleven studies included in the final meta-analysis, reported anxiety was positively and strongly associated with poor ART adherence (pooled odds ratio [pOR]: 1.59, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.29–1.96, p < 0.001) (Fig. 2). Separate subgroup analysis excluding patients newly initiating ART also showed that anxiety was positively associated with poor ART adherence in participants previously established on ART (pOR: 1.61, 95% CI 1.18–2.20, p = 0.003) (Fig. 3a). Reported anxiety was also positively associated with poor ART adherence in a pooled analysis of the five studies that used the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale to assess anxiety (pOR: 1.78, 95% CI 1.18–2.68, p = 0.006) (Fig. 3b).
In the six studies located in Asia, anxiety was positively associated with poor adherence (pOR: 1.70, 95% CI 1.30–2.23, p < 0.001) (Fig. 3c). This included studies located in China, Nepal, Vietnam, Thailand, and India [31, 34, 39,40,41,42]. Among the four studies located in Africa, anxiety was not statistically significantly associated with poor ART adherence, (pOR: 1.15, 95% CI 0.79–1.67, p = 0.455) (Fig. 3d). These four studies were located in Cameroon, Nigeria, and South Africa [33, 36,37,38]. We did not pursue subgroup analysis for Latin American countries due to our search only returning one study, located in Brazil, that was compatible with our analysis [35].
Assessments of Heterogeneity and Publication Bias
For the eleven included studies, the Cochrane Q statistic was 18.15 (p = 0.052) and the I2 proportion was 44.9%, representing moderate heterogeneity. The estimate of between-study variance (τ2) was 0.045. Egger’s test failed to demonstrate a statistically significant difference in effect size between smaller and larger studies (p = 0.898). A funnel plot of the eleven studies was asymmetric, however, subsequent trim and fill analysis which included three new hypothetical studies only slightly moved the random effects estimate closer to the null value (pOR: 1.39, 95% CI 1.00–1.78), and the pooled estimate remained statistically significant when these two hypothetical studies were included (p = 0.01).
Discussion
In this meta-analysis of 11 studies, reported anxiety was strongly associated with poor ART adherence among PLHIV in LMICs. This strong association persisted among those PLHIV received ART for at least six months. There was a wide range in reported anxiety prevalence. Anxiety was also associated with poor adherence among the five studies that used the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) to assess adherence. Regional subgroup analysis demonstrated that reported anxiety was positively associated with poor ART adherence in Asia but failed to demonstrate a statistically significant association in among studies in Africa.
While the reported prevalence of anxiety varied among included studies, the reported prevalence of anxiety in studies using the HADS alone ranged from 4.5% to 69.8%, suggesting that the variation in overall prevalence found in our study is unlikely to be explained solely by the use of different diagnostic anxiety scales. In the study that reported the highest anxiety prevalence [43], conducted in India, the authors used the median HADS score to derive a categorical cut-off for anxiety, rather than a predetermined value. In comparison, the study with the lowest reported anxiety among those using the HADS [31], conducted in Thailand, used a pre-determined cutoff of anxiety scores greater than or equal to eleven out of fifteen possible points to diagnose anxiety. Despite using the same screening tool, this difference in diagnostic criteria may account for the large difference in anxiety prevalence across the included studies. Notably, the two studies with the lowest reported anxiety prevalence also reported two of the strongest associations between anxiety and poor adherence, and two of the lowest rates of poor ART adherence. [31, 36]. However, the reported prevalence of anxiety and poor adherence also falls below prior estimates for people living with HIV in LMICs, and so it is likely that these discrepancies are related to challenges in accurately measuring anxiety and adherence in low-resource settings.
Many of the anxiety scales used in the included studies were meant primarily for screening rather than diagnosis, which could also have contributed to the variation in reported prevalence [44,45,46,47,48]. Screening tools are often used for diagnosis due to the lack of availability of trained clinicians, however the data presented here demonstrate the potential lack of reliability when they are used. While the WHO advocates for and outlines a general framework for screening for anxiety and other mental health conditions, they do not recommend the use of one screening tool over another [49]. A universal screening tool that has been validated for use in resource-limited settings, such as the GAD-7 [50, 51], would allow for uniformity across study data and make training and scaling up of mental health programs easier. Regardless of the screening tool used, each instrument should be validated in the local language and culture, and adapted as needed, before widespread implementation [52, 53].
Given the limited mental health resources available in many LMICs, identifying patients that will most likely benefit from mental health-related interventions will be vital in moving towards the UNAIDS 90-90-90 treatment goals. The subgroup analysis of studies from Asia, coupled with the ongoing gap in viral suppression among people living with HIV in Asian countries [2] illustrates a clear need to scale up mental health resources in Asian countries. Though the analysis of studies located in Africa failed to demonstrate a statistically significant association, it was limited by a small sample size. For 90% of HIV-infected adults on treatment to be virally suppressed, health systems need to be able to identify those most at risk for poor adherence [54]. Though resources may be limited in many of the countries included in this review, effective, affordable mental health interventions have been validated in these settings; moving forward it is possible to increase access to these resources in a cost-effective manner [18].
This paper focuses on poor ART adherence as an outcome of anxiety disorders, however, virologic failure may be a better measure of HIV-related outcomes. While adherence can be used as a surrogate for viral suppression, it remains an imperfect marker, in part because many of the tools traditionally used to assess adherence are not completely sensitive or specific [55]. Accurately validating these tools is challenging, in part due to the lack of an inexpensive gold-standard against which to measure accuracy. As quantitative point-of-care viral load testing was recently approved by the WHO for use in resource-limited settings [56], viral load could be an effective surrogate for assessing adherence [57].
While a prior review assessed the association between symptoms of depression, alcohol use disorders, and ART adherence in sub-Saharan Africa [5], to our knowledge this is the first review specific to LMICs focused on anxiety and ART adherence. Our review is limited by the heterogeneity of the studies included, and a relatively small number of studies included in the meta-analysis. Additionally, because most of the included studies did not include outcomes stratified by age and gender, we were unable to perform further subgroup analysis. Two papers met inclusion criteria for our analysis but reported outcomes in a way that were not compatible with the meta-analysis [29, 39]. Both studies also demonstrated a positive association between anxiety and poor adherence. While our analysis demonstrated an association between anxiety and poor adherence, this does not prove a causal relationship. Additionally, due to the overall paucity of data on this topic, our analysis is limited by the inclusion of multiple study types. The majority of studies were cross-sectional, however, we also included three retrospective cohort studies, and one randomized controlled trial. Previous studies suggested that the association between anxiety disorder and ART adherence may be non-linear, with more severe anxiety disorder associated with increased ART adherence relative to no anxiety disorder. We were unable to confirm or dispute this characterization given the limited data available from LMICs.
Our analysis adds to the existing body of research regarding mental health and HIV in LMICs. Depression, alcohol use, and now anxiety have all been demonstrated to be associated with poor ART adherence. We recommend that future research on this topic focus on the role of an integrated, transdiagnostic mental health approach to screening and treatment of these related, but distinct conditions. Furthermore, we recommend further research to better characterize the association between anxiety severity and poor adherence, as this may help to better identify high-risk patients.
In conclusion, reported anxiety appears to be strongly associated with poor ART adherence among PLHIV in LMICs. The use of standardized, validated, and culturally adapted tools to measure anxiety and adherence would allow for more accurate analysis. Effective, evidence-based services for the treatment of anxiety disorder and other common mental disorders are warranted across LMICs. Once such services are available, PLHIV should be routinely screened for mental health issues, including anxiety.
References
UNAIDS. 90-90-90 An ambitious treatment target to help end the AIDS epidemic. United Nations. 2014.
UNAIDS. Ending Aids Progress Towards the 90-90-90 Targets. Glob Aids Update. 2017;198. Available from: http://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/Global_AIDS_update_2017_en.pdf.
Demyttenaere K, Bruffaerts R, Posada-Villa J, Gasquet I, Kovess V, Lepine JP, et al. Prevalence, severity, and unmet need for treatment of mental disorders in the World Health Organization World Mental Health Surveys. JAMA. 2004;291(21):2581–90.
World Health Organization. Mental Health Atlas. Vol. 93, Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 2015.
Nakimuli-Mpungu E, Bass JK, Alexandre P, Mills EJ, Musisi S, Ram M, et al. Depression, alcohol use and adherence to antiretroviral therapy in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review. AIDS Behav. 2012;16(8):2101–8.
Wagner GJ, Ghosh-Dastidar B, Holloway IW, Kityo C, Mugyenyi P. Depression in the pathway of HIV antiretroviral effects on sexual risk behavior among patients in Uganda. AIDS Behav. 2012;16(7):1862–9.
Alemu H, Mariam DH, Tsui A, Ahmed S, Shewamare A. Effect of depressive symptoms and social support on weight and CD4 count increase at HIV clinic in Ethiopia. AIDS Care. 2012;24(7):866–76. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540121.2011.648160.
Krumme AA, Kaigamba F, Binagwaho A, Murray MB, Rich ML, Franke MF. Depression, adherence and attrition from care in HIV-infected adults receiving antiretroviral therapy. J Epidemiol Commun Health. 2015;69(3):284–9.
Marconi VC, Wu B, Hampton J, Ordonez CE, Johnson BA, Singh D, et al. Early warning indicators for first-line virologic failure independent of adherence measures in a South African urban clinic. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2013;27(12):657–68.
Brandt C, Zvolensky MJ, Woods SP, Gonzalez A, Safren SA, O’Cleirigh CM. Anxiety symptoms and disorders among adults living with HIV and AIDS: a critical review and integrative synthesis of the empirical literature. Clin Psychol Rev. 2017;51:164–84.
Gonzalez A, Solomon SE, Zvolensky MJ, Miller CT. The interaction of mindful-based attention and awareness and disengagement coping with HIV/AIDS-related stigma in regard to concurrent anxiety and depressive symptoms among adults with HIV/AIDS. J Health Psychol. 2009;14(3):403–13.
Nilsson Schonnesson L, Diamond PM, Ross MW, Williams M, Bratt G. Baseline predictors of three types of antiretroviral therapy (ART) adherence: a 2-year follow-up. AIDS Care. 2006;18(4):407–14.
van Servellen G, Chang B, Garcia L, Lombardi E. Individual and system level factors associated with treatment nonadherence in human immunodeficiency virus-infected men and women. AIDS Patient Care STDS. 2002;16(6):269–81.
Wang Z. Chinese version of Zung’s self-rating anxiety scale. J Shanghai Psychiatry. 1984;2:73–4.
Rooks-Peck CR, Adegbite AH, Wichser ME, Ramshaw R, Mullins MM, Higa D, et al. Mental health and retention in HIV care: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Health Psychol. 2018;37(6):574–85.
Comulada WS, Rotheram-Borus MJ, Pequegnat W, Weiss RE, Desmond KA, Arnold EM, et al. Relationships over time between mental health symptoms and transmission risk among persons living with HIV. Psychol Addict Behav. 2010;24(1):109–18.
Mimiaga MJ, Biello K, Reisner SL, Crane HM, Wilson J, Grasso C, et al. Latent class profiles of internalizing and externalizing psychosocial health indicators are differentially associated with sexual transmission risk: Findings from the CFAR network of integrated clinical systems (CNICS) cohort study of HIV-infected men eng. Health Psychol. 2015;34(9):951–9.
Sikkema KJ, Dennis AC, Watt MH, Choi KW, Yemeke TT, Joska JA. Improving mental health among people living with HIV: a review of intervention trials in low- and middle-income countries. Glob Ment Heal. 2015;2:e19.
Rabkin JG. Prevalence of psychiatric disorders in HIV illness. Int Rev Psychiatry. 1996;8(2–3):157–66. https://doi.org/10.3109/09540269609046300.
APA. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th ed. Arlington: American Psychiatric Association; 2013.
Radzniwan R, Alyani M, Aida J, Khairani O, Nik Jaafar N, Tohid H. Psychological status and its clinical determinants among people living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA) in Northern Peninsular Malaysia. HIV AIDS Rev. 2016;15:141–6.
Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, Altman DG. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 2009;6(7):e1000097.
Veritas Health Innovation. Covidence Systematic Review Software. Melborne, Australia. 2018. www.covidence.org.
The World Bank. The World Bank In Middle Income Countries. http://www.worldbank.org/en/country/mic/overview.
Borenstein M, Hedges LV, Higgins JPT, Rothstein HR. A basic introduction to fixed-effect and random-effects models for meta-analysis. Res Synth Methods. 2010;1(2):97–111.
Calvetti P, Giovelli P, Gauer G, de Moraes J. Psychosocial factors associated with adherence to treatment and quality of life in people living with HIV/AIDS in Brazil. J Bras Psiquiatr. 2014;63:8–15.
Amirkhanian Y, Kelly J, DiFranceisco W, Kuznetsova A, Tarima S, Yakovlev A, et al. Predictors of HIV care engagement, antiretroviral medication adherence, and viral suppression among people living with hiv infection in St. Petersburg, Russia. AIDS Behav. 2016;22:791–9.
Panigrahi M, Swain T, Mohanty S. Nonadherence to anti-HIV medication is associated with higher level of anxiety: experience from a tertiary care hospital of Odisha. Indian J Pharmacol. 2015;47:672–5.
Campos LN, Guimarães M, Remien R. Anxiety and depression symptoms as risk factors for non-adherence to antiretroviral therapy in Brazil. AIDS Behav. 2008;14:1–11.
Qiao S, Li X, Zhou Y, Shen Z, Tang Z, Stanton B. The role of enacted stigma in parental HIV disclosure among HIV-infected parents in China. AIDS Care. 2015;27:28–35.
Prasithsirikul W, Chongthawonsatid S, Ohata P, Keadpudsa S, Klinbuayaem V, Rerksirikul P, et al. Depression and anxiety were low amongst virally suppressed, long-term treated HIV-infected individuals enrolled in a public sector antiretroviral program in Thailand. AIDS Care. 2017;29:299–305.
Nguyen N, Tran B, Hwang L, Markham C, Swartz M, Vidrine J, et al. Effects of cigarette smoking and nicotine dependence on adherence to antiretroviral therapy among HIV-positive patients in Vietnam. AIDS Care. 2016;28:359–64.
Nel A, Kagee A. The relationship between depression, anxiety and medication adherence among patients receiving antiretroviral treatment in South Africa. AIDS Care. 2013;25:948–55.
Joshi B, Chauhan S, Pasi A, Kulkarni R, Sunil N, Bachani D, et al. Level of suboptimal adherence to first line antiretroviral treatment & its determinants among HIV positive people in India. Indian J Med Res. 2014;140:84–95.
Guimarães M, Rocha G, Camos L, de Freitas F, Gualberto F, Teixeira R, et al. Difficulties reported by HIV-infected patients using antiretroviral therapy in Brazil. Clinics (Sao Paulo). 2008;63:165–72.
Adejumo O, Oladeji B, Akpa O, Malee K, Baiyewu O, Ogunniyi A, et al. Psychiatric disorders and adherence to antiretroviral therapy among a population of HIV-infected adults in Nigeria. Int J STD AIDS [Internet]. 2016;27:938–49.
Yunusa MA, Njoku CH, Obembe A. Self-reported adherence to treatment: a study of socioeconomic factors and psychiatric morbidity among male and female patients with HIV infection in Sokoto, Nigeria. Running title: Treatment adherence, socioeconomic factors and psychiatric morbidity in H. Niger J Med. 2014;23:33–9.
Pefura-Yone E, Soh E, Kengne A, Balkissou AD, Kuaban C. Non-adherence to antiretroviral therapy in Yaounde: prevalence, determinants and the concordance of two screening criteria. J Infect Public Health. 2013;6:307–15.
Tao J, Qian H, Kipp A, Ruan Y, Shepherd B, Amico K, et al. Effects of depression and anxiety on antiretroviral therapy adherence among newly diagnosed HIV-infected Chinese MSM. AIDS. 2017;31:401–6.
Yu Y, Luo D, Chen X, Huang Z, Wang M, Xiao S. Medication adherence to antiretroviral therapy among newly treated people living with HIV. BMC Public Health. 2018;18(1):1–8.
Pokhrel KN, Sharma VD, Pokhrel KG, Neupane SR, Mlunde LB, Poudel KC, et al. Investigating the impact of a community home-based care on mental health and anti-retroviral therapy adherence in people living with HIV in Nepal : a community intervention study. BMC Infec. 2018;18:1–9.
Nguyen NTP, Tran BX, Hwang LY, Markham CM, Swartz MD, Vidrine JI, et al. Effects of cigarette smoking and nicotine dependence on adherence to antiretroviral therapy among HIV-positive patients in Vietnam. AIDS Care. 2015;28:1–6.
Joshi B, Chauhan S, Pasi A, Kulkarni R, Sunil N, Bachani D, et al. Level of suboptimal adherence to first line antiretroviral treatment & its determinants among HIV positive people in India. Indian J Med Res. 2014;140(1):84–95.
Beck AT, Epstein N, Brown G, Steer RA. An inventory for measuring clinical anxiety: psychometric properties. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1988;56(6):893–7.
Spitzer RL, Kroenke K, Williams JBW, Lowe B. A brief measure for assessing generalized anxiety disorder: the GAD-7. Arch Intern Med. 2006;166(10):1092–7.
Stern AF. The hospital anxiety and depression scale. Occup Med (Lond). 2014;64(5):393–4.
Zung WW. A rating instrument for anxiety disorders. Psychosomatics. 1971;12(6):371–9.
Rabin R, Oemar M, Oppe M, Janssen B, Herdman M. EQ-5D-5L user guide. Basic information on how to use the EQ-5D-5L instrument. 2015.
World Health Organization. mhGAP Intervention Guide for Mental, Neurological and Substance Use Disorders in Non-Specialized Health Settings: Mental Health Gap Action Programme (mhGAP). mhGAP Interv Guid Ment Neurol Subst Use Disord Non-Specialized Heal Settings Ment Heal Gap Action Program. 2010;1–121.
Barthel D, Barkmann C, Ehrhardt S, Bindt C. Psychometric properties of the 7-item Generalized Anxiety Disorder scale in antepartum women from Ghana and Cote d’Ivoire. J Affect Disord. 2014;169:203–11.
Chibanda D, Verhey R, Gibson LJ, Munetsi E, Machando D, Rusakaniko S, et al. Validation of screening tools for depression and anxiety disorders in a primary care population with high HIV prevalence in Zimbabwe. J Affect Disord. 2016;198:50–5.
Sweetland AC, Belkin GS, Verdeli H. Measuring Depression and Anxiety in Sub-Saharan Africa. Depress Anxiety. 2014;31(3):223–32.
Tennyson RL, Kemp CG, Rao D. Challenges and strategies for implementing mental health measurement for research in low-resource settings. Int Health. 2016;8(6):374–80.
Jiamsakul A, Kerr SJ, Kiertiburanakul S, Azwa I, Zhang F, Chaiwarith R, et al. Early suboptimal ART adherence was associated with missed clinical visits in HIV-infected patients in Asia. AIDS Care. 2018;30:1–7.
Berg KM, Arnsten JH. Practical and conceptual challenges in measuring antiretroviral adherence. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2006;43(Suppl 1):S79–87.
WHO. WHO Prequalification of In Vitro Diagnostics PUBLIC REPORT Product : Xpert ® HIV-1 Viral Load with GeneXpert ® Dx, GeneXpert ® Infinity- 48, GeneXpert ® Infinity-48 s and GeneXpert ® Infinity-80 WHO reference numbers : PQDx 0192-070-00, PQDx 0193-070-00. World Health Organization. 2017.
Dorward J, Drain PK, Garrett N. Point-of-care viral load testing and differentiated HIV care. Lancet HIV. 2018;5(1):e8–9.
Steele GI. Development and validation of the Xhosa translations of the Beck inventories: 2. Item analysis, internal consistency, and factor analysis. J Psychol Afr. 2008;18:217.
Robins LN, Wing J, Wittchen HU, Helzer JE, Babor TF, Burke J, et al. The Composite International Diagnostic Interview. An epidemiologic Instrument suitable for use in conjunction with different diagnostic systems and in different cultures. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1988;45(12):1069–77.
Gureje O, Lasebikan VO, Kola L, Makanjuola VA. Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of mental disorders in the Nigerian Survey of Mental Health and Well-Being. Br J Psychiatry. 2006;188(5):465–71.
Gureje O, Obikoya B. The GHQ-12 as a screening tool in a primary care setting. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 1990;25(5):276–80.
Gureje O, Ogunniyi A, Kola L, Afolabi E. Functional disability among elderly Nigerians: results from the Ibadan Study of Ageing. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2006;54(11):1784–9.
Tran BX, Ohinmaa A, Nguyen LT. Quality of life profile and psychometric properties of the EQ-5D-5L in HIV/AIDS patients. Health Qual Life Outcomes. 2012;10:132.
Bjelland I, Dahl AA, Haug TT, Neckelmann D. The validity of the hospital anxiety and depression scale: an updated literature review. J Psychosom Res. 2002;52(2):69–77.
Botega NJ, Bio MR, Zomignani MA, Garcia C Jr, Pereira WA. Mood disorders among inpatients in ambulatory and validation of the anxiety and depression scale HAD. Rev Saude Publica. 1995;29(5):355–63.
Lam CLK, Pan PC, Chan AWT, Chan SY, Munro C. Can the Hospital Anxiety and Depression (HAD) Scale be used on Chinese elderly in general practice? Fam Pract. 1995;12(2):149–54. https://doi.org/10.1093/fampra/12.2.149.
Abiodun OA. A validity study of the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale in general hospital units and a community sample in Nigeria. Br J Psychiatry. 1994;165(5):669–72.
Nilchaikovit T, Lotrakul M, Phisansuthideth U. Development of Thai version of Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale in cancer patients. J Psychiatr Assoc Thail. 1996;41:18–30.
Lane DA, Jajoo J, Taylor RS, Lip GY, Jolly K. Cross-cultural adaptation into Punjabi of the english version of the hospital anxiety and depression scale. BMC Psychiatry. 2007;7:5.
Thomas BC, Devi N, Sarita GP, Rita K, Ramdas K, Hussain BM, et al. Reliability and validity of the Malayalam hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS) in cancer patients. Indian J Med Res. 2005;122(5):395–9.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Adrienne Shapiro MD, PhD, Rachel Kubiak, Haylea Hannah, and the other members of the Drain TB/HIV Research Lab for their mentorship and editing support.
Funding
Infectious Disease Society of America Medical Scholars Program. Research reported in this publication was supported by the Infectious Disease Society of America Education & Research Foundation (IDSA ERF) and National Foundation for Infectious Diseases (NFID), the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease of the National Institutes of Health (K23 AI108293), the National Institute for Mental Health (F31 MH112397), the Harvard University Center for AIDS Research (P30 AI060354), the Massachusetts General Hospital Executive Committee on Research, and the University of Washington/Fred Hutch Center for AIDS Research, an NIH-funded program under Award Number AI027757 which is supported by the following NIH Institutes and Centers: NIAID, NCI, NIMH, NIDA, NICHD, NHLBI, NIA, NIGMS, NIDDK. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health or other funding agencies.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
Authors Wykowski, Kemp, Velloza, Rao and Drain all declare they have no conflicts of interest to report.
Ethical Approval
This article does not contain any studies with human participants performed by any of the authors.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Appendices
Appendix 1: Anxiety and ART Adherence in Sub-Saharan Africa: Systematic Review
Search Protocol
Specific Aims
-
1.
Meta-analyze associations between anxiety and ART adherence in Sub-Saharan Africa
-
a.
Sub-aim: anxiety and viral load, anxiety and CD4 count
-
a.
Methods
Search Terms
PsycINFO, PubMed, CINAHL
(antiretroviral therapy, highly active OR ART OR anti-hiv agents OR hiv infections/drug therapy OR HAART OR antiretroviral* OR HIV treatment* OR hiv therap* OR HIV)
AND
(adherence OR nonadherence OR compliance OR noncompliance OR non-adherence OR non-compliance OR viral load OR CD4 OR viral suppress*)
AND
(anxiety OR anxious OR “GAD” OR “Generalized anxiety disorder” OR “BAI” OR “Beck Anxiety Inventory” OR “HADS-A” OR “HOSPITAL ANXIETY AND DEPRESSION SCALE-ANXIETY” OR “STAI” OR “STATE-TRAIT ANXIETY INVENTORY”)
AND
(Afghanistan OR Albania OR Algeria OR Samoa OR Angola OR Antigua OR Barbuda OR Argentina OR Armenia OR Azerbaijan OR Bangladesh OR Belarus OR Belize OR Benin OR Bhutan OR Bolivia OR Bosnia OR Herzegovina OR Botswana OR Brazil OR Bulgaria OR Burkina Faso OR Burundi OR Cambodia OR Cameroon OR Cabo Verde OR Central African Republic OR Chad OR Chile OR China OR Colombia OR Comoros OR Congo OR Costa Rica OR Côte d’Ivoire OR Cote d’Ivoire OR Ivory OR Cuba OR Djibouti OR Dominica OR Dominican OR Ecuador OR Egypt OR Salvador OR Eritrea OR Ethiopia OR Fiji OR Gabon OR Gambia OR Georgia OR Ghana OR Grenada OR Guatemala OR Guinea OR Guinea-Bissau OR Guyana OR Haiti OR Honduras OR India OR Indonesia OR Iran OR Iraq OR Jamaica OR Jordan OR Kazakhstan OR Kenya OR Kiribati OR Korea OR Kosovo OR Kyrgyz OR Lao OR Laos OR Latvia OR Lebanon OR Lesotho OR Liberia OR Libya OR Lithuania OR Macedonia OR Madagascar OR Malawi OR Malaysia OR Maldives OR Mali OR Marshall OR Mauritania OR Mauritius OR Mexico OR Micronesia OR Moldova OR Mongolia OR Montenegro OR Morocco OR Mozambique OR Myanmar OR Namibia OR Nepal OR Nicaragua OR Niger OR Nigeria OR Pakistan OR Palau OR Panama OR Papua New Guinea OR Paraguay OR Peru OR Philippines OR Romania OR Russia OR Russian OR Rwanda OR Samoa OR Sao Tome OR Senegal OR Serbia OR Seychelles OR Sierra Leone OR Solomon Islands OR Somalia OR South Africa OR Sri Lanka OR St. Lucia OR St. Vincent OR Grenadines OR Sudan OR Suriname OR Swaziland OR Syrian OR Syria OR Tajikistan OR Tanzania OR Thailand OR Timor-Leste OR Togo OR Tonga OR Tunisia OR Turkey OR Turkmenistan OR Tuvalu OR Uganda OR Ukraine OR Uruguay OR Uzbekistan OR Vanuatu OR Venezuela OR Vietnam OR “West Bank” OR Gaza OR Yemen OR Zambia OR Zimbabwe OR Africa OR sub-saharan OR developing countries[mh] OR “developing countries” OR “resource-limited” OR “resource-constrained” OR “low- and middle-income” OR LMIC OR “third world” OR “low income countries”)
EMBASE
(‘highly active antiretroviral therapy’ OR ART OR ‘anti-hiv agents’ OR ‘hiv infections/drug therapy’ OR HAART OR antiretroviral* OR ‘HIV treatment*’ OR ‘hiv therap*’ OR HIV)
AND
(adherence OR nonadherence OR compliance OR noncompliance OR non-adherence OR non-compliance OR ‘viral load’ OR CD4 OR ‘viral suppress*’)
AND
(anxiety OR anxious OR ‘GAD’ OR ‘Generalized anxiety disorder’ OR ‘BAI’ OR ‘Beck Anxiety Inventory’ OR ‘HADS-A’ OR ‘HOSPITAL ANXIETY AND DEPRESSION SCALE-ANXIETY’ OR ‘STAI’ OR ‘STATE-TRAIT ANXIETY INVENTORY’)
AND
(Afghanistan OR Albania OR Algeria OR Samoa OR Angola OR Antigua OR Barbuda OR Argentina OR Armenia OR Azerbaijan OR Bangladesh OR Belarus OR Belize OR Benin OR Bhutan OR Bolivia OR Bosnia OR Herzegovina OR Botswana OR Brazil OR Bulgaria OR ‘Burkina Faso’ OR Burundi OR Cambodia OR Cameroon OR ‘Cabo Verde’ OR ‘Central African Republic’ OR Chad OR Chile OR China OR Colombia OR Comoros OR Congo OR ‘Costa Rica’ OR Ivoire OR Ivory OR Cuba OR Djibouti OR Dominica OR Dominican OR Ecuador OR Egypt OR Salvador OR Eritrea OR Ethiopia OR Fiji OR Gabon OR Gambia OR Georgia OR Ghana OR Grenada OR Guatemala OR Guinea OR Guinea-Bissau OR Guyana OR Haiti OR Honduras OR India OR Indonesia OR Iran OR Iraq OR Jamaica OR Jordan OR Kazakhstan OR Kenya OR Kiribati OR Korea OR Kosovo OR Kyrgyz OR Lao OR Laos OR Latvia OR Lebanon OR Lesotho OR Liberia OR Libya OR Lithuania OR Macedonia OR Madagascar OR Malawi OR Malaysia OR Maldives OR Mali OR Marshall OR Mauritania OR Mauritius OR Mexico OR Micronesia OR Moldova OR Mongolia OR Montenegro OR Morocco OR Mozambique OR Myanmar OR Namibia OR Nepal OR Nicaragua OR Niger OR Nigeria OR Pakistan OR Palau OR Panama OR ‘Papua New Guinea’ OR Paraguay OR Peru OR Philippines OR Romania OR Russia OR Russian OR Rwanda OR Samoa OR ‘Sao Tome’ OR Senegal OR Serbia OR Seychelles OR ‘Sierra Leone’ OR ‘Solomon Islands’ OR Somalia OR ‘South Africa’ OR ‘Sri Lanka’ OR ‘St. Lucia’ OR ‘St. Vincent’ OR Grenadines OR Sudan OR Suriname OR Swaziland OR Syrian OR Syria OR Tajikistan OR Tanzania OR Thailand OR Timor-Leste OR Togo OR Tonga OR Tunisia OR Turkey OR Turkmenistan OR Tuvalu OR Uganda OR Ukraine OR Uruguay OR Uzbekistan OR Vanuatu OR Venezuela OR Vietnam OR ‘West Bank’ OR Gaza OR Yemen OR Zambia OR Zimbabwe OR Africa OR sub-saharan OR ‘developing countries’ OR ‘developing country’ OR resource-limited OR resource-constrained OR ‘low- and middle-income’ OR LMIC OR ‘third world’ OR ‘low income countries’)
Search Results (Date): 07/16/2018
Database | Number of results |
---|---|
PubMed | 163 |
PsycINFO | 248 |
CINAHL | 127 |
EMBASE | 126 |
Other Sources
-
Reference lists of included articles
-
“Cited by” lists of included articles
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wykowski, J., Kemp, C.G., Velloza, J. et al. Associations Between Anxiety and Adherence to Antiretroviral Medications in Low- and Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. AIDS Behav 23, 2059–2071 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-018-02390-8
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10461-018-02390-8