Abstract
The management of groundwater poses challenges in basaltic terrain as its availability is not uniform due to the absence of primary porosity. Indiscriminate excessive withdrawal from shallow as well as deep aquifers for meeting increased demand can be higher than natural recharge, causing imbalance in demand and supply and leading to a scarcity condition. An innovative artificial recharge system has been conceived and implemented to augment the groundwater sources at the villages of Saoli and Sastabad in Wardha district of Maharashtra, India. The scheme involves resectioning of a stream bed to achieve a reverse gradient, building a subsurface dam to arrest subsurface flow, and installation of recharge shafts to recharge the deeper aquifers. The paper focuses on analysis of hydrogeological parameters like porosity, specific yield and transmissivity, and on temporal groundwater status. Results indicate that after the construction of the artificial recharge system, a rise of 0.8–2.8 m was recorded in the pre- and post-monsoon groundwater levels in 12 dug wells in the study area; an increase in the yield was also noticed which solved the drinking water and irrigation problems. Spatial analysis was performed using a geographic information system to demarcate the area of influence of the recharge system due to increase in yields of the wells. The study demonstrates efficacy, technical viability and applicability of an innovative artificial recharge system constructed in an area of basaltic terrain prone to water scarcity.
Résumé
La gestion des eaux souterraines pose des défis en terrain basaltique car sa disponibilité n’est pas uniforme du fait de l’absence de porosité primaire. Les prélèvements excessifs depuis les aquifères superficiels ou profonds sans distinction pour satisfaire une demande accrue peuvent être supérieurs à la recharge naturelle, causant un déséquilibre entre demande et ressource renouvelable et menant à une situation de pénurie. Un système de recharge artificielle innovant a été conçu et mis en application pour augmenter les ressources en eau souterraine aux villages de Saoli et de Sastabad dans le district de Wardha au Maharashtra (Inde). Le principe comporte l’aménagement d’un lit de rivière pour en inverser le gradient, construisant un barrage de subsurface pour bloquer l’écoulement de subsurface, et l’installation de puits de recharge pour recharger les aquifères plus profonds. L’article se concentre sur l’analyse des paramètres hydrogéologiques comme la porosité, le rendement et la transmissivité, et sur l’évolution temporelle de l’état des eaux souterraines. Les résultats indiquent qu’après la construction du système de recharge artificielle, une élévation de 0.8–2.8 m a été enregistrée dans les niveaux piézométriques antérieurs et postérieurs à la mousson dans 12 puits du secteur d’étude ; une augmentation du rendement a également été notée, ce qui a résolu le problème d’eau potable et d’irrigation. L’analyse spatiale a été réalisée en utilisant un système d’information géographique pour délimiter la zone d’influence du système de recharge due à l’augmentation des rendements des puits. L’étude démontre l’efficacité, la viabilité technique et l’applicabilité d’un système de recharge artificielle innovant construit dans un contexte de terrain basaltique enclin à la pénurie d’eau.
Resumen
La gestión del agua subterránea plantea desafíos en los terrenos basálticos ya que su disponibilidad no es uniforme debido a la ausencia de porosidad primaria. La extracción indiscriminada excesiva tanto el acuíferos someros como profundos para satisfacer la mayor demanda puede ser mayor que la recarga natural, causando un desequilibrio entre la demanda y la oferta y conduciendo a una condición de escasez. Se ha concebido y aplicado un sistema de recarga artificial innovador para aumentar las fuentes de agua subterránea en las ciudades de Saoli y Sastabad en el distrito de Wardha de Maharashtra, India. El esquema involucra el re-seccionamiento de un lecho de una corriente para lograr un gradiente inverso, construyendo una presa subsuperficial para detener el flujo subsuperficial, y la instalación de pozos de recarga para recargar los acuíferos más profundos. El trabajo se enfoca en el análisis de los parámetros hidrogeológicos como la porosidad, rendimiento específico y transmisividad, y en el estado temporal de las aguas subterráneas. Los resultados indican que después de la construcción del sistema de recarga artificial, se registró un aumento de 0.8–2.8 m en los niveles de agua subterránea pre y post monzón en 12 pozos perforados en el área de estudio; además se observó un incremento en el rendimiento que resolvió los problemas de agua potable y de riego. Se realizó un análisis espacial utilizando un sistema de información geográfica para demarcar el área de influencia del sistema de recarga debido al aumento en los rendimientos de los pozos. El estudio demuestra la eficacia, la viabilidad técnica y la aplicabilidad de un sistema de recarga artificial innovador construido en un área de terreno basáltico propensa a la escasez de agua.
摘要
地下水管理在玄武岩地区遇到挑战,因为缺乏原生孔隙,其可用性并不一致。为满足日益增加的需求,从浅层和深层含水层任意过度抽取的水可能超过天然补给量,引起供需失衡,造成水资源短缺。提出并实施了创新的人工补给系统以增加印度马哈拉施特拉邦Wardha 地区Saoli和 Sastabad 村的地下水源。方案涉及一个河流的重新分割以实现梯度反转、建设一个地下大坝捕获地下水流及打补给井补给深层含水层。本文重点分析了水文地质参数,如孔隙度、单位出水量和导水系数以及重点论述了当时的地下水状态。结果显示,建设人工补给系统后,研究区12口挖的井季风前后地下水位上升了0.8–2.8 米;出水量也有所增加,解决了饮水和灌溉问题。利用地理信息系统进行了空间分析,划分了由于井出水量增加造成的补给系统的影响区域。研究结果展示了在具有缺水倾向的玄武岩地区建设创新人工补给系统的功效、技术可行性和可应用性。
Resumo
O gerenciamento de águas subterrâneas apresenta desafios em terreno basáltico já que sua disponibilidade não é uniforme devido à ausência de porosidade primária. A retirada excessiva e indiscriminada de água, tanto de aquíferos raros como de profundos, para atender o aumento da demanda pode ser maior do que a recarga natural, causando desequilíbrio na demanda e oferta e gerando uma condição de escassez. Um sistema inovador de recarga artificial tem sido concebido e implementado para aumentar as fontes de águas subterrâneas nas aldeias de Saoli e Sastabad no distrito de Wardha em Maharashtra, Índia. O esquema envolve a ressecção de um leito de rio para alcançar um gradiente reverso, construindo uma barragem subsuperficial para deter o escoamento subterrâneo, e a instalação de poços de recarga para recarregar aquíferos profundos. O artigo objetiva a análise de parâmetros hidrogeológicos como porosidade, rendimento especifico e transmissividade, e a situação temporal das águas subterrâneas. Os resultados indicam que após a construção do sistema de recarga artificial, foi registrada uma elevação de 0.8–2.8 m nos níveis de águas subterrâneas na pré e pós monção em 12 poços escavados na área de estudo; um aumento do rendimento também foi observado, o qual resolveu os problemas de água potável e irrigação. A análise espacial foi feita usando um sistema de informações geográficas para demarcar a área de influência do sistema recarga devido ao aumento do rendimento dos poços. O estudo demonstrou a eficácia, viabilidade técnica e aplicabilidade de um sistema de recarga artificial construído em uma área de terreno basáltico, susceptível a escassez hídrica.
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
Introduction
Groundwater supplies more than 85 % of rural India’s domestic and agricultural water needs, which is depleting fast in many areas due to its large-scale withdrawal (Bhalerao and Kelkar 2013). The stress on groundwater in most of the rural areas of Maharashtra state can be ascribed to changes in the precipitation pattern and exploitation. Groundwater depletion has reached a critical state in certain areas within Maharashtra such that many watersheds have been reportedly declared overexploited (CGWB and GSDA 2005). The stress on groundwater affects the sustainability of sources as it creates imbalance in recharge and discharge under natural conditions (Kumar and Kumar 2011). The potential and availability of groundwater in basaltic terrain in Maharashtra not only depends on secondary porosity in the form of fractures, joints and the degree of weathering, but it also depends on geomorphological set up and hydrogeological conditions (GSDA and CGWB 2014; Katpatal et al. 2014; Obi Reddy et al. 2000; Katpatal and Dube 2010).
Recharge enhancement with subsurface storage is a known technology and has already successfully been implemented in many countries at different scales (Tuinhof et al. 2002). It represents a flexible and cost effective means to increase storage capacity. A significant change in approach to groundwater management was introduced by Dillon (2005) when he proposed the term ‘managed aquifer recharge’ (MAR) as a tool useful for replenishing falling groundwater levels. Managed aquifer recharge or artificial recharge is the purposeful recharge of water to aquifers for subsequent recovery for environmental benefit (Dillon et al. 2010).
Additional enhancements of natural recharge provide surplus water for various uses (Hollander et al. 2007). Artificial recharge of water to an aquifer is nowadays widely applied for emergency water storage (Van Ginkel 2015). Most of the studies relating to groundwater recharge explain the process as natural replenishment of an aquifer mainly through precipitation and replenishment through seepage from streams, lakes and return flow from irrigation canals and fields (Bhattacharya 2010). Groundwater storage can be replenished during the subsequent wet period through enhancement of the natural or artificial recharge. Groundwater storage is strongly related to the infiltration of water into the aquifers (Tuinhof et al. 2002). The streams are prime feeders to subsurface storage (Levick et al. 2008; Goodrich et al. 2004). Due to heavy silt accumulation, the infiltration rate is affected (BIS 2008). The compact soil has low infiltration rates which results in excessive runoff (Jagdale and Nimbalkar 2012). The impervious nature of the silt causes considerable increase in the runoff (Henry et al. 1992), thus affecting the sustainability of the groundwater abstraction structures. An earthen subsurface dam with either clay or plastic sheets is a common practice in Maharashtra but the method faces sustainability problems and has not been found effective in hard rock areas (GSDA and CGWB 2007). Gale (2005) has suggested methodologies for MAR and their application in semi-arid regions. These methods include channel modifications, well-shaft and bore-well recharge, and induced bank filtration. In India, to address the problem of sustainability of groundwater resources, several traditional artificial recharge structures have been proposed and are in use, including earthen dams, gully plugs, check dams, recharge shafts and bench terracing (CGWB 2000; BIS 2008; GSDA and CGWB 2007). The traditional system of subsurface recharge in Maharashtra state faces silting problems and reduced storage on the upstream of dams (VIIDP 2012). Hence, a recharge structure which can control the silting problem and enhance recharge in hard-rock terrain, like basalts with impervious soils due to clay content, is desired.
The village of Saoli in central India was facing acute water scarcity during summer. A detailed hydrogeological survey was carried out in 2010 and it was observed that out of 19 wells located in the village, 2 were drinking water supply wells and the remaining were irrigation wells. The depths of the wells range from 7.9 to 14.6 m. The post-monsoon water levels were in the range of 3.5–6.4 m depth and pre-monsoon water levels were in the range of 7.7–13.6 m depth. The post monsoon yield ranged from 36 to 60 m3/day. Out of the 19 irrigation wells, only 2 wells were yielding (18–27 m3/day) in the summer season, which was inadequate for the population of the villages (2,009 inhabitants) and for irrigation purposes. This had resulted in scarcity from the month of April onwards. The drinking-water-supply wells are located close to the stream. It was observed that the stream was heavily silted, and due to heavy silt, the recharge to the groundwater was affected.
This paper presents the conceptualization and design of an innovative artificial recharge system focused on increasing the groundwater yields by means of artificial recharge to increase the groundwater potential. The innovative artificial recharge system was constructed in hard rock basaltic terrain in the month of May 2011.
The conceptualized recharge system consists of three components, each to achieve a specific objective. The first component in the innovative artificial recharge system consists of a subsurface dam in the form of a reinforced concrete wall to arrest base flow. The foundation of the subsurface dam rests on impervious hard rock. Construction of subsurface dams is a known technology and has solved the drinking-water problem of the Holy City of Makkah in Saudi Arabia by creating subsurface storage (Khairy et al. 2010). In order to capture the base flow as well as subsurface flow, it is necessary to the seal the permeable strata to the impervious zone (Yadav et al. 2012). A subsurface dam arrests the groundwater in the pore spaces of rock for sustainable use; hence, the sites of subsurface dams should be located where the geological stratum has effective porosity, hydraulic conductivity and hard-rock basement (Ishida et al. 2011); Mutiso (2002), in his study in Kenya, showed that the water table behind the subsurface dam rose and extended laterally for distances up to 200 m on either side or 500 m in the upstream direction.
The second component conceived in the system consists of three reverse-gradient deepened segments, each 100 m in length with varying depths of 1, 1.5 and 2 m respectively. These reverse-gradient segments increase surface-water storage for recharge. Gabion structures have also been provided at the end of the segment to capture silt. The third component provided in the system constitutes the five recharge shafts of 30 m depth, placed at an interval of 50 m within the reverse-gradient segments, from the subsurface dam to recharge the deeper aquifer. A recharge shaft is a structure commonly used for artificial recharge of aquifers which are separated by an impervious layer (Bhalerao and Kelkar 2013). The most important aspect is the efficiency of the recharge shaft, and at times acceptance rate of an aquifer may be up to 15 L/s at certain places (CGWB 2000). In this case study, the recharge shafts penetrate the impervious basaltic layer at 12 m depth and recharge the deeper vesicular basalt.
The objectives of the study include analysis of the groundwater balance in the affected area, the nature of the aquifer and the availability and potential of the groundwater resource. A further objective was to design a methodology for groundwater augmentation. Based on the analysis of hydrogeological parameters, the artificial recharge system was conceived, designed and constructed for groundwater recharge in 2011.
After completion of the construction in May 2011, continuous monitoring of the groundwater levels in pre- and post-monsoon periods during 2012 to 2015 recorded the impact of the recharge system. The study presents results on analysis of pre- and post-project groundwater levels and yields of the wells. A geographical information system (GIS) was used to spatially represent the area under the influence of the recharge system showing increase in groundwater availability. A Kriging interpolation method within GIS was used to identify the area of influence (AOI) of the artificial recharge system.
Study area
The study area is located in Saoli and Sastabad villages of district Wardha of Maharashtra state in India. The study area falls in micro-watershed No. 5/13 in elementary watershed No. WRW-2 of Wardha sub-basin of Godavari basin and has an area of 5.38 km2 (Fig. 1). The area is bounded by latitude 20°38′45″N–20°40′N and longitude 78°46′E–78°48′E. The maximum and minimum temperatures are 47 and 8 °C, respectively, and the average precipitation during monsoon period is 890 mm.
The area is located on a slightly dissected plateau (Fig. 2) having a general slope of 1–3 % towards the SE direction. It is drained by first and second order streams which are influent in nature. The area is covered by clayey soil (Fig. 2), which has thickness between 1.3 and 1.5 m. The study area is covered by basalt of Lower Cretaceous to upper Eocene age (Patki et al. 2012). The geological profile of the study area (field survey by author) indicates that vesicular basalt is underlain by hard massive basalt (Fig. 3). The weathered and fractured vesicular basalt acts as an aquifer in this area.
Methods
The conceptualization and design of the innovative artificial recharge system focused on increasing the groundwater yield by means of artificial recharge to increase the groundwater potential. Analyses of parameters required for designing the recharge system are discussed in this section, including precipitation, runoff, soil properties and aquifer parameters.
Precipitation and runoff analysis and study of soil and aquifer properties
Precipitation and runoff analysis and studies of soil and aquifer properties in the study area are dealt with here. It has been observed that there is a relationship between hydraulic conductivity and hydraulic properties of the rocks, especially with respect to specific retention, specific yield, porosity etc. (Stanislaw 2011; Bear 1972). These properties are analyzed by conducting field and laboratory tests of the samples collected from the study area.
Precipitation analysis
The precipitation data (Agriculture Department, Government of Maharashtra) for the last 15 years (2001–2015, from the rain gauge station at Wardha) were analyzed to study the precipitation pattern. The precipitation analysis reveals that years 2004, 2006 and 2009 were low precipitation years and consequently water scarcity was observed in the following summers. Years 2007 and 2013 had above-average precipitation (Fig. 4a). The project was completed in May 2011. The daily precipitation data prior to the project were plotted for the year 2011 (Fig. 4b) to study storm events and the number of rainy days. In the year 2011, the number of rainy days observed was 35, and there were 5–6 storm events observed during the monsoon period. A correlation between precipitation and runoff was performed for the period 2001–2015 (Fig. 4c). The coefficient of correlation worked out as 0.977, which indicates a strong dependence of runoff on precipitation. The evaporation rate in Central India is reported to be 2–3 mm/day during the precipitation period (CWC 2006). Since the stream on which the project was constructed is a flowing stream and the study pertains to quantifying the groundwater recharge based on variation in groundwater levels, the evaporation aspect has not been considered.
Runoff calculation
Precipitation of the year 2011 was used to calculate the runoff in the study area in order to find out availability of water for conservation. The runoff was calculated by the Inglis method (Eq. (1); Karanth 1999), which is applicable in the study area where there is a slope of 1–3 %.
In Eq. (1), P is the precipitation (mm) and R is the runoff (mm).
Properties of soil
The properties of the soil were studied to assess soil type and hydraulic conductivity. These parameters were determined in the laboratory by collecting undisturbed soil samples from the study area. Liquid limit and plastic limit tests were conducted to determine the type of soil (Liu and Evett Jack 2008).
The permeability of the silt accumulated in the stream bed over the years was calculated by the variable/falling-head method (Eq. 2; Liu and Evett Jack 2008). The undisturbed samples of the deposited silt were collected using cylindrical cores (11.7 cm length and 10 cm diameter) at different depths in a progressive pit to a depth of 2 m. The undisturbed samples were analyzed in the laboratory for computation of the hydraulic conductivity using a variable-head method.
In Eq. (2), K the hydraulic conductivity (cm/s), L is the length of sample (cm), A is the area of sample (cm2), a is the cross sectional area of the stand pipe (cm2), h 1 is the initial head (cm), h 2 is the final head (cm) and t is the time (s).
Aquifer properties
The aquifer properties of rocks were studied by conducting laboratory tests in order to find out absorption capacity. The specific yield and transmissivity were calculated by the author by conducting an aquifer pumping test on a representative well in the study area (CGWB 1982, 1986). The specific capacity and the average discharge capacity of the representative well were calculated by conducting field tests. Specific retention of the rock (Karanth 1999) was calculated by conducting water absorption tests in the laboratory on the rock samples collected from the cut-off trench dug for the subsurface dam to a depth of 8 m.
The specific capacity and the discharge of the well were calculated using the Slichter formula (Eq. 3; Sammel 1974). The pumping test was conducted in the field on well No. 3, as a representative well since the aquifer conditions are the same across the area where the 19 observation wells are located. The drawdown and recovery were measured at specific intervals of time (Table 1). The discharge rate computed manually and that obtained from specific capacity were found to match. Since the discharge was known and constant (18 m3/h), the specific capacity computed using the Slichter method matched the known discharge.
In Eq. (3), C is the specific capacity (L/min/unit of drawdown), r is the radius (m), t is the time (m), s 1 is the total drawdown (m) and s 2 is the residual drawdown (m).
Discharge of the well was calculated by Eq. (4).
In Eq. (4), C is the specific capacity (L/min/unit of drawdown), D is the total drawdown (m), and Q is the discharge (m3/day) of the well.
Transmissivity (T) is calculated by Eq. (5) (Papadopulos and Cooper 1967).
In Eq. (5), T is the transmissivity (m2/day), Q is the discharge (m3/day), Sw is the drawdown (m), W is the value (m) obtained from the y-axis after matching the time drawdown curve to Papadopulos and Cooper (1967) standard curves.
Specific yield (S y), which is the capacity of rock to drain water under force of gravity (Karanth 1999), is calculated by Eq. (6) (Papadopulos and Cooper 1967).
In Eq. (6), S y is the specific yield [percent], T is the transmissivity (m2/day), t is the time (min), r is the radius (m), θ is the value obtained (min) from the x-axis after matching of time drawdown curve to Papadopulos and Cooper standard curves. By calculating S r (the specific retention [percent]) and S y (the specific yield [percent]), the percentage of voids (porosity) of the rock formation is determined (Raghunath 2006); these are based on the field observations and sample analysis in the laboratory. The results obtained are listed in Table 2.
The results pertaining to parameters related to precipitation, runoff, soil and aquifer properties are discussed in the following. It has been observed that:
-
1.
A total runoff depth of 308 mm is available for water conservation structures in this area.
-
2.
The stream was heavily silted before construction of the project. The value of plasticity index, PI, has been calculated as 21 %. If PI is more than 17 %, the soil is of clayey type in nature (Liu and Evett Jack 2008).
-
3.
The value of hydraulic conductivity, K, is 7.8 × 10−7cm/s, which proves that soil is of clayey type.
-
4.
The infiltration rate in this soil under natural conditions is very slow, i.e. 1.2 cm/h (Jagdale and Nimbalkar 2012).
-
5.
The value of K of sand in the stream bed after removing clay and silt is found to be 2.08 × 10−3 cm/s, which indicates that the soil in the stream bed is of a pervious type (Jagdale and Nimbalkar 2012).
Thus, it is observed that stream deepening and reversal of the stream-bed gradient improves the infiltration rate considerably.
In the hard rock terrain, the streams are located on the lineaments which are weaker zones (Rajurkar et al. 1990; Bhuiyan 2015) and most of the groundwater abstraction structures are located on the banks of streams. The degree of weathering and intensity of fractures are greater in this area. It can be observed from Table 2 that the values of porosity (n), transmissivity (T) and specific yield (S y) of weathered and fractured basalt are high but, due to overexploitation of groundwater, the water levels are declining. Hence, these sites are best suitable for artificial groundwater recharge through shafts and for capturing the subsurface flow by constructing subsurface dams.
Design of artificial recharge system and methodology of its construction
The design of the reverse gradient artificial recharge system consists of the following three components.
Deepening of stream bed to achieve reverse gradient
Silted streams were modified by resectioning and deepening to increase stream bed area in contact with water for storage and infiltration. This method may be adopted in areas where the streams are influent (Yadav et al. 2012). The 300-m-length segment of second-order stream was selected close to where drinking water supply wells are located. The cross section of stream after resectioning and deepening is a trapezoid with base width of 10 m and top width of 16 m. A variation in depth at 100-m horizontal intervals from the subsurface dam was created; the segment depths were 1, 1.5 and 2 m (segments III, II and I respectively as shown in Fig. 5). Due to the reverse-gradient trench, the surface-water velocity is reduced, the wetted perimeter is increased and storage volume is increased, thus increasing infiltration. Due to the reverse gradient, a sink of dimension 100 m × 10 m × 2 m is created in segment I for capture of silt and segments II and III enhance prolonged storage of water and facilitate infiltration (Fig. 5). The total water storage area in the trapezoidal section generated by the stream deepening in reverse gradient of the three different segments was calculated (Sahastrabudhe 2009) and is shown in Table 2.
After removal of clay and silt from the stream bed, the undisturbed samples were collected using a cylindrical core (5.7 cm length and 10 cm diameter) at three locations, one in each segment of reverse gradient. The hydraulic conductivity, K, was calculated by the constant head method using Eq. (7) (Liu and Evett Jack 2001).
In Eq. (7), K is the hydraulic conductivity (cm/s), V is the quantity of water collected (ml), L is the length of sample (cm), A is the cross sectional area of soil sample (cm2), t is the time (s) and h is the head (cm). The estimated surface water storage of 5,850 m3 created by stream deepening in reverse gradient is now available for various purposes. Due to this segment-wise deepening in the depth of 1–2 m, the storage in the segments is prolonged up to the month of March, which is the beginning of summer in India.
Subsurface dam
The yield of the wells starts reducing from the month of March onwards because of the downward movement of subsurface flow under hydraulic gradient in weathered and fractured rock. In order to capture the base flow, a subsurface concrete dam was constructed at about 10 m downstream of well No. 2. The cut-off trench for constructing the subsurface dam was excavated to 8 m below the stream bed level, to hard basalt. The subsurface dam, made of reinforced concrete, has dimensions of 0.20 m in thickness, 16 m length and 8 m depth. The thickness of the dam was fixed based on height of the dam (Khairy et al. 2010).
Storage created by the subsurface dam is calculated by two methods using Eqs. (8)–(9) (CGWB 2000; GSDA and CGWB 2007).
In Eqs. (8–9), S P is the storage calculated by porosity (m3), S SY is the storage calculated by specific yield (m); D is the depth of subsurface dam (m); A is the effective area of influence (m), n is porosity (percent) and S y is the specific yield (percent).
The groundwater available for exploitation through storage created by the subsurface dam considering the porosity (n; 10.36 %) is 408,704 m3, and considering the specific yield (4.58 %) is 181,734 m3. The subsurface storage created due to the subsurface dam has no evaporation losses and also ensures availability of groundwater in the summer period. After the aquifer becomes oversaturated, sideways subsurface flow takes place, which was evident from observations in well No. 17, located about 80 m downstream of the subsurface dam; in well No. 17 there were no adverse effects and it does not show post project reduction in groundwater levels and yield (Tables 3 and 4). The post project monitoring during 2012–2015 indicates that no changes due to erosion were observed in the downstream of the dam as the height of the subsurface dam is just 0.20 m and it does not generate turbulent flow. The subsurface concrete dam is very stable and does not incur maintenance costs (Khairy et al. 2010).
Recharge shaft
It has been observed, through water absorption tests carried out in the field, that the hard massive basalt in the study area acts as an impervious layer between the shallow and deeper aquifers (Fig. 3). Hence, there is no direct recharge to the deeper aquifers. In order to recharge deeper aquifers, the recharge shafts were constructed in the resectioned nala bed on the upstream side of the subsurface dam. Five recharge shafts were constructed, separated by a distance of 50 m on the upstream side of the subsurface dam. These recharge shafts have borewells of 100 mm diameter and 30 m depth. Slotted casing pipes were used to case the borewells. Circular filtration chambers of 1 m diameter and 1 m depth, made of cemented bricks, were constructed around the borewells. Small holes were retained in the brick chamber at regular intervals to allow recharge of water. Graded filter media filled the chamber, with gravels up to 20 mm in size at the bottom and coarse sand at the top as shown in Fig. 6a,b. A slug test (Bouwer and Rice 1976) was carried out to determine the acceptance rate of the aquifer. A known quantity of water was thrust into the borewell and the desaturation time was noted.
The rate of acceptance of water through the slug test was calculated by Eqs. (10)–(11).
In Eqs. (10)–(11), Q m is the volume of water not absorbed (m3), r is the radius of bore well (m), H is the head loss (m), Q 0 is the water absorbed (m3), V is the volume of water thrust (m3)and the desaturation period was 5 min.
The theoretical acceptance rate of water by one recharge shaft is 36 L/min, considering the availability of water for 120 days, total recharge by five recharge shafts will be 31,104 m3. The gabion structure, installed at the end of each segment of the reverse-gradient trench, stops deposition and ensures infiltration. The innovative artificial recharge system described in the present study (Fig. 7) has been implemented with positive changes to the groundwater levels and its availability.
Results
A comparative analysis of groundwater availability before and after the construction of the artificial recharge system is discussed in this section, whereby groundwater levels and yields of the wells before and after the construction have been compared. Spatial interpolation techniques in a geographic information system (GIS) were used to demarcate the increased area of influence (AOI) of the artificial recharge system.
Analysis of groundwater levels
The pre- and post-monsoon water levels for the pre-and post-project situations are shown in Table 3. It should be mentioned that pre-monsoon observations means those taken before the precipitation period, and post monsoon observations are those taken after the precipitation period. The project was completed in May 2011 and so the pre-monsoon groundwater levels of 2011 are pre project. The post monsoon groundwaters levels of 2011 and later are the post project observations. It may be observed in Table 3 that there is significant rise in post-project groundwater levels. The rise in post-project groundwater levels may not be ascribed to increase in precipitation in 2013 as the groundwater levels show increased trends even in 2012 and 2014 when the precipitation was below normal and normal respectively. The comparisons of post and pre-monsoon water levels for the pre- and post-project scenarios have been graphically presented in Fig. 8a,b. It may be observed in Fig. 8a that the pre-monsoon groundwater levels of 2011 in the observation wells are deeper but show significant increase in pre-monsoon groundwater levels of years 2012, 2013 and 2014. A precipitation of 890 mm was recorded in the year 2011 and the pre-monsoon groundwater levels of year 2012 show significant rise. This increase in groundwater level may be only due to construction of the artificial recharge system, as post-monsoon groundwater levels (Fig. 8b) also show similar trends even with varying precipitation in the years 2012, 2013 and 2014.
Analysis of well yield
The yields of the wells in the pre- and post-project situations are given in Table 4 and are represented in the yield maps of the project area in Fig. 9. The well yields were estimated from the pumping rates and the number of pumping hours per day. It may be observed (Table 4) that the yields of the wells also improved significantly after the installation of the artificial recharge system. Significant improvement in well yield may be observed in the post project observations. It may be noticed that there is significant improvement in the yield of the wells in the years 2012 and 2014 when the precipitation was normal, and also when the precipitation was high in the year 2013. The changes in yield of the wells (Table 4) have been spatially interpolated in the GIS environment using a kriging method to show the increase of yields due to the artificial recharge system (Fig. 9). It may be noticed in Fig. 9 that significant increase in the yields is observed in the post project scenarios both in the pre- and post-monsoon periods.The area of influence (AOI) generated due to installation of the artificial recharge system is shown in Fig. 10. It may be observed (Fig. 10) that 12 wells have benefitted by the recharge system and show significant increase in groundwater levels and yields.
Technical suitability of the artificial recharge system
The stream modification is an old practice, but modification to achieve reverse gradient, as proposed in the present study creates different segments of varying depths to arrest silt deposition in segment I (Fig. 5) and enhance more infiltration in segments II and III (Fig. 5). Segment I is provided with a gabion structure to arrest silt and also reduces the velocity of steady stream flow. The three segments also create prolonged storage for infiltration and groundwater recharge through recharge shafts. In some parts of India, the streams usually dry up after the monsoon period. The base flow captured in the reverse gradient structure is further recharged to lower aquifers through the recharge shafts within the sinks created through the reverse gradient structure (Fig. 5). This artificial recharge system is best suited to the basaltic terrain that has a weathered and fractured zone to 8 m depth. The artificial recharge system proposed is not applicable where thickness of soil and local alluvium is more than 3 m. The deepening of streams should be limited to 2–3 m or to the depth of the lowermost layer of soil or alluvium. The reverse gradient structures, as well as the filter chambers of the recharge shafts should be manually desilted after the monsoon period but the silt must be removed after the streams dry up.
Conclusions
The present study was conducted to augment the water availability scenario by implementation of an innovative artificial recharge system in basaltic terrain and post project impacts have been observed to be encouraging. From the results derived and post project observations, the following conclusions may be drawn.
After the construction of the recharge system, a maximum rise of 2.8 m was observed in the post-monsoon groundwater level and a maximum rise in the yield was observed to be 66 m3/day. The minimum rise in the post-monsoon groundwater level was observed to be 1 m, while minimum rise in the yield was 18 m3/day. Before the construction of the artificial recharge system, 17 out of 19 existing wells went almost dry in the summer (pre monsoon) period with only 2 wells yielding water (with yield of 18–27 m3/day). However, after the construction of the recharge system, there was a significant rise in the groundwater levels and yields in 12 wells within the AOI of the recharge system in the summer period. The maximum rise in summer in groundwater level was 2.1 m and minimum rise was 1 m. The maximum increase in yield in summer was 63 m3/day, while the minimum increase in yield was 18 m3/day. After implementation of the artificial recharge system, the area of influence of storage was generated through spatial interpolation in a GIS environment and was observed to be 0.49360 km2 (Fig. 10). The artificial recharge system proposed in the present study is best suited to basaltic terrain that has a weathered and fractured zone to 8 m depth, followed by an impervious massive basalt zone. After observing the success and efficacy of the artificial recharge system in the study area, the system is being extensively used in scarcity-affected areas of basaltic terrain in the other parts of state of Maharashtra, India.
References
Bear J (1972) Dynamics of fluids in porous media. Dover, NewYork
Bhalerao A, Kelkar T S (2013) Artificial recharge of groundwater: a novel technique for replenishment of an aquifer with water from land surface. Int J Earth Sci Eng 3(1):165–183
Bhattacharya AK (2010) Artificial groundwater recharge with a special reference to India. IJRRAS 4(2):214–221
Bhuiyan C (2015) Hydrological characterization of geological lineaments: a case study from the Aravalli terrain, India. Hydrogeol J 23(4):673–686
BISIS 15792 (2008) Artificial recharge to groundwater: guidelines. Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi
Bouwer H, Rice RC (1976) A slug test method for determining hydraulic conductivity of unconfined aquifers with completely or partially penetrating wells. Water Resour Res 12(3):423–428
CGWB (1982) Manual of evaluation of aquifer parameters. CGWB, Ministry of Irrigation, GoI, New Delhi, pp 40–122
CGWB (1986) Manual on analysis of pumping test data of large diameter wells. Technical Series M, CGWB, Ministry of Water Resources, GoI, New Delhi, 28 pp
CGWB (2000) Master plan for artificial recharge to groundwater in Maharashtra. CGWB, Ministry of Water Resources, GoI, New Delhi, 76 pp
CGWB and GSDA (2005) Report on dynamic groundwater resources of Maharashtra as on March 2005. CGWB, New Delhi, and Groundwater Surveys and Development Agency, Nagpur, India, 230 pp
CWC (2006) Evaporation control in reservoirs. Basin Planning and Management Organisation, Report, Central Water Commission, GoI, New Delhi. http://cwc.gov.in/. Accessed November 2015
Dillon PJ (2005) Future management of aquifer recharge. Hydrogeol J 13(1):313–316
Dillon P, Toze S, Page D, Vanderzalm J, Bekele E, Sidhu J, Rinck-Pfeiffer S (2010) Managed aquifer recharge: rediscovering nature as a leading edge technology. Water Sci Technol 62(10):2338–2345
Gale I (2005) Strategies for managed aquifer recharge (MAR) in semi-arid areas. UNESCO, Paris
Goodrich DC, Williams DG, Unkrich CL, Hogan JF, Scott RL, Hultine KR, Pool D, Coes AL, Miller S (2004) Comparison of methods to estimate ephemeral channel recharge, Walnut Gulch, San Pedro River Basin, Arizona. In: Groundwater recharge in a desert environment, Water Science and Applications Series, vol 9. AGU, Washington, DC, pp 77–99
GSDA and CGWB (2014) Report on dynamic groundwater resources of Maharashtra as on March 2008. Groundwater Survey and Development Agency, Nagpur, India and CGWB, New Dehli, 228 pp
GSDA and CGWB (2007) Dynamic groundwater resources of Maharashtra as on March 2007. Groundwater Survey and Development Agency, Nagpur, India and CGWB, New Delhi, 332 pp
Henry FH, Buxton T, Haglin N (1992) Effect of urban storm runoff control on groundwater recharge in Nassau, NY. Groundwater 30(4):507
Hollander HM, Mull R, Panda SN (2007) A concept for managed aquifer recharge using ASR-wells for sustainable use of groundwater resources in an alluvial coastal aquifer in eastern India. In: Proceedings of the 6th International Symposium on Managed Artificial Recharge of Groundwater (ISMAR6), Phoenix, AZ, November 2007, Arizona Hydrological Society, Phoenix, pp 15–29
Ishida S, Tsuchihara T, Yoshimoto S, Imaizumi M (2011) Sustainable use of groundwater with underground dam. JARQ 45(1):51–61
Jagdale SD, Nimbalkar PT (2012) Infiltration studies of different soils under different soil conditions and comparison of infiltration models with field data. Int J Adv Eng Tech 3(2)154–157
Karanth KR (1999) Groundwater assessment, development and management. Mc-Graw Hill, New York
Katpatal YB, Dube YA (2010) Comparative overlay analysis through analytical hierarchical process to delineate groundwater potential zones using satellite data. Int J Earth Sci Eng 3(5):638–653
Katpatal YB, Pophare AM, Lamsoge BR (2014) A groundwater flow model for overexploited basaltic aquifer and Bazada formation in India. Environ Earth Sci 72(11):4413–4425
Khairy Ahmed,Abdulla S, Al-Ghamdi, Gutub Saud A (2010) Analysis and design of a subsurface dam. Int J Civil Environ Eng 10(3):27–33.
Kumar B, Kumar U (2011) Ground water recharges zonation mapping and modeling using geomatics. Int J Environ Sci 1(7):16–71
Levick LR, Goodrich DC, Hernandez M (2008) The ecological and hydrological significance of ephemeral and intermittent streams in the arid and semi-arid American Southwest. EPA/600/R-08/134 ARS/233046, US EPA, Washington, DC. www.epa.gov. Accessed February 2016
Liu Cheng, Evett Jack B (2008) Soils and foundations. The University of North Carolina, Charlotte, NC, USA
Mutiso S (2002) The significance of subsurface water storage in Kenya. Seminar Proceedings, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 18–19 December 2002, Netherlands National Committee for the IAH and Netherlands Hydrological Society, Amsterdam, 29 pp
Obi Reddy GP, Chandra Mouli K, Srivastav SK, Srinivas CV, Maji AK (2000) Evaluation of groundwater potential zones using remote sensing data: a case study of Gaimukh watershed, Bhandara district, Maharashtra. J Indian Soc Remote Sens 28(1):19–32
Tuinhof A, Olsthoorn, De Vries T N, Recharge J J (2002) Enhancement and suburface storage. Seminar Proceedings, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 18–19 December 2002, Netherlands National Committee for the IAH and Netherlands Hydrological Society, Amsterdam, 78 pp
Papadopulos IS, Cooper HH (1967) Drawdown in a well of large diameter. Water Resour Res 3:241–244
Patki N, Ghodke VR, Sathe NJ (2012) Delineation of recharging zones for groundwater in Bhima River Basin, Pandharpur, Maharashtra. Proceedings of International Conference SWRDM-2012, Kolhapur, December 2012, pp 63–67
Raghunath HM (2006) Groundwater, aquifer properties and groundwater flow, 3rd edn. New Age Int., New Delhi, 7 pp
Rajurkar ST, Bhate V D, Harma S B (1990) Lineament fabric of Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra and its tectonic significance. In: Precambrian of Central India. Spec. Publ. no. 28, Geol. Survey of India, Calcutta, pp 241–259
Sahastrabudhe SR (2009) Irrigation and power hand book, 16th edn., chap 14. Kalson, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, 653 pp
Sammel EA (1974) Aquifer test in large diameter wells in India. Groundwater 12(5):265–271
Stanislaw Zak (2011) Correlations between hydraulic conductivity and selected hydrogeological properties of rocks. In: Developments in hydraulic conductivity research. InTech, Rijeka, Croatia, pp 113–132.
Van Ginkel M (2015) Aquifer design for freshwater storage and recovery in artificial islands and coastal expansions. Hydrogeol J 23:615–618
VIIDP (2012) Operational guidelines. Vidarbha Intensive Irrigation Development Programme, Ministry of Agriculture, GoI, New Delhi, 7 pp
Yadav A, Sonje A, Mathur P, Jain DA (2012) A review of artificial ground water recharge. Int J Pharma Bio Sci 3(3):304–311
Acknowledgements
The authors are very thankful to the National Rural Drinking Water Program sponsored by Government of India, the Ground Water Survey and Development Agency (GSDA) of Maharashtra state (India) for their valuable support during implementation of the project; and Mr. Rajendra Deshkar, Ms. Isha Ghodeswar of GSDA and Mr. Deepak Dhote from Rural Water Supply Department of Maharashtra state (India) for helping in the field work and technical supervision.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bhusari, V., Katpatal, Y.B. & Kundal, P. An innovative artificial recharge system to enhance groundwater storage in basaltic terrain: example from Maharashtra, India. Hydrogeol J 24, 1273–1286 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-016-1387-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10040-016-1387-x