Introduction

Triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) tears are most frequently found in the central, avascular articular disc [1]. These are not amenable to formal repair and biomechanical studies have shown that up to 80% of the disc can be removed without creating instability [1, 2]. Optimal treatment for patients with central TFCC remains controversial [3,4,5,6,7,8,9]. Nonoperative treatments include rest, splinting, cortisone injections, and modifying lifestyle to limit aggravating movements [10]. Although arthroscopic debridement is the most frequently used surgical treatment for central TFCC lesions [5, 6], the effectiveness of this procedure remains controversial [4].

The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence of and risk factors for radiographic central TFCC tears in both symptomatic and asymptomatic individuals.

Methods

In this retrospective case control study, 221 patients who had ulnar-sided wrist pain with positive ulnocarpal stress test were age- and sex-matched with 221 controls without ulnar-sided wrist symptoms. Initially, 257 patients who had undergone MRI for ulnar-sided wrist pain to identify abnormalities associated with TFCC, cartilage, or bone marrow of carpal bones were enrolled at an urban tertiary referral hospital between March 2013 and August 2017. Inclusion criteria were: (1) age younger than 50 years, (2) a history of ulnar wrist pain that worsened with pronation and ulnar deviation of the wrist, and (3) a positive provocation test (ulnocarpal stress test). Patients underwent complete wrist examinations and plain radiographs prior to MRI to rule out other sources of pain such as pisotriquetral arthritis, distal radio-ulnar joint arthrosis, extensor carpi ulnaris subluxation or tendinitis, and neuritis of the dorsal cutaneous branch of the ulnar nerve. Exclusion criteria were: (1) distal radio-ulnar joint instability, and (2) radiographic evidence of an old fracture or congenital anomalies of wrist such as a Madelung deformity. Based on these criteria, 221 patients were evaluated. Their mean age was 40 years (range 20–49). Of those patients, 140 were women and 126 patients had right-sided symptoms.

A total of 221 controls were selected from patients who visited the outpatient clinic of our hospital and had undergone wrist or hand MRI for other reasons than ulnar-sided wrist pain during the same study period. The control group included patients with tumorous lesions around the wrist (including ganglion, giant cell tumor or lipoma), chronic tendinopathy, compressive neuropathy (carpal tunnel syndrome, Guyon canal syndrome), scaphoid fracture or carpal instability. Controls were selected by cumulative sampling method at the end of the follow-up period according to matching variables in a stepwise fashion, based on age followed by sex. This study was approved by our Institutional Review Board. All participants provided written informed consent. It was conducted in accordance with the principles of research involving human patients as expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki (64th, 2013) and in compliance with Good Clinical Practice standards.

Conventional T1- and T2-weighted MR scans performed in the Radiology Department using 3.0 T MRI scanner (Siemens Magnetom Verio 3T MRI System, Siemens, Munich, Germany) were evaluated in both groups. Contrast agents were utilized only in asymptomatic controls with tumorous condition. MRI images of participants were obtained in prone position with their wrists in plane. Images were archived in the database. Two blinded reviewers (a musculoskeletal radiologist and an orthopaedic hand specialist) independently reviewed MR scans of 30 symptomatic patients in two sessions with a 14-day interval between sessions. Plain radiographs and MR scans were presented to reviewers in a random order. Orders were altered during repeat sessions. Inter-observer and intra-observer reliabilities of four radiologic parameters (the degree of ulnar plus variance, type of central TFCC lesions, presence of carpal or distal ulnar bone enhancement, cartilage degeneration of ulno-carpal or distal radio-ulnar joint) were assessed using correlation coefficients. Palmer class 1A traumatic tears of TFCC were characterized as central flap type tears of the disc proper. Palmer class 2 degenerative changes were subclassified as follows: 2A, TFCC fraying and mucoid degeneration; 2B, TFCC degeneration with lunate and/or ulnar chondromalacia (ulnocarpal impaction); 2C, TFCC perforation plus ulnocarpal impaction; 2D, TFCC perforation plus ulnocarpal impaction plus lunotriquetral ligament (LTL) perforation; and 2E, TFCC perforation plus ulnocarpal impaction plus LTL perforation with frank ulnocarpal osteoarthritis. This study did not classify the cause of TFCC injuries. Cartilage degeneration of the lunate, triquetrum, and ulna were evaluated based on the Outerbridge grading system with five grades (grade 0 = normal to grade 4 = full thickness cartilage loss) based on radiographic images. In this study, grades 3 and 4 were grouped by the presence of cartilage degeneration, while grades 0, 1, and 2 were grouped by the absence of cartilage degeneration.

Statistical analysis

A post hoc power analysis indicated that a sample size of 442 patients (221 per group) would have 77% power to detect a difference in the prevalence of central TFCC lesions in symptomatic group (31%) versus non-symptomatic group (23%) with a precision of 5%.

Descriptive statistics were used to determine patients’ demographics and clinical characteristics while Kolmogorov–Smirnov test was used to identify the normality of variable distributions. To determine the relationship between symptomatic and asymptomatic groups, parameters such as gender, age, body mass index (BMI), prevalence of TFCC tears, ulnar plus variance, and type of TFCC lesions were assessed. In addition, radiologic parameters were compared between symptomatic and asymptomatic individuals who had central TFCC lesions. Chi-squared test was used to analyze categorical variables. Two-sample t test was used to analyze numerical variables. Parametric t test was performed to determine any differences between the two groups for variables with normal distribution such as patient age and body mass index, whereas nonparametric Mann–Whitney U test was performed for variables without normal distribution such as ulnar plus variance. Variables with p < 0.10 were included in multivariable analysis. Logistic regression analysis was carried out to identify independent risk factors for symptomatic TFCC lesions. All reported p values were two-sided and p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Inter-observer and intra-observer reliability were assessed with Cohen kappa coefficient. Kappa values were interpreted as follows: < 0.20, slight agreement; 0.21–0.40, fair agreement; 0.41–0.60, moderate agreement; 0.61–0.80, substantial agreement; and > 0.80, almost perfect agreement [11].

Results

The prevalence of central TFCC lesions was 68/221 (31%) in symptomatic patients, which was not significantly different from that (68/221, 23%) in asymptomatic controls (p = 0.07) (Table 1). The type of central TFCC tear varied significantly between the two groups. In the symptomatic group, 8% (18/221) of patients had type 1A (flap tear) lesions compared to 4% (8/221) in the control group (p = 0.04). Patients in the symptomatic group (showing positive ulno-carpal stress test) had significantly greater ulnar plus variance than the control group (1.6 [− 1.8 to 3.4] vs. 0.7 [− 2.2 to 2.6], p < 0.01). They were more likely to have bony enhancement on MR images (p = 0.01). Other clinical characteristics such as prevalence of type 2 TFCC lesions, arthritis of ulno-carpal or distal radio-ulnar joint, or presence of synovitis were not significantly different between the two groups.

Table 1 Demographic and clinical characteristics of symptomatic patients and asymptomatic controls
Full size table

Patients with symptomatic TFCC lesions were younger (p < 0.01) with greater ulnar plus variance (p < 0.01). They were more likely to have bony enhancement on ulnar head or carpus (p = 0.02) compared to those with asymptomatic TFCC lesions. There were also a significantly higher number of female patients in the symptomatic TFCC group than in the asymptomatic TFCC group (p = 0.03) (Table 2). Multivariable logistic regression analysis revealed that younger age (< 40 years old; odds ratio [OR] 1.9, 95% CI 1.2–2.6), female gender (OR 2.1, 95% CI 1.7–2.5), and presence of bony enhancement (OR 2.7, 95% CI 2.4–3.0) were significant factors for symptom development associated with central TFCC lesions.

Table 2 Comparisons of clinical characteristics between symptomatic and asymptomatic central TFCC lesions
Full size table

Intra- and inter-observer correlations for bony enhancement on ulnar head or carpus were the highest while those for Palmer’s type 2 sub-classification were the lowest among radiographic measurements. All measurements except Palmer’s type 2 sub-classification were reproducible and reliable (above substantial agreement) among observers (Table 3).

Table 3 Inter-observer and intra-observer reliabilities of radiographic parameters
Full size table

Discussion

Increasing prevalence of degenerative changes of TFCC with age diminishes the accuracy of MRI-based diagnosis and treatment for patients with newly symptomatic tears. This study shows that the prevalence of radiographic central TFCC lesions in symptomatic patients is similar to that in asymptomatic controls. In addition, this study reveals that symptoms of TFCC lesions are associated with younger age, female gender, and presence of bony enhancement on MR images.

The majority of radiographic and clinical studies of central TFCC lesions have limited case series [4, 6]. Few studies have documented the prevalence of central TFCC lesions in symptomatic compared with asymptomatic individuals. Mikic has evaluated TFCC of 180 cadaver wrists of subjects with age ranging from premature infants to 97 years [12]. He found that degenerative changes of TFCCs began to appear in the third decade of life. He also found that 50% of TFCCs in individuals older than 60 had degenerative perforations. Results of the present study demonstrated that radiographic central TFCC tears were asymptomatic in many individuals younger than 50 years.

In this study, patients with signal enhancement of carpal or distal ulna on MRI were more likely to exhibit ulnar-sided wrist symptoms and signs. This radiographic sign was found in 32% of symptomatic TFCC tears. It was the only significant radiologic factor for symptoms associated with central TFCC lesions. Almost none of radiologic factors including degree of ulnar plus variance, type of TFCC lesion, or arthritis of ulno-carpal or distal radio-ulnar joint had a significant effect on symptom development of central TFCC lesions. These results are consistent with previous MRI findings showing that radiological factors have limited diagnostic value in symptomatic TFCC injury [13]. However, MRI findings are often a precursor to plain radiographic findings [14]. Results of this study suggest that carpal or distal ulna bone enhancement is distinct and it can facilitate the prediction of symptoms. Subchondral bone marrow edema is an indirect sign of chondromalacia and an early finding of ulnar impaction syndrome [14]. Most patients with 1A lesions of TFCC had a bone bruise which may implicate ulnar impaction syndrome. Such symptoms are more likely to be originated from ulnocarpal impaction rather than traumatic injury. Conversely, distinguishing causes can be problematic because traumatic lesions are subject to healing processes that change morphologies during the course of treatment [15]. It might be impossible to distinguish between traumatic and degenerative TFCC lesions on MRI scans. A previous study has indicated that the presence or absence of an injury affects inter-rater reliability for the classification of central TFCC lesions [16].

In terms of demographic factors, symptoms of TFCC lesions were associated with female gender and younger age in the present study. Gender difference in treatment outcomes may be partly explained by higher physical vulnerability [17] or pain sensitivity [18] in women. Musculoskeletal pain and disability have been found to be more prevalent [19] and more severe in women compared to those in men [20]. In this study, patients with younger age were more likely to have symptoms of central TFCC lesions. A number of studies found that symptomatic TFCC injuries are associated with athletes and individuals engaged in manual work involving hands [21, 22]. Conversely, age-related degenerative changes begin as early as the third decade of life, and the prevalence of TFCC lesions has been found to be high among asymptomatic individuals aged 50 years and above [23].

The present study had some limitations. It was a retrospective single-center study. Thus, there might be possible selection bias involving participants in the asymptomatic group. One may argue that controls could have radial-sided wrist pain due to TFCC lesion. Thus, it would be better to evaluate health controls without any complaints at the wrist. Ulnar-sided wrist pain and the presence of positive ulno-capal stress test were considered as the most important clinical implications of TFCC lesions. The interpretation of radiology reports might introduce potential bias. Previous studies have indicated that the sensitivity of 3 T MR for detecting TFCC tears is 80–86% and specificity for detection of tears is 100%, thus reducing the need for arthrographic examination [24,25,26]. This study audited the accuracy of these reports. However, the present study could not control the consistency of sub-classification of type 2 tears on MRI findings. MRI settings for wrist lesions might vary between symptomatic and asymptomatic individuals. Less TFCC tears might be found in the control group because scans were technically performed for other pathologies. However, routine T1- and T2-weighted images for the wrist were usually acquired and compared. Radiographic results were not verified by arthroscopy. Arthroscopy of the radiocarpal or even the distal radio-ulnar joint would reveal the real status of the TFCC. However, many patients showed symptom improvements after conservative treatment (brace, physiotherapy, and lifestyle modification) without arthroscopy. Finally, this study evaluated MR images from a convenient sample of patients with hand and wrist problems in an urban area, and all patients were younger than 50 years. Thus, our findings should be interpreted cautiously for populations with different patient and clinical demographics.

In summary, this study showed a similar prevalence of radiographic central TFCC lesions between symptomatic and asymptomatic individuals. Symptoms of central TFCC lesions seem to be associated with younger age, female gender, and presence of bony enhancement on MR images.