Abstract
Already in 1947, Australia proposed in the UN Commission on Human Rights the establishment of an International Court of Human Rights. While regional human rights courts were created in the following decades in Europe, the Americas, and Africa, the United Nations so far has entrusted only quasi-judicial treaty monitoring bodies with the examination of individual complaints, whose decisions are, however, nonbinding under international law. This is the reason why the author of this chapter, together with Julia Kozma and Martin Scheinin, drafted a Statute for a World Court of Human Rights in the framework of a Swiss initiative aimed at preparing a new Agenda for Human Rights on the occasion of the 60th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. This proposal goes beyond the model of regional human rights courts and also provides for an optional competence to hold international organizations, transnational corporations, and other non-State actors accountable for human rights violations. Despite the fact that the current political climate is not very favorable to innovative and future-oriented ideas to strengthen international human rights protection, this initiative was well-received by civil society and the academic community. There is, however, one significant exception: Philip Alston, one of the most prominent human rights scholars of our time, launched a fundamental attack on the very idea of a World Court of Human Rights, calling it a “truly bad idea.” After a short overview of the main reasons for a World Court and the main features of the draft statute, this chapter examines the various reasons put forward by Philip Alston against the World Court and subjects them to a critical review.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Alston P (2013) A world court for human rights is not a good idea. Available at http://justsecurity.org/2796/world-court-human-rights-good-idea. Accessed 28 Jan 2018
Alston P (2014a) Against a world court of human rights, working paper no 31–71 of October 2013 at the New York University School of Law. Reprinted in Ethics & International Affairs 28(2):197–212
Alston P (2014b) A truly bad idea: a world court for human rights. Available at https://www.opendemocracy.net/openglobalrights-blog/philip-alston/truly-bad-idea-world-court-for-human-rights. Accessed 28 Jan 2018
Alston P, Tessitore J (2014) Interview with Philip Alston on a world court for human rights. Available at https://www.ethicsandinternationalaffairs.org/2014/eia-interview-with-philip-alston-on-a-world-court-for-human-rights. Accessed 28 Jan 2018
BBC News (2012) Prisoners will not get the vote, says David Cameron. Available at http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-20053244. Accessed 22 Feb 2018
Cassese A (2012) Realizing utopia: the future of international law. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Devereux A (2002) Australia and the international scrutiny of civil and political rights: an analysis of Australia’s negotiating policies 1946–1966. Aust Yearb Int Law 22:47–52
European Court of Human Rights (2005) Hirst v UK, No. 74025/01, Judgement of the Grand Chamber of 6 October 2005
Frowein J (2002) Provisional measures by the international court of justice, the La Grand case. ZAÖRVR 62(1–2):55–60
International Commission of Jurists (2011) Towards a world court of human rights: questions and answers, supporting paper to the 2011 report of the panel on human dignity, Geneva
International Court of Justice (1993) Genocide case (Bosnia and Herzegovina v Yugoslavia), provisional measures, order of 13 Sept 1993, I.C.J. Reports 1993, at 325
International Court of Justice (2001) La Grand case (Germany v United States), judgment of 27 June 2001, I.C.J. Reports 2001, at 466
International Court of Justice (2016). Annual report. UN Doc. A/71/4 of 11 Aug 2016
Kirkpatrick J (2014) A modest proposal: a global court of human rights. J Hum Rights 13(2):230–248. https://doi.org/10.1080/14754835.2013.824288
Kozma J, Nowak M, Scheinin M (2010) A world court of human rights: consolidated statute and commentary. NWV, Wien
Leach P, Paraskeva C, Uzelak G (2009) International human rights & fact finding: an analysis of the fact-finding missions conducted by the European Commission and European Court of Human Rights. London Metropolitan University, London
Li T (2017) The establishment of a world court of human rights and the design of its complementarity jurisdiction. Doctoral Thesis at Vienna University
Nowak M (2007) The need for a world court of human rights. HRLR 7(1):251–259
Nowak M (2009) Eight reasons why we need a world court of human rights. In: Alfredsson G, Grimheden J, Ramacharan B, de Zayas A (eds) International human rights monitoring mechanisms – essays in honour of Jakob Th. Möller, vol 2. Brill, Leiden, pp 695–706
Nowak M (2012a) It’s time for a world court of human rights. In: Bassiouni C, Schabas W (eds) New challenges to the UN human rights machinery – what future for the UN treaty body system and the human rights council procedures? Intersentia, Cambridge, pp 17–34
Nowak M (2012b) On the creation of a world court of human rights. Nat Taiwan Univ Law Rev 7(1):257–291
Nowak M (2013a) A new world court of human rights: a role for international humanitarian law? In: Kolb R, Gaggioli G (eds) Research handbook on human rights and humanitarian law. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, pp 531–539
Nowak M (2013b) Comments on the UN high commissioner’s proposals aimed at strengthening the UN human rights treaty body system. NQHR 31(1):3–8
Nowak M (2014) The right of victims of human rights violations to a remedy: the need for a world court of human rights. NJHR 32(1):3–17
Panel of Eminent Persons. Protecting dignity: an agenda for human rights, www.UDHR60.ch. Accessed 28 Jan 2018
Ssenyonjo M (2016) Economic, social and cultural rights in international law, 2nd edn. Oxford, Hart
Trechsel S (2004) A world court for human rights? Northwest J Int Hum Rights 1. Available at https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1002&context=njihr. Accessed 28 Jan 2018
UN Commission on Human Rights, Draft resolution for an International Court on Human Rights / submitted by the representative of Australia, UN Doc. E/CN.4/15, UN 5 Feb 1947
UN General Assembly Resolution 60/147 of 16 Dec 2005
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2018 Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
About this entry
Cite this entry
Nowak, M. (2018). A World Court of Human Rights. In: Oberleitner, G. (eds) International Human Rights Institutions, Tribunals, and Courts. International Human Rights. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-5206-4_10
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-5206-4_10
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Singapore
Print ISBN: 978-981-10-5205-7
Online ISBN: 978-981-10-5206-4
eBook Packages: Law and CriminologyReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Business, Economics and Social Sciences