Abstract
In this chapter, the experience of production and cost analysis in transportation is reviewed. The key production and cost analysis needs of the sector can be identified providing strategic operational insight, establishing evidence as to which market and regulatory structures yield best outcomes and providing the evidence base for regulatory scrutiny either through yardstick competition or more formal price cap regulation. The upshot of this is that transportation has provided the motivation and illustration for many innovations within production, cost, and efficiency methods, and this chapter brings to life the issues and solutions found in the sector.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
- 1.
As of 2021, Road; previously the Office of Rail Regulation and prior to that the Office of the Rail Regulator.
- 2.
For notational convenience and consistency with other equations which do not distinguish between the network size variable and other outputs, the network size variable is treated as the mth output and so only the first m-1 output elasticities are used in the RtD equation (which excludes this output).
References
Caves DW, Christensen LR, Swanson JA (1981) Productivity growth, scale economies, and capacity utilisation in U.S. Railroads, 1955–74. Am Econ Rev 71(5):994–1002
Caves DW, Christensen LR, Tretheway MW (1984) Economies of density versus economies of scale: why trunk and local service airline costs differ. Rand J Econ 15(4):471–489
Farsi M, Filippini M, Greene WH (2005) Efficiency measurement in network industries: application to the Swiss railway companies. J Regul Econ 28(1):69–90
Filippini M, Greene W (2016) Persistent and transient productive inefficiency: a maximum simulated likelihood approach. J Prod Anal 45(2):187–196
Wheat P, Stead AD, Greene WH (2019) Robust stochastic frontier analysis: a student’s t-half normal model with application to highway maintenance costs in England. J Prod Anal 51(1):21–38
Nilsson J-E (2002) Restructuring Sweden’s railways: the unintentional de-regulation. Swed Econ Policy Rev 9:229–254
Shleifer A (1985) A theory of yardstick competition. RAND J Econ 16(3):319–327
Nash C, Nilsson J-E, Link H (2013) Comparing three models for introduction of competition into railways. JTEP 47(2):191–206
Hart O, Shleifer A, Vishny RW (1997) The proper scope of government: theory and an application to prisons. Q J Econ 112(4):1127–1161
ICAO (2013) Airport economics manual. Doc 9562, 3rd edn. International Civil Aviation Organization
Cherwony W, Mundle SR, Porter BD, Gleichman GR (1982) Review of bus costing procedures. Transp Res Rec 854:54–60
Stopher RP, Brandrup L, Lee B, Parry ST (1987) Development of a bus operating cost allocation model compatible with UMTA urban transportation planning system models. Transp Res Rec 1108:31–41
Sinner M, Weidmann U, Nash A (2018) Application of a cost-allocation model to Swiss bus and train lines. Transp Res Rec 2672(8):431–442. https://doi.org/10.1177/0361198118772702
Braeutigam RR (1999) Learning about transport costs. In: Gomez-Ibanez JA, Tye WB, Winston C (eds) Essays in transportation economics and policy: a handbook in honor of John R. Meyer. Brookings Institution Press, Washington, DC
Link H, Stuhlemmer A (DIW Berlin), Haraldsson M (VTI), Abrantes P, Wheat P, Iwnicki S, Nash C, Smith A, CATRIN (Cost Allocation of TRansport INfrastructure cost) (2008) Deliverable D 1, Cost allocation practices in the European Transport Sector. Funded by Sixth Framework Programme. VTI, Stockholm
Waters WG (1976) Statistical costing in transportation. Transp J 15(3):49–62
Taussig FW (1891) A contribution to the theory of railway rates. Q J Econ 5(4):438–465
Griliches Z (1972) Cost allocation in railroad regulation. Bell J Econ Manag Sci 3:26–41
Andrikopoulos A, Loizides J (1998) Cost structure and productivity growth in European railway systems. Appl Econ 30:1625–1639
Coelli T, Perelman S (1999) A comparison of parametric and non-parametric distance functions: with application to European Railways. Eur J Oper Res 117:326–339
Coelli T, Perelman S (2000) Technical efficiency of European Railways: a distance function approach. Appl Econ 32:1967–1976
Couto A, Graham DJ (2008) The contributions of technical and allocative efficiency to the economic performance of European Railways. Port Econ J 7:125–153
Cowie J, Riddington G (1996) Measuring the efficiency of European Railways. Appl Econ 28:1027–1035
Deprins D, Simar L (1989) Estimating technical inefficiencies with correction for environmental conditions. Ann Public Coop Econ 60:81–102
Gathon HJ, Perelman S (1992) Measuring technical efficiency in European Railways: a panel data approach. J Prod Anal 3:135–151
Gathon HJ, Pestieau P (1995) Decomposing efficiency into its managerial and its regulatory components: the case of European Railways. Eur J Oper Res 80:500–507
Ivaldi M, McCullough GJ (2001) Density and integration effects on class I U.S. freight railroads. J Regul Econ 19(2):161–182
Kumbhakar SC (1988a) Estimation of input-specific technical and allocative inefficiency in Stochastic Frontier models. Oxf Econ Pap 40(3):535–549
Kumbhakar SC (1988b) On the estimation of technical and allocative inefficiency using frontier functions: The case of U.S. Class I Railroads. Int Econ Rev 29(4):727–743
Kumbhakar SC, Orea L, Rodriguez-Alvarez A, Tsionas EG (2007) Do we estimate an input or an output distance function? An application of the mixture approach to European Railways. J Prod Anal 27:87–100
Lan LW, Lin ETJ (2006) Performance measurement for railway transport: stochastic distance functions with inefficiency and ineffectiveness effects. JTEP 40(3):383–408
Loizides J, Tsionas EG (2002) Productivity growth in European Railways: a new approach. Transp Res A 36(7):633–644
Parisio L (1999) A comparative analysis of European railroads efficiency: a cost frontier approach. Appl Econ 31:815–823
Cantos P, Villarroya J (2000) Efficiency, technical change and productivity in the European rail sector: a stochastic frontier approach. Int J Transp Econ 27(1):55–76
Cantos P, Villarroya J (2001) Regulation and efficiency: the case of European Railways. Transp Res A 35(5):459–472
Tsionas EG, Christopoulos DK (1999) Determinants of technical inefficiency in European Railways: simultaneous estimation of firm-specific and time-varying inefficiency. KONJUNKTURPOLITIK 45:240–256
Oum TH, Yu C (1994) Economic efficiency of railways and implications for public policy: a comparative study of the OECD countries’ railways. JTEP 28:121–138
Fielding GJ, Babitsky TT, Brenner ME (1985) Performance evaluation for bus transit. Transp Res 19A:73–82
Oum TH, Zhang Y (1997) A note on scale economies in transport. JTEP 31:309–315
Caves DW, Christensen LR, Tretheway MW, Windle RJ (1985) Network effects and the measurement of returns to scale and density for U.S. Railroads. In: Daughety AF (ed) Analytical studies in transport economics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 97–120
Spady RH, Friedlaender AF (1978) Hedonic cost functions for the regulated trucking industry. Bell J Econ 9(1):159–179
Bishop M, Thompson D (1992) Regulatory reform and productivity growth in the UK’s public utilities. Appl Econ 24:1181–1190
Wilson WW (1997) Cost savings and productivity in the railroad industry. J Regul Econ 11:21–40
Lee T, Baumel CP (1987) The cost structure of the U.S. Railroad industry under deregulation. J Transp Res Forum 27(1):245–253
Odolinski K, Smith ASJ (2016) Assessing the cost impact of competitive tendering in rail infrastructure maintenance services: evidence from the Swedish Reforms (1999 to 2011). JTEP 50(1):93–112
Johansson P, Nilsson JE (2002) An economic analysis of track maintenance costs, deliverable 10 Annex A3 of UNITE (UNIfication of accounts and marginal costs for Transport Efficiency), Funded by EU 5th Framework RTD Programme. ITS, University of Leeds, Leeds. Online: http://www.its.leeds.ac.uk/projects/unite/
Odolinski K, Nilsson J-E (2017) Estimating the marginal maintenance cost of rail infrastructure usage in Sweden; does more data make a difference? Econ Transp 10:8–17
Haraldsson M (2007) Essays on transport economics. Doctoral thesis, Uppsala University
Wheat P (2015) The sustainable freight railway: designing the freight vehicle-track system for higher delivered tonnage with improved availability at reduced cost SUSTRAIL, Deliverable 5.3: access charge final report annex 4, British Case Study
Odolinski K, Wheat P (2018) Dynamics in rail infrastructure provision: maintenance and renewal cost in Sweden. Econ Transp 14:21–30
Odolinski K, Wheat P (2021) Rail cost functions. In: Vickerman, Roger (eds.) International Encyclopedia of Transportation, 1:425–430, United Kingdom: Elsevier Ltd. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-102671-7.10080-6
Gaudry M, Lapeyre B, Quinet E (2016) Infrastructure maintenance, regeneration and service quality economics: a rail example. Transp Res B 86:181–210
Andersson M, Björklund G, Haraldsson M (2016) Marginal railway renewal costs: a survival data approach. Transp Res A 87:68–77
Andersson M, Smith A, Wikberg Å, Wheat P (2012) Estimating the marginal cost of railway track renewals using corner solution models. Transp Res A 46:954–964
Nilsson J-E, Svensson K, Haraldsson M (2015) Estimating the marginal costs for road infrastructure reinvestment. CTS working paper 2015:5. CTS
Wheat P, Smith ASJ, Nash CA (2009) CATRIN (Cost Allocation of TRansport INfrastructure cost), deliverable 8 – rail cost allocation for Europe. Funded by Sixth Framework Programme. Coordinated by VTI, Stockholm
Odolinski K (2019) Estimating the impact of traffic on rail infrastructure maintenance costs: the importance of axle loads. JTEP 53(3):258–274
Wheat P, Smith A (2008) Assessing the marginal infrastructure maintenance wear and tear costs for Britain’s Railway network. JTEP 42(2):189–224
Andersson M (2006) Marginal railway infrastructure cost estimates in the presence of unobserved effects. Case study 1.2D I Annex to Deliverable D 3 Marginal cost case studies for road and rail transport, Information Requirements for Monitoring Implementation of Social Marginal Cost Pricing, EU Sixth Framework Project GRACE (Generalisation of Research on Accounts and Cost Estimation)
Munduch G, Pfister A, Sögner L, Stiassny A (2002) Estimating marginal costs for the Austrian Railway system, working paper 78. Department of Economics, Vienna University of Economics and B.A, Vienna
Gaudry M, Quinet E (2003) Rail track wear-and-tear costs by traffic class in France. Universite de Montreal, Publication AJD-66
Marti M, Neuenschwander R (2006) Case study 1.2E: track maintenance costs in Switzerland, annex to GRACE (Generalisation of Research on Accounts and Cost Estimation) Deliverable D3: marginal cost case studies for road and rail transport. Funded by 6th Framework RTD Programme. Ecoplan, Berne
Kennedy J, Smith ASJ (2004) Assessing the efficient cost of sustaining Britain’s rail network: perspectives based on zonal comparisons. JTEP 38(2):157–190
Johansson P, Nilsson J (2004) An economic analysis of track maintenance costs. Transp Policy 11(3):277–286
Tervonen J, Idstrom T (2004) Marginal rail infrastructure costs in Finland 1997–2002. Report by the Finnish Rail Administration. Available at http://www.rhk.fi. Accessed 20 July 2005
Smith ASJ, Wheat PE, Nixon H (2008) International benchmarking of network rail’s maintenance and renewal costs, joint ITS, University of Leeds and ORR report written as part of PR2008, June 2008. Presentation available at http://www.rail-reg.gov.uk
Marti M, Neuenschwander R, Walker P (2009) CATRIN (cost allocation of transport infrastructure cost), Deliverable 8 Annex 1B – rail cost allocation for Europe: track maintenance and renewal costs in Switzerland. Funded by the Sixth Framework Programme. VTI, Stockholm
Smith ASJ, Wheat P (2012b) Estimation of cost inefficiency in panel data models with form specific and sub-company specific effects. J Prod Anal 37:27–40
NERA (2000) Review of Overseas Railway Efficiency: A Draft Final Report for the Office of the Rail Regulator. NERA, London
Smith ASJ, Walker P, Wheat PE, Guiraud L, Silavong C (2017) Estimating the marginal maintenance cost for the French railway network: a comparison of models. ITEA Conference, Barcelona, p 20
LEK (2003) Regional benchmarking: report to network rail. ORR and SRA, London
Office of Rail Regulation (2018) PR18 econometric top-down benchmarking of Network Rail, a report. http://orr.gov.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0011/27875/pr18-econometric-top-down-benchmarking-of-network-rail.pdf
Smith ASJ, Thiebaud JC, Wheat PE (2020) Efficiency analysis of the rail network in France. mimeo
International Union of Railways (UIC) (2008) Lasting infrastructure cost benchmarking (LICB). December 2008. Available at http://www.uic.org/IMG/pdf/li08C_sum_en.pdf. Accessed 20 Dec 2013
Smith ASJ, Wheat P (2010) Sensitivity analysis on the UIC harmonisation factors. Report for Rail Consult
Smith ASJ (2012) The application of stochastic frontier panel models in economic regulation: experience from the European rail sector. Transp Res E 48:503–515
Odolinski K (2015) Reforming a publicly owned monopoly: costs and incentives in railway maintenance. Doctoral dissertation, Örebro Studies in Economics 30
Affuso L, Angeriz A, Pollitt MG (2002) Measuring the efficiency of Britain’s privatised train operating companies. Regulation initiative discussion paper series, no: 48. London Business School
Affuso L, Angeriz A, Pollitt MG (2003) Measuring the efficiency of Britain’s privatised train operating companies. mimeo (unpublished version provided by the authors)
Cowie J (2009) The British passenger rail privatisation: conclusions on subsidy and efficiency from the first round of franchises. JTEP 43(1):85–104
Merkert R, Smith ASJ, Nash CA (2009) Benchmarking of train operating firms – a transaction cost efficiency analysis. J Transp Plann Technol 33(1):35–53
Cowie J (2002a) Subsidy and productivity in the privatised British passenger railway. Econ Issues 7(1):25–37, 38
Smith ASJ, Nash C, Wheat P (2009) Passenger rail franchising in Britain – has it been a success? Int J Transp Econ 36(1):33–62
Cowie J (2002b) The production economics of a vertically separated railway – the case of the British train operating companies. Trasporti Europei 20–21:96–103
Cowie J (2005) Technical efficiency versus technical change – the British passenger train operators. In: Hensher DA (ed) Competition and ownership in land passenger transport: selected refereed papers from the 8th international conference (Thredbo 8) Rio de Janeiro, September 2003. Elsevier, Amsterdam/London
Smith ASJ, Wheat P (2012a) Evaluating alternative policy responses to franchise failure: evidence from the passenger rail sector in Britain. JTEP 46(1):25–49
Small K, Winston C, Evans CA (1989) Road work: a new highway pricing and investment policy. The Brookings Institution, Washington, DC
Lindberg G (2002) Marginal costs of road maintenance for heavy goods vehicles on Swedish roads. Annex 2 to Deliverable 10, UNITE (UNIfication of accounts and marginal costs for Transport Efficiency), Research project funded by the Fifth EU Framework RTD Programme. ITS, University of Leeds, Leeds
Link H (2014) A cost function approach for measuring the marginal cost of road maintenance. JTEP 48(1):15–33
Yarmukhamedov S, Swärdh J-E (2016) Marginal cost of road maintenance and operation: Swedish estimates based on data from 2004 to 2014. VTI notat 15A-2016
Wheat PE (2013) Econometric cost analysis in vertically separated railways. PhD Thesis, University of Leeds. Available at: https://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/7459/
Wheat PE (2017) Scale, quality and efficiency in road maintenance: evidence for English local authorities. Transp Policy 59:46–53
Massiani J, Ragazzi G (2008) Costs and efficiency of highway concessionaires: a survey of Italian operators. Eur Transp 38:85–106
Welde M, Odeck J (2011) The efficiency of Norwegian road toll companies. Util Policy 19:162–171
Fritzsche C (2018) Analyzing the efficiency of county road production – evidence from Eastern German Counties. Ger Econ Rev 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1111/geer.12170
Kalb A (2014) What determines local governments’ cost-efficiency? The case of road maintenance. Reg Stud 48(9):1483–1498. https://doi.org/10.1080/00343404.2012.731044
Lyon B, Dwyer A (2011) Road maintenance: options for reform. Report. Infrastructure Partnerships Australia
ISTED (2002) La Lettre de I’STED, N26, October 2002
Arnek M (2002) Empirical essays on procurement and regulation. Doctoral thesis, Uppsala University
Smith ASJ, Wheat P, Wolanski M (2015) Public transport operations costs. In: Nash C (ed) Handbook of research methods and applications in transport economics and policy. Edward Elgar
Farsi M, Filippini M, Kuenzle M (2006) Cost efficiency in regional bus companies. JTEP 41(3):345–361
Bhattacharyya A, Kumbhakar SC, Bhattacharyya A (1995) Ownership structure and cost efficiency: a study of publicly owned passenger- bus transportation companies in India. J Prod Anal 6:47–61
Pickerl DH (1985) Rising deficits and the uses of transit subsidies in the United States. JTEP 19(3):281–298
Viton PA (1981) A translog cost function for urban bus transit. J Ind Econ 29(3):287–304
Bitzan JD, Peoples JH (2017) The economics of airport operations. Advances in airline economics, vol 6. Emerald Publishing
Bottasso A, Conti M (2017) The cost structure of the airport industry: methodological issues and empirical evidence. In: Bitzan JD, Peoples JH (eds) The economics of airport operations. Advances in airline economics. Emerald Publishing, pp 181–212
Martin JC, Voltes-Dorta A (2011) The econometric estimation of airports’ cost function. Transp Res B Methodol 45(1):112–127
Gillen DW, Oum TH, Tretheway MW (1990) Airline cost structure and policy implications: a multi-product approach for Canadian airlines. JTEP 24(1):9–34
Oum TH, Yu C (2001) Winning airlines: productivity and cost competitiveness of the world’s major airlines. Springer Science + Business Media, LLC
Yu C (2017) Airline productivity and efficiency: concept, measurement, and applications. In: Bitzan JD, Peoples JH, Wesley WW (eds) Airline efficiency. Advances in airline economics, vol 5. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp 11–53
Jara-Díaz SR, Cortés CE, Morales GA (2013) Explaining changes and trends in the airline industry: economies of density, multiproduct scale, and spatial scope. Transp Res E 60:13–26
Odolinski K, Nilsson J-E, Yarmukhamedov S, Haraldsson M (2020) The marginal cost of track renewals in the Swedish railway network: Using data to compare methods. Economics of Transportation 22:100170
Wheat PE, Smith ASJ (2015) Do the usual results of railway returns to scale and density hold in the case of heterogeneity in outputs: a hedonic cost function approach. J Transp Econ Policy 49(1):35–57
Christopoulos DK, Loizides J, Tsionas EG (2000) Measuring Input-Specific Technical Inefficiency In European Railways: A Panel Data Approach. International Journal of Transport Economics 27(2):147–171
Yarmukhamedov S, Smith ASJ, Thiebaud J-C (2020) Competitive tendering, ownership and cost efficiency in road maintenance services in Sweden: A panel data analysis. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice 136:194–204
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2022 Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
About this entry
Cite this entry
Wheat, P., Odolinski, K., Smith, A. (2022). Applications of Production Theory in Transportation. In: Ray, S.C., Chambers, R.G., Kumbhakar, S.C. (eds) Handbook of Production Economics. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-3455-8_39
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-3455-8_39
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Singapore
Print ISBN: 978-981-10-3454-1
Online ISBN: 978-981-10-3455-8
eBook Packages: Economics and FinanceReference Module Humanities and Social SciencesReference Module Business, Economics and Social Sciences