Abstract
On the basis of a number of illustrated case studies from Germany, Nepal, India, China, and Japan, a variety of aspects of authenticity are presented in as undogmatic a way as possible—from the primary importance of tangible material to intangible aspects connected with building rituals and craftsmanship, and practices of cyclic renewal. Factors such as spirit of place and architecture often outweigh archeological perspectives, which tend to freeze an object in time. Until recently, conservation and restoration strategies were based on principles often aspiring to the status of belief systems. The past two decades have confronted the heartlands of the conservation movement in the West with a variety of values rooted in the conviction that it is time to leave behind the ideology of Europe’s nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the obsession with patina and materiality. The incipient transcultural debate is in the process of transcending established borderlines and exploring the amazing similarities between “European”/”North American” and “Asian” ideas and strategies in connection with such values as identity or integrity.
Access this chapter
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
- 1.
Born 1923 in New York, Lowenthal is professor emeritus of geography at University College London. He read history at Harvard and geography at Berkeley, served in the US Army and the US State Department in 1945–1946 before becoming professor of geography at the University of California (1972–1985). His books The Past is a Foreign Country (Cambridge University Press, 1985) and Heritage Crusade and the Spoils of History (Cambridge University Press, 1998) have widened the scope of discussion on conservation issues. When in 2010 Stephens Randall published The Past Is No Foreign Country, Lowenthal reacted “to the wholesale perversion of history” by planning to revise his book for publication in 2012 and to retitle it The Past was a Foreign Country.
- 2.
Translated from German by Niels Gutschow: Man könnte auch sagen, die Kopie ist originaler als das Original, denn je älter ein Gebäude wird, desto mehr entfernt es sich vom ursprünglichen Zustand. Born in Korea, Han lives in Berlin and writes in German.
- 3.
“Deuvet-Nachrichten im Überblick,” Der Pendelwinker 6/1 (2007), 24.
- 4.
Quoted after Lupfer and Sigel 2000a, 29.
- 5.
Translations in the text by the author.
- 6.
Statement of the Landesamt für Denkmalpflege Sachsen-Anhalt Halle, 22 November 1999, cited in Mrass 2011.
- 7.
The case is presented here based on the MA thesis by Shaohua Zhang 2009. Zhang presents the historical background of the Stone Sutra Valley in exhaustive detail. The thesis documents and illustrates recent interventions and contains on-site interviews conducted in December 2008.
- 8.
“Zweck der Restaurierung solle vor allem das Erhalten sein; man solle das, was zerfallen will, vor weiterer Beschädigung behüten. Man solle es so herstellen, daß man deutlich erkenne, was an einem Bau alt und was neu sei, und man solle das, was man neu hinzufüge, auch stilistisch als neu kennzeichnen.” Cornelius Gurlitt in “Bericht des Ersten Tages für Denkmalpflege, 24–25. September 1900 in Dresden” (Berlin 1900), 51, quoted from Buttlar et al. 2011, 62.
- 9.
- 10.
Kennedy 2011, 6.
- 11.
The arguments set out in the following were advanced in a statement by Josef Wiedemann, dated 26 July 1961, see Wiedemann 1980, 388–390.
- 12.
Translations by the author.
- 13.
Ernst Mittig spoke of “Beweismittel für den Zweiten Weltkrieg” and Helmut Fußbroich of a “Denk- und Mahnmal,” see Hoven 1996.
- 14.
Arnold Wolff, the master builder of the cathedral, is quoted from “Dokumentation zur Diskussion um die Ziegelplombe am Nordturm des Kölner Domes (Pfeiler F 1 West) in den Jahren 1995 und 1996,” Cologne, April 1996.
- 15.
Ibid.
References
Adams, Douglas. 1985. The Original Hitchhiker Radio Scripts. Edited by Geoffrey Perkins. London: Pan Books.
Adams, Douglas and Mark Carwardine. 1990. Last Chance to See. London: Heinemann Ltd.
Buttlar, Adrian von, and Gabi Dolff-Bonekämper, Michael S. Falser, Achim Hubel, Georg Mörsch, Johannes Habich, eds. 2011. Denkmalpflege statt Attrappenkult. Basel: Birkhäuser Architektur.
Chung, Seung-Jin. 2005. “East Asian Values in Historic Conservation.” Journal of Architectural Conservation 1/11 (March): 55–70.
Dehio, Georg. 1988. “Was soll aus dem Heidelberger Schloß werden.” In Konservieren, nicht restaurieren. Streitschriften zur Denkmalpflege um 1900, edited by Georg Dehio and Alois Riegl, 34–42. Braunschweig: Friedr. Vieweg & Sohn (originally published 1902).
Deres, Thomas, and Martin Rüther. 1995. Fotografieren verboten! Heimliche Aufnahmen von der Zerstörung Kölns. Cologne: Emons Verlag.
“Deuvet-Nachrichten im Überblick.” 2007. Der Pendelwinker 6/1: 24–27.
“Dokumentation zur Diskussion um die Ziegelplombe am Nordturm des Kölner Domes (Pfeiler F 1 West) in den Jahren 1995 und 1996.” 1996 (April). Köln: Unpublished document.
Dvořák, Max. 1916. Katechismus der Denkmalpflege. Wien: J. Bard.
Eck, Diana. 1980. “Indian Tirthas: ‘Crossings’ in Sacred Geography.” History of Religions 20, 4: 323–344.
Enders, Siegfried and Niels Gutschow, eds. 1998. Hozon. Architectural and Urban Conservation in Japan. Stuttgart: Edition Axel Menges.
Fitch, James Marston. 1990. Historical Preservation. Curatorial Management of the Built World. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press (originally published 1982).
Frith, Stephen. 2008. “Ise and Ngunnhu: Intangible Memoria and the Authentic Copy.” In The Venice Charter Revisited: Modernism, Conservation and Tradition in the 21st Century, edited by Matthew Hardy, 682–693. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Gutschow, Niels. 1998. “Quest for the original state–reconstruction and restoration to an earlier state in Japanese conservation.” In Hozon. Architectural and Urban Conservation in Japan, edited by Siegfried Enders and Niels Gutschow, 28–87. Stuttgart: Edition Axel Menges, 1998.
Gutschow, Niels. 2010. “Towards a transcultural discourse in conservation and restoration. Review and outlook.” In Conservation and Preservation. Interactions between Theory and Practice. In memoriam Alois Riegl (1858–1905), edited by Michael S. Falser and Michael Lipp and Andrzej Tomaszewski, 11–17. Firenze: Editioni Polistampa.
Gutschow, Niels. 2011a. “Conservation Practice. A Conflict or Renewal of the Spirit of the Stupa?” In Light of the Valley. Renewing the Sacred Art and Traditions of Svayambhu, edited by Tsering Palmo Gellek and Padma Dorje Maitland, 32–41. Cazadero: Dharma Publishing.
Gutschow, Niels. 2011b. Architecture of the Newars. A History of Building Typologies and Details in Nepal. Chicago: Serindia Publications.
Han, Byung-Chul. 2011. Shanzai—Dekonstruktion auf Chinesisch. Berlin: Merve Verlag.
Henrichsen, Christoph. 2004. Holzkultur Japan. Bauten, Gegenstände, Techniken. Basel: Birkhäuser-Verlag für Architektur.
Hoven, Herbert. 1996. “Die störende Plombe.” Die Zeit, 9 February.
ICOMOS. 1965. “International Charter for the Conservation and Restoration of Monuments and Sites (Venice Charter).” Approved by the Second International Congress of Architects and Technicians of Historic Monuments in Venice from 25 to 31 May, 1964, adopted by ICOMOS in 1965. Accessed 5 November 2011, http://www.icomos.org/charters/venice_e.pdf, preamble.
ICOMOS. 2008. “Québec Declaration on the Preservation of the Spirit of Place.” Adopted at Québec, Canada, 4 October 2008. Accessed 10 October 2011, http://www.international.icomos.org/quebec2008/quebec_declaration/pdf/GA16_Quebec_Declaration_Final_EN.pdf
IUCN. 1987. “World Heritage Nomination, IUCN Summary (437: Mount Taishan Scenic Beauty and Historic Interest Zone, China).” UNESCO Advisory Body Evaluation 1987. Accessed 5 October 2011. http://whc.unesco.org/archive/advisory_body_evaluation/437.pdf.
Japanese Agency for Cultural Affairs and UNESCO. 2004. “Yamato Declaration on Integrated Approaches for Safeguarding Tangible and Intangible Cultural Heritage.” Approved at the International Conference on the Safeguarding of Tangible and Intangible Heritage, Nara, Japan, 20–23 October 2004. Accessed 11 October 2011, http://australia.icomos.org/wp-content/uploads/Yamato_Declaration.pdf
Jokilehto, Jukka. 1993. “Treatment and Authenticity.” In Management Guidelines for World Cultural Heritage Sites, edited by Bernard Feilden and Jukka Jokilehto, 59–75. Rome: ICCROM-UNESCO-ICOMOS.
Kennedy, Randy. 2011. “An Islamic Fantasia, Created by Authentic Craftsmen.” The New York Times, reprinted in Süddeutsche Zeitung, 28 March 2011: 6.
Lai, Guolong. 2005. “Cultural Identities in Modern China and the Politics of Orientalism.” In Architectural Imitations. Reproductions and Pastiches in East and West, edited by Wim Denslagen and Niels Gutschow, 231–259. Maastricht: Shaker Publications.
Lowenthal, David. 1994. “Criteria of Authenticity.” In Conference on Authenticity in Relation to the World Heritage Convention, edited by Knut Einar Larsen and Nils Marstein, 35–64. Bergen: Tapir Publishers.
Lowenthal, David, and Simon Jenkins. 2011. “Prizing the past for the present and the future.” In British Academy Review 18: 34–40.
Lupfer, Gilbert, and Paul Sigel. 2000a. “bauen bedeutet gestalten von lebensvorgängen.” In Architektur und Kunst. Das Meisterhaus Kandinsky-Klee in Dessau, edited by Norbert Michels, 9–34. Leipzig: E. A. Seemann Verlag.
Lupfer, Gilbert, and Paul Sigel. 2000b. “Baumonographie.” In Architektur und Kunst. Das Meisterhaus Kandinsky-Klee in Dessau, edited by Norbert Michels, 92–94. Leipzig: E. A. Seemann Verlag.
Marshall, John. 1923. Conservation Manual. A Handbook for the Use of Archaeological Officers and Others Entrusted with the Care of Ancient Monuments. Calcutta: Superintendent Government Printing, India.
Menon, A.G. Krishna. 1989. “Conservation in India, a search for direction.” Architecture + Design 11–12: 22–27.
Menon, A.G. Krishna. 1994. “Rethinking the Venice Charter: The Indian Experience.” South Asian Studies 10: 37–44.
Menon, A.G. Krishna. 2005. “Inventive Mimesis in New Dehli: The Temples in Chhattarpur.” In Architectural Imitations. Reproductions and Pastiches in East and West, edited by Wim Denslagen and Niels Gutschow, 98–123. Maastricht: Shaker Publishing.
Menon, A.G. Krishna. 2008. “The Afterlife of the Venice Charter in Postcolonial India.” In The Venice Charter Revisited: Modernism, Conservation and Tradition in the 21st Century, edited by Matthew Hardy, 16–23. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Michell, George. 1989. Monuments of India. Vol. 1: Buddhist, Jain, Hindu. London: Viking.
Mote, Frederick W. 1973. “A Millennium of Chinese Urban History: Form, Time and Space Concepts in Soochow.” Rice University Studies 59.4: 35–65.
Mrass, Marcus. 2011. “Nur eine Pause in der Existenz? Die Meisterhäuser in Dessau.” In DenkmalDebatten. Accessed 9 May 2011, http://denkmaldebatten.denkmalschutz.de/kontroversen/meisterhaeuser-dessau
Nitschke, Günter. 1964. “Die Metabolisten Japans.” Bauwelt 18/19: 499–515.
Nitschke, Günter. 1993. From Shinto to Ando. Studies in Architectural Anthropology in Japan. London: Academy Editions.
Riegl, Alois. 1903. Der Moderne Denkmalkultus: Sein Wesen und seine Entstehung. Vienna: Braumüller.
Ruskin, John. 1849. The Seven Lamps of Architecture. London: Smith, Elder, and Co., 65 Cornhill.
Ryckmans, Pierre. 2008. “The Chinese Attitude Towards the Past.” China Heritage Quarterly 14 (2008). Accessed 10 February 2012, http://www.chinaheritagequarterly.org/articles.php?searchterm=014_chineseAttitude.inc&issue=014. Originally published in Papers on Far Eastern History 39 (March) 1989: 1–16.
Schock-Werner, Barbara. 2005. 46. Dombaubericht. Köln: Verlag Kölner Dom.
Schock-Werner, Barbara. 2006. “47. Dombaubericht, von Oktober 2005 bis September 2006.” In Kölner Domblatt. Jahrbuch des Zentral-Dombau-Vereins 71, 9–60. Köln: Verlag Kölner Dom.
Schock-Werner, Barbara. 2008. 49. Dombaubericht. Köln: Verlag Kölner Dom.
Steinbach, Rudolf. 1948. “Die Alte Brücke in Heidelberg und die Problematik des Wiederaufbaus.” Baukunst und Werkform 2: 34–40.
Stovel, Herb. 2008. “Origins and Influence of the Nara Document on Authenticity.” APT Bulletin 39.2/3: 9–17.
Tange, Kenzo, and Noboru Kawazoe. 1965. Ise. Prototype of Japanese Architecture. Cambridge: M.I.T. Press (the Japanese version was originally published in 1962, Showa 37).
Thapar, Romila. 2004. Somanatha. The Many Voices of History. Delhi: Penguin Books.
Theophile, Erich, and Niels Gutschow, eds. 2003. The Sulima Pagoda. East Meets West in the Restoration of a Nepalese Temple. Trumbull: Weatherhill.
The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language. 2006. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Traeger, Jörg. 1992. “Zehn Thesen zum Wiederaufbau zerstörter Architektur.” Kunstchronik 45/12: 629–633.
Tschudi-Madsen, Stefan. 1985. “Principles in Practice.” Association for Preservation Technology International (APT) Bulletin, 17/3–4: 17–19.
UNESCO. 2005. “Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention.” Paris, 2 February 2005. Accessed 3 March 2011. http://whc.unesco.org/archive/opguide05-en.pdf
Vierneisel, Klaus. 1980. “Ein Nachwort zur heutigen Glyptothek.” In Glyptothek München 1830–1980. Jubiläumsausstellung zur Entstehungs- und Baugeschichte, edited by Klaus Vierneisel and Gottlieb Leinz, 398–402. München: Prestel Verlag.
Viollet-le-Duc, Eugène-Emmanuel. 1990. The Foundations of Architecture. New York: Braziller (originally published 1854).
Wiedemann, Josef. 1980. “Der Innenausbau der Glyptothek nach der Zerstörung.” In Glyptothek München 1830–1980. Jubiläumsausstellung zur Entstehungs- und Baugeschichte, edited by Klaus Vierneisel and Gottlieb Leinz, 386–397. München: Prestel Verlag.
Zhang, Shaohua. 2009. “Die Schutzprojekte im Steinsutratal am Taishan.” Master’s Thesis, University of Heidelberg.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2017 Springer International Publishing Switzerland
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Gutschow, N. (2017). Architectural Heritage Conservation in South and East Asia and in Europe: Contemporary Practices. In: Weiler, K., Gutschow, N. (eds) Authenticity in Architectural Heritage Conservation. Transcultural Research – Heidelberg Studies on Asia and Europe in a Global Context. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-30523-3_1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-30523-3_1
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-319-30522-6
Online ISBN: 978-3-319-30523-3
eBook Packages: Social SciencesSocial Sciences (R0)