Abstract
This article initially analyzes Pierre Duhem’s incursions in the direction of medieval science, delineating both (a) the genesis of historiographic research brought about by his discoveries regarding medieval statics, which occurred at the end of 1903, and (b) his persistence in that direction resulting from a new set of discoveries, this time associated to medieval dynamics and the names of John Buridan and Nicole Oresme, which occurred in mid-1908. In a second moment, the article argues that the Duhemian thinking supports itself on a philosophic vision of historical development present ever since the beginning, in 1892, of his epistemological publications. It underscores that his philosophy of history, essential for sustaining an understanding of the methodology itself, is (a) optimistic insofar as it reveals that the historical events are ruled by a providence that makes even the sincere errors of the theoreticians fruitful and that (b) the author embraces a teleological, almost determinist conception of historical evolution as being governed by laws that make predictions of the future of theories possible. Lastly, based on the preceding considerations, the intention is to draft a synthetic and coherent position regarding the supposed (dis)continuism attributed to our historian.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Agassi J (1967/2008) Towards an historiography of science. In: Agassi J (ed) Science and its history: a reassessment of the historiography of science. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 119–242
Biard J (2004) Le rôle des condamnations de 1277 dans le développement de la physique selon Pierre Duhem. Rev Quest Sci 175(1):15–36
Brenner A (1990) Duhem: Science, réalité et apparence. La relation entre philosophie et histoire dans l’oeuvre de Pierre Duhem. J. Vrin, Paris
Brenner A (2004) Genèse, évolution et continuité du développement scientifique selon Pierre Duhem. Rev Quest Sci 175(1):37–58
Canguilhem G (1968) Études d’histoire et de philosophie des sciences. Vrin, Paris
Chiappin J (1989) Duhem’s theory of science: An interplay between philosophy and history of science. PhD Thesis. University of Pittsburgh, Pittsbugh
Duhem P (1892/1996) Some reflections on the subject of physical theories. In: Essays in the history and philosophy of science (ed and trans: Ariew, R, Barker P). Hackett, Indianapolis/Cambridge, pp 1–28
Duhem P (1893) Introduction à la mécanique chimique. Georges Carré, Paris
Duhem P (1894) Les théories de l’optique. Rev Deux Mondes 4(123):94–125
Duhem P (1895/2002) Theories of heat. In: Mixture and chemical combination and related essays (ed and trans: Needham P). Springer, Dordrecht, pp 121–191
Duhem P (1896/2002) The evolution of physical theories from the Seventeenth Century to our day. In: Mixture and chemical combination and related essays, (ed and trans: Needham P). Springer, Dordrecht, pp 193–213
Duhem P (1898/2002) The phase law. In: Mixture and chemical combination and related essays (ed and trans: Needham P). Springer, Dordrecht, pp 235–251
Duhem P (1899) Usines et laboratoires. Rev Philomatique de Bordeaux et du Sud-Ouest 2(9):385–400
Duhem P (1900) Théorie et pratique. Rev Philomathique de Bordeaux et du Sud-Ouest 3(6):250–262
Duhem P (1902a) Les théories électriques de J. Clerk Maxwell: Étude historique et critique. Hermann, Paris
Duhem P (1902b) Mixture and chemical combination. In Mixture and chemical combination and related essays (ed and trans: Needham P). Springer, Dordrecht, pp 2–118
Duhem P (1903) L’évolution de la mécanique. Joanin, Paris
Duhem P (1904) De l’accélération produite par une force constante: Notes pour servir a l’histoire de la dynamique. In: Claparède É (ed) Rapports et comptes rendus du deuxième congrès international de philosophie tenu à Genève du 4 au 8 septembre 1904. Henry Kündig, Genève, pp 859–915
Duhem P (1905a) Paul Tannery. Rev Philos 5(1):216–230
Duhem P (1905b) Physics of a believer. In: Duhem P (ed) The aim and structure of physical theory (trans: Wiener P). Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 273–311
Duhem P (1905–1906/1991) The origins of statics: The sources of physical theory (trans: Leneaux G, Vagliente V and Wagener G). Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London
Duhem P (1906) Le P. Marin Mersenne et la pesanteur de l’air: Le P. Mersenne et le poids spécifique de l’air. Rev Gén Sci Pures Appl 17:769–782
Duhem P (1906–1913/1984) Études sur Léonard de Vinci: Ceux qu’il a lus et ceux qui l’ont lu. Éditions des Archives Contemporaines, Paris
Duhem P (1907) Compte rendu de Josiah-Willard Gibbs: “the scientific papers”. Bull Sci Math 31:181–211
Duhem P (1908/1969) To save the phenomena: An essay on the idea of physical theory from Plato to Galileo (trans: Doland E and Maschler C). The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Duhem P (1909a) Le mouvement absolu et le mouvement relatif. Librairie de Montligeon, Montligeon
Duhem P (1909b) Un précurseur français de Copernic: Nicole Oresme (1377). Rev Gén Sci Pures Appl 20:866–873
Duhem P (1911/1996) History of physics. In: Ariew R, Barker P (eds) Essays in the history and philosophy of science. Hackett, Indianapolis, pp 163–221
Duhem P (1912) Préface. In: Maire A (ed) L’oeuvre scientifique de Blaise Pascal: Bibliographie critique et analyse de tous les travaux qui s’y rapportent. Hermann, Paris, pp i–ix
Duhem P (1913) Lettre accompagnant le don de la troisième série des “Études sur Léonard de Vinci” à l’Académie des Sciences. C R Hebd Seances Acad Sci 157(14):535–538
Duhem P (1913–1959) Le système du monde: Histoire des doctrines cosmologiques de Platon. 10 v. Hermann, Paris
Duhem P (1914/1991) The aim and structure of physical theory (trans: Wiener P). Princenton University Press, Princenton
Duhem P (1915/1991) German science (trans: Lyon J). Open Court, La Salle
Duhem P (1916a) La chimie est-elle une science française? Hermann, Paris
Duhem P (1916b) Lettre accompagnant le don du quatrième tome du “Système du monde: Histoire des doctrines cosmologiques de Platon à Copernic” à l’Académie des Sciences. C R Hebd Seances Acad Sci 162(18):666–670
Duhem P (1917) Notices sur les titres et travaux scientifiques de Pierre Duhem. Gauthier-Villars, Paris
Duhem P (1919) De Maxwell et de la manière allemande de l’exposer. La Revue du Mois 20(115):113–131
Jaki S (1984) Uneasy genius: the life and work of Pierre Duhem. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, The Hague/Boston/Lancaster/Dordrecht
Koyré A (1961) La révolution astronomique: Copernic, Kepler, Borelli. Hermann, Paris
Leite F (2012) Um estudo sobre a filosofia da história e sobre a historiografia da ciência de Pierre Duhem. PhD Thesis. Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo
Leite F (2015) A gênese e a persistência do historiador medieval – O caso de Pierre Duhem. Rev Bras Hist Ciênc 8(1):26–43
Leite F (2016) Um Argumento a Favor da Existência de Deus Formulado por Pierre Duhem. Trans/Form/Ação 39(4):33–58
Lemonnier H (1917) Les “Études” de Pierre Duhem sur Léonard de Vinci. J Savants 15:25–34
Maiocchi R (1985) Chimica e filosofia: Scienza, epistemologia, storia e religione nell’opera di Pierre Duhem. La Nuova Italia, Firenze
Martin RND (1991) Pierre Duhem: philosophy and history in the work of a believing physicist. Open Court, La Salle
Mentré F (1904) La simultanéité des découvertes scientifiques. Rev Sci 41(2):555–559
Patapievici H-R (2015) The “Pierre Duhem thesis”: a reappraisal of Duhem’s discovery of the physics of the middle ages. Logos Episteme 6(2):201–218
Stoffel J-F (2002) Le phénoménalisme problématique de Pierre Duhem. Académie Royale de Belgique, Bruxelles
Stoffel J-F (2017) L’“Histoire de la physique” de Pierre Duhem: Contexte d’une publication singulière et historique de l’usage du terme “révolution”. In: Stoffel J-F (ed) Pierre Duhem, cent ans plus tard (1916–2016). Université de Tunis, Tunis, pp 271–300
Tannery P (1887a) La géométrie grecque: Comment son histoire nous est parvenue et ce que nous en savons. Gauthier-Villars, Paris
Tannery P (1887b/1930) Pour l’histoire de la science hellène: De Thalès à Empédocle. Gauthier-Villars, Paris
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2023 Springer Nature Switzerland AG
About this entry
Cite this entry
Leite, F.R. (2023). Pierre Duhem: Between the Historiography of Science and Philosophy of History. In: Condé, M.L., Salomon, M. (eds) Handbook for the Historiography of Science. Historiographies of Science. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-99498-3_1-1
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-99498-3_1-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Publisher Name: Springer, Cham
Print ISBN: 978-3-030-99498-3
Online ISBN: 978-3-030-99498-3
eBook Packages: Springer Reference Humanities, Soc. Sciences and Law
Publish with us
Chapter history
-
Latest
Pierre Duhem: Between the Historiography of Science and Philosophy of History- Published:
- 21 July 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-99498-3_1-2
-
Original
Pierre Duhem: Between the Historiography of Science and Philosophy of History- Published:
- 30 May 2023
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-99498-3_1-1