Abstract
This chapter considers the place of law in current political debates about how best to address problems of social justice, with particular reference to sex/gender and sexuality. In examining recent ‘moments’ of successful law reform around issues of sex/gender and sexuality, I will argue that the contemporary thirst for law as a route to equality does not address deeper, more structural questions of inequality. Accommodation and assimilation of ‘others’ within the existing legal system will always leave open the question of what social justice could look like were it not understood autopoietically — solely and self-referentially within the confines of existing frameworks of legal rights and responsibilities. What is more, recent moments of sex/gender and sexuality law reform tell us something not only about the gap between law and ‘the social’ but also about the power of law and legal techniques. In this chapter I will explore what happens when, first, legal tools are used to adapt existing doctrinal approaches to include — co-opt — those who previously have fallen outwith the protection of the law; and second, how such techniques fail to deliver justice, despite the good intentions of those who aim for equality (albeit without the kind of radical rethinking that activists and critical scholars might desire).
Preview
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams, R (2013) ‘Unequal Marriage? How the “Spousal Veto” Harms Transgender People’ Huffington Post 9 July 2013 www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/richard-adams/unequal-marriage-and-transgenders_b_3560849.html
Auchmuty, R (2012) ‘Law and the Power of Feminism: How Marriage Lost Its Power to Oppress Women’ 20(2) Feminist Legal Studies 71–87
Barker, N (2013) Not the Marrying Kind: A Feminist Critique of Same-Sex Marriage (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan)
Barlow, J and M Mason (2013) ‘All Marriages Are Equal… But Some Are More Equal Than Others’ New Law Journal, 26 July 2013
Boyd, S and C Young (2006) ‘Losing the Feminist Voice? Debates on the Legal Recognition of Same Sex Partnerships in Canada’ 14 Feminist Legal Studies 213–40
Brown, W (1995) States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity (Princeton: Princeton University Press)
Butler, J (1993) Bodies that Matter: On the Discursive Limits of ‘Sex’ (New York: Routledge)
Charles, C (2012) Critical Queer Studies: Law, Film, and Fiction in Contemporary American Culture (Farnham: Ashgate)
Cowan, S (2007) ‘Freedom and Capacity to Make a Choice: A feminist Analysis Of consent in the Criminal Law of Rape’ in V Munro and C Stychin (eds), Sexuality and the Law: Feminist Engagements, (London: Glasshouse Press/ Routledge-Cavendish), pp. 51–71
Cowan, S (2008) ‘The Headscarf Controversy: A Response to Jill Marshall’ 14(3) Res Publica 193–201
Cowan, S, R Sandland and A Sharpe (2009) ‘Debate and Dialogue: The Gender Recognition Act’ 18(2) Social and Legal Studies 241–63
Craig, E (2013) ‘The Case for the Federation of Law Societies Rejecting Trinity Western University’s Proposed Law Degree Program’ 25(1) Canadian Journal of Women and the Law 148–170
Currah, P (2002–2003) ‘The Transgender Rights Imaginary’ 4 Georgetown Journal of Gender and the Law 705
Daly, K (2002) ‘Sexual Assault and Restorative Justice’ in H Strang and J Braithwaite (eds), Restorative Justice and Family Violence (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
Du Toit, L (2007) ‘The Conditions of Consent’ in R Hunter and S Cowan (eds), Choice and Consent: Feminist Engagements with Law and Subjectivity (London: Taylor & Francis)
Eaton, M (1994) ‘Lesbians, Gays and the Struggle for Equality Rights: Reversing the Progressive Hypothesis’ 17 Dalhousie Law Journal 130
Ellison, L and V Munro (2009a) ‘Reacting to Rape: Exploring Mock Jurors’ Assessments of Complainant Credibility’ 49 (2) British Journal of Criminology 202–19
Ellison, L and V Munro (2009b) ‘Of “Normal Sex” and “Real Rape”: Exploring The Use of Socio-Sexual Scripts in (Mock) Jury Deliberation’ 18(3) Social Legal Studies 291–312
Friedson, A (2013) Blind to Sameness: Sexpectations and the Social Construction of Male and Female Bodies (Chicago: University of Chicago Press)
Gotell, L (2007) ‘The Discursive Disappearance of Sexualized Violence: Feminist Law Reform, Judicial Resistance, and Neo-Liberal Sexual Citizenship’ in
D E Chunn, S B Boyd and H Lessard (eds), Reaction and Resistance: Feminism, Law and Social Change (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press)
Gotell, L (2010) ‘Canadian Sexual Assault Law: Neoliberalism and the Erosion of Feminist-inspired Law Reforms’ in C McGlynn and V Munro (eds), Rethinking Rape Law: International and Comparative Perspectives (London: Routledge), pp. 209–23
Gotell, L (2013) ‘Carceral Feminisms’ paper presented at the Canadian Law and Society Association Conference, Vancouver, 2–3 July 2013
Halberstam, J (2011) The Queer Art of Failure (Durham: Duke University Press)
Halley, J (2003) ‘Gender, Sexuality and Power: Is Feminist Theory Enough?’ (Parts III and VII) 12 Columbia Journal of Gender and Law 610–37
Hillyard, P (2014) ‘Critique and Reaction: Zemiology’s challenge to Criminology’ paper presented to the Legal Theory Spring Workshop, University of Edinburgh, 29 May 2014
Hudson, B (1998) ‘Restorative Justice: The Challenge of Sexual and Racial Violence’ 25(2) Journal of Law and Society 237–56
Joey (2013) ‘The Gay Agenda: How the Corporate Media Fails Queers’ 112 Slingshot 8
Kingdom, E (1991) What’s Wrong with Rights? (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press)
Larcombe, W (2011) ‘Falling Rape Conviction Rates: (Some) Feminist Aims and Measures for Rape Law’ 19(1) Feminist Legal Studies 27–45
Leckey, R (2014) ‘States of Identity’ paper presented at Who Are We?: The Quest for Identity in Law Conference, University of Dalhousie, Canada, 20–1 October 2014
Lenon, S (2005) ‘Marrying Citizens! Raced Subjects? Rethinking the Terrain of Equal Marriage Discourse’ 17 Canadian Journal of Women and the Law 405–21
McGlynn, C (2010) ‘Feminist Activism and Rape Law Reform in England and Wales: A Sisyphean Struggle?’ in C McGlynn and V Munro (eds), Rethinking Rape Law: International and Comparative Perspectives (London: Routledge-Cavendish)
McGlynn, C and V Munro (eds) (2010) Rethinking Rape Law: International and Comparative Perspectives (London: Routledge-Cavendish)
Miller, S and L Iovanni (2013) ‘Using Restorative Justice for Gendered Violence: Success with a Postconviction Model’ 8(4) Feminist Criminology 247–68
Mossman, M J (1987) ‘Feminism and Legal Method: The Difference It Makes’ 3 Wisconsin Women’s Law Journal 147–68
Namaste, V (2000) Invisible Lives: The Erasure of Transsexual and Transgendered People (Chicago: University of Chicago Press)
Newman, D (2013) ‘On The Trinity Western University Controversy: An Argument for a Christian Law School in Canada’ (2013) 22(3) Constitutional Forum/Forum constitutionnel 1–14
Pothier, D (2013) ‘An Argument against Accreditation of Trinity Western University’s Proposed Law School’ (2014) 23(1) Constitutional Forum/Forum constitutionnel 1–7
Reece, H (2013) ‘Rape Myths: Is Elite Opinion Right and Popular Opinion Wrong?’ Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 1–29
Riles, A (2005) ‘A New Agenda for the Cultural Study of Law: Taking on the Technicalities’ 53 Buffalo Law Review 973–1033
Scales, A (1986) ‘The Emergence of Feminist Jurisprudence: An Essay’ 95 Yale Law Journal 1373–403
Sharpe, A (2013), ‘We Must Not Uphold Gender Norms at the Expense of Human Dignity: Sexual Intimacy, Gender Variance and Criminal Law’ New Statesman, May 2013
Smart, C (1984) The Ties that Bind (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul)
Smart, C (1989) Feminism and the Power of Law (London: Routledge)
Smart, C (2012) ‘Reflection’ 20(2) Feminist Legal Studies 161–5
Snider, L (1990) ‘The Potential of the Criminal Justice System to Promote Feminist Concerns’ 10 Studies in Law Politics and Society: A Research Annual 143–73
Snider, L (1998) ‘Towards Safer Societies: Punishment, Masculinities and Violence against Women’ 38(1) British Journal of Criminology 1–39
Spade, D (2011) Normal Life: Administrative Violence, Critical Trans Politics and the Limits of Law (Brooklyn: South End Press)
Spencer, J (2004) ‘The Sexual Offences Act 2003: Child and Family Offences’ Criminal Law Review 328–60
Temkin, J and B Krahé (2008) Sexual Assault and the Justice Gap: A Question of Attitude (Oxford: Hart Publishing)
Westmarland, N and G Gangoli (2011) International Approaches to Rape (Bristol: Policy Press)
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Copyright information
© 2016 Sharon Cowan
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Cowan, S. (2016). Sex/Gender Equality: Taking a Break from the Legal to Transform the Social. In: Cowan, D., Wincott, D. (eds) Exploring the ‘Legal’ in Socio-Legal Studies. Palgrave Macmillan Socio-Legal Studies. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-137-34437-3_6
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-137-34437-3_6
Publisher Name: Palgrave Macmillan, London
Print ISBN: 978-1-349-56054-7
Online ISBN: 978-1-137-34437-3
eBook Packages: Social SciencesSocial Sciences (R0)